Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
570 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, detail-oriented, friendly, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Elise was knowledgeable, patient, diligent
almost 6 years ago
Elise was knowledgeable, patient, diligent

Elise was knowledgeable, patient, diligent. She handled the process like a professional and didn’t make it feel like just another transaction. We welcome her into our home not just as an agent but as a friend. We look forward to working with her in the future.

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise Fay and her team at Sibbach/ Exp Realty are a dedicated group of real estate professionals
almost 6 years ago
Elise Fay and her team at Sibbach/ Exp Realty are a dedicated group of real estate professionals

Elise Fay and her team at Sibbach/ Exp Realty are a dedicated group of real estate professionals. They have someone specific assigned to each phase of the selling process. Elise was able to walk with me down the renovation path and then get my home on the market and sold in less than 60 days.. we listed on May 16th amidst the COVID environment and came to a successful close of escrow on 7/2/2020. While the Sibbach team was very professional and helpful I give all the Glory to God who found me a buyer that absolutely loves my home .. just as much as I did! Thank you Elise for being a wonderful realtor. You are the best!

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was great to work with and her professional experience was helpful in making decisions selling
almost 6 years ago
Elise was great to work with and her professional experience was helpful in making decisions selling

Elise was great to work with and her professional experience was helpful in making decisions selling our home. I felt her knowledge about our area was a big advantage as well as being with a quality team. The home was listed for only a short time frame and at the final stages she provided a breakdown of the offers making them easy to understand and evaluate. We would be happy to recommend Elise to anyone.

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was great to work with!
almost 6 years ago
Elise was great to work with!

Elise was great to work with and her professional experience was helpful in making decisions selling our home. I felt her knowledge about our area was a big advantage as well as being with a quality team. The home was listed for only a short time frame and at the final stages she provided a breakdown of the offers making them easy to understand and evaluate. We would be happy to recommend Elise to anyone.

Elise Fay
Seller review
She treated us like family. We could not imagine having a better experience finding our home.
almost 6 years ago
She treated us like family. We could not imagine having a better experience finding our home.

Ilene was the perfect agent for our family. We are from the east coast and she knew everything about her area. She treated us like family. We could not imagine having a better experience finding our home. We have a 4 year old who went to every home with us. This might be a challenge to some, but Ilene handling our son perfectly. He became part of her "team" and she made him happy and comfortable the entire process. We know that we will use Ilene for all our future real estate transactions. Ilene is a true professional and we would recommend her without hesitation.

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
Where do I even start as the words I write here will fail to adequately convey the tremendous job Il
about 6 years ago
Where do I even start as the words I write here will fail to adequately convey the tremendous job Il

Where do I even start as the words I write here will fail to adequately convey the tremendous job Ilene did for my husband and I. We contacted Ilene when we knew we’d be relocating from Iowa so from the start she was faced with that extra challenge since we were not familiar with Arizona. She obviously read and listened to every detail of what we were looking for because it only took one weekend for us to find not only the perfect area but the perfect builder for us! We are not always easy to please but that goes to show the skills she has and how truly wonderful she is at what she does. She was not only a wealth of knowledge regarding real estate and builders but also on AZ areas. She took the extra time to drive around and show us different things she knew we’d be interested in and gave us helpful tips and advise. We truly never could have built a home from IA without having Ilene on our side. She was our voice during the build as well as our eyes. She took countless pictures and videos as things progressed and was truly was just as excited through it all as we were. We were at ease the whole time knowing we had Ilene on our side. We truly could not be happier in our Class new home in AZ! What makes Ilene even more special is she continues to show her support, and how much she truly cares, by doing things to help us feel welcomed and more settled in our house long after we have closed! It’s with great pleasure to say Ilene Is someone we consider to be our dear friend! If you are in the market for a new home Ilene is who you want on your side!!

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
This was my first time buying a house and I had no idea what any part of the process entailed
about 6 years ago
This was my first time buying a house and I had no idea what any part of the process entailed

This was my first time buying a house and I had no idea what any part of the process entailed. Elise was very thorough and honest with me from the start, and was never pushy. She found the perfect house for me and walked me through every step of the way and immediately took care of any issues that came up. I felt like I had a personal assistant rather an a realtor because she was that attentive and helpful. I could text her at any time of the day and she would be on it. Elise also has great connections with excellent inspectors, brokers, handymen, painters, and pool guys. She is not only an excellent realtor with a sharp eye and knowledge of the area, she is a genuinely great person. There is nothing that she could have done better throughout working with me, and I highly recommend her to anyone and everyone. Thank you for helping me get my dream first house Elise!

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise is such a wonderful realtor
about 6 years ago
Elise is such a wonderful realtor

Elise is such a wonderful realtor. Very professional, knowledgeable and always is there to answer any questions throughout the home selling experience. We are so happy to have listed our home with Elise and her team. She helped us with final prep details and pointed out several things that really helped our listing stand out. We were under contract within 2 days of our open house and closed just a few short weeks later! We highly recommend Elise.

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise Fay-What an amazing realtor and fabulous person
about 6 years ago
Elise Fay-What an amazing realtor and fabulous person

Elise Fay. What an amazing realtor and fabulous person! At our initial meeting Elise made solid suggestions regarding updates needed to our home before listing. We followed her advice and it paid dividends. She was always available to answer questions and kept us updated through each step of the sales process. We are thrilled and satisfied with the sale of our home and we would rate Elise 10+ for making it all happen.

Elise Fay
Seller review
After having met Ilene, it was as if we had already been friends and knew her already
about 6 years ago
After having met Ilene, it was as if we had already been friends and knew her already

After having met Ilene, it was as if we had already been friends and knew her already. She is a special kind of human being and works extremely hard for her clients. She's responsive and always positive. Although we had some bumps in the road, she definitely made it more bearable. I would highly recommend her to anyone needing a realtor. You will not get anyone more dedicated, knowledgeable and helpful than her. I value her expertise and now consider her a friend. Cheers and happy house hunting with the best, Ilene McKenna. -The Hommel's

Ilene McKenna
409 - 420 of 570
Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
Contact Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent