Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
307 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, friendly, responsive, honest, well-prepared, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent & Confident
9 months ago
Excellent & Confident

Toot was a wonderful help when assisting with preparing, staging and showing our home for our sale. She was excellent at communicating what would help and what would not (from pricing, staging and overall appeal). Even when it was a slow start to selling our home, she continued to be confident with us to stay the course, she remained active and persistent with showings and advice on what steps would help us reach out goal of selling. We always felt very comfortable approaching her with our thoughts/concerns as well as her ability to communicate tougher subjects effectively that would help us sell our home. Overall, we thoroughly enjoyed having her help with this whole process and will continue to return back to her with any home purchases/sales in the future.

Toot Penovich

Toot Penovich

  5   (55 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic Agent!
9 months ago
Fantastic Agent!

Mary did a fantastic job for our family. Selling property with siblings can be difficult and Mary knew how to deal with all of the ins and outs of a complicated deal with multiple sellers. She knows the market and was able to direct us throughout the transaction to a wonderful outcome. Would recommend her to anyone!!

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Buyer review
As first-time homebuyers, my fiancé and I were equal parts excited and terrified—kind of like riding
10 months ago
As first-time homebuyers, my fiancé and I were equal parts excited and terrified—kind of like riding

As first-time homebuyers, my fiancé and I were equal parts excited and terrified—kind of like riding a roller coaster you can’t get off until the paperwork’s done. Tracy was the perfect guide through the chaos. She’s personable, easy to talk to, and asked all the right questions to help us figure out what actually mattered to us (spoiler: good windows are apparently a bigger deal than we thought). Even though we did a lot of the online house hunting ourselves, Tracy’s feedback was pure gold. She spotted red flags we would have completely missed and always shared her take on the market so we didn’t accidentally overpay or fall in love with a money pit. Her mix of expertise and common sense kept us grounded while still letting us dream. What really set Tracy apart was her availability and patience with our many “rookie” questions—some of which were probably more entertaining than helpful. She never made us feel rushed, and her advice always came with just the right balance of professionalism and warmth. We’re now happily in our first home, and Tracy’s the reason the process felt a lot less like an anxiety inducing process and more like a very exciting (and successful) adventure. Thank you, Tracy!! Come over for burgers anytime;)

Tracy Yndestad

Tracy Yndestad

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Toot is the Best!
10 months ago
Toot is the Best!

We were referred to Toot from a friend and the experience was wonderful from start to finish. She’s so warm, kind, and helps guide you through the entire selling process. I was so worried selling our first home would be super stressful, but Toot made the whole process easy and seamless, and it felt like we were leaving with a new friend. I was told she’s the best and she lived up to that (and more)!

Toot Penovich

Toot Penovich

  5   (55 reviews)
Buyer review
The best realtor you'll ever find
10 months ago
The best realtor you'll ever find

Toot is exceptional. From Day 1 when we met her at someone else's showing, to finding us a dream home, to selling our home, you can't do better than Toot. She walked us through every step, worked endless hours doing paperwork and getting our buying process to be easy and painless. Communication was perfect, quick to answer questions and her knowledge of the market is superior. Plus, Toot is genuine. She really cares for her clients, who become friends to her. Such a warm hospitable personality and honest character, a refreshing change from a chaotic world!

Toot Penovich

Toot Penovich

  5   (55 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent
10 months ago
Excellent

She was honest, straightforward and always had a plan in a long and frustrating sale

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Seller review
Absolutely Perfect!!!
10 months ago
Absolutely Perfect!!!

Mary is extremely knowledgeable and by far the best realtor I’ve ever used - period. She took care of two very difficult situations with the utmost professionalism. Mary was on top of every aspect of our sale throughout the process until the finish line. I would not recommend anyone else. She’s number one #1 in my book!!!!!!

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Seller review
Mary was very knowledgeable with the every aspect of the industry!
10 months ago
Mary was very knowledgeable with the every aspect of the industry!

We knew right away after meeting with Mary that she was the one that we wanted to represent us on selling all 3 of our homes! She was very thorough and made us feel comfortable moving forward with selling our homes!

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Buyer review
Made my first home buying experience wonderful.
10 months ago
Made my first home buying experience wonderful.

Mary made my first home buying experience as stress free as possible. She was there with me, answering my questions and helping me through every step of the way. She’s also super prompt with communication. I could not have asked for a better experience with the biggest purchase of my life.

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Seller review
A Truly Family-Like Experience
10 months ago
A Truly Family-Like Experience

From the very beginning, we felt like more than just clients—we felt like family. Mary went above and beyond to make the entire process of selling our home smooth, stress-free, and even enjoyable. Communication was outstanding every step of the way. We were always kept in the loop, and every question we had (big or small) was answered with patience and clarity. What really stood out was the genuine care and dedication shown throughout the sale. We never felt rushed or pressured—just supported. The attention to detail, market knowledge, and strategic guidance made a huge difference in getting our home sold quickly and at a great price. We’re so grateful for the experience and would wholeheartedly recommend Mary to anyone looking for someone who treats you like family and delivers exceptional results.

Thunder Homes

Thunder Homes

  4.9   (54 reviews)
Seller review
Remarkable and Professional
11 months ago
Remarkable and Professional

Lori provided such a smooth and seamless experience with team knowledge. We listed and closed in 23 days. Lori was always available to answer questions and give advice. We would recommend Lori for this transition to your next adventure.

Lori Watters

Lori Watters

  5   (23 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent customer service
11 months ago
Excellent customer service

We were referred to Toots through a recommendation. We were very pleased with her integrity, professionalism, and quick response to any concern we had. We moved from another state and the real estate market and laws were unfamiliar to us. Toots made us feel comfortable and made the whole process smooth! Highly recommend!

Toot Penovich

Toot Penovich

  5   (55 reviews)
133 - 144 of 307
Realty One Group Simplified
Contact Realty One Group Simplified
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent