Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
135 reviewsacross 35 different locations, showing 12.
over 4 years ago
It was a pleasure working with Mike.

I felt very comfortable working with Mike. From his knowledge of the real estate market, the way he takes his fiduciary responsibility as priority one, to the ease of communication, I was highly impressed and couldn’t ask for a better experience. I would highly recommend Mike for all your real estate needs.

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
over 4 years ago
"Mike Mondello has a sterling reputation

Mike Mondello has a sterling reputation. Friends, family and neighbors repeatedly remarked upon how knowledgeable, responsive and professional he was. I also appreciated the mailings I received about his listings in my neighborhood. I had no doubt that Mike Mondello would be a fantastic broker when the time came to sell my home. Mike Mondello was friendly, trustworthy, helpful and respectful throughout the transaction, with both me and the other party. I was so impressed by his knowledge and skill coordinating negotiations and facilitating the closing of the sale. He was available whenever I needed to contact him, including on weekends and in the evenings. Mike Mondello is a true professional in every respect. From my initial contact with Mike through post-closing, he was truly excellent. His honesty, attention to detail, expertise in all aspects of the local market, plus his friendly demeanor made the transaction run flawlessly. I really appreciated all of his help coordinating the pre-listing maintenance work on my home. I was also impressed by his referrals and coordination with packing/moving companies once my house sold. Thanks to his keen marketing and expert pricing, my home received multiple offers and went into contract within 72 hours of listing. He was on top of every issue relating to the closing, and personally delivered the closing documents to me once the transaction was finalized. I could not be more pleased with my experience. My overall experience was excellent and I would wholeheartedly recommend Mike Mondello to anyone selling or buying property in Central Florida. This experience was far superior to any other real estate transaction I have been party to, thanks to Mike.

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
"Mike always had my best interest at heart regarding the sale of my home

Mike always had my best interest at heart regarding the sale of my home. Mike takes his fiduciary responsibility very seriously. He always answers questions or concerns in a timely manner. I have recommended Mike to my family and friends. Give Mike a call for all your real estate needs, you won’t be disappointed.

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Communicator

Mr. Tony is a great communicator and was excellent at being transparent every step of our journey to closing day. His knowledge and communication skills help to keep my anxiety down going through this volatile real-estate season. Thank you for your Professionalism, in helping my family get to this finish line to home ownership!!!

Tony Johnson

Tony Johnson

  5   (4 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
We’ve known this guy Paul -aka “ the real estate coach” for over 30 years now.

Instead of being called “ the real estate coach” this guy should be called Dr. Paul . His 35 years of knowledge and experience in real estate in the southwest Orlando area is unequaled by any other Realtor. His professional demeanor and his patience with taking us through the process at our pace , explaining all that’s going on , asking for our feedback , wether it’s on the buyers side, sellers side, landlord side or tenant side - he can guide you to the best possible outcome and make it seem simple . After our last closing, he showed us a sheet with the names of 32 different professionals that had been involved in our closing- mortgage people, title people, inspectors, and more - all of which had to do their job in concert with the other 31 . We have bought fixer uppers to live in, fixer uppers to rent out, brand new homes to live in or rent out- followed Paul’s advice over the past 30 plus years , and as we get ready to retire- we feel,with Paul’s guidance and knowledge of the real estate game, we will be able to enjoy our “ golden years . You should call him , set up a time to meet, he will not pressure you in any way, just answer your questions , maybe offer some advice , and let you go at the pace you feel comfortable with .

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
So Experienced!

Paul was so flexible with getting us our first home! 10/10 would recommend working with him!

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
"I cannot give enough praise

I cannot give enough praise. Thank you MIKE MONDELLO, you are amazing!

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Get 'er done!

So Paul was my agent when I purchased my home in 2016. He quickly demonstrated his expertise and knowledge and built trust which made the process very smooth. I would highly recommend Paul, and I plan to use him again when I purchase this year.

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Paul McGarigal is the MAN!!!

I moved out of state almost 2 years ago, and for 18 months Paul managed the renting of our house, and did an awesome job of it. When we decided it was time to sell, he worked out a deal with the renters and was able to get our house on the market within 2 months. While we were 600 miles away, Paul did a great job of getting and keeping the house cleaned, recommendations for what the house needed and getting those done, showing the house, and the knowledge of knowing when to refuse the inappropriate offers so we could accept the good one. We only got a few thousand below asking price, but that was the fault of the appraiser, who refused to account for the work done and new roof, despite Paul being there and showing them the proof of the work. We would have got even less, but because of Paul's experience and negotiating talents, we nearly got what we asked for (which was actually MORE than we thought we would get when my wife and I decided to put it on the market, because Paul suggested a higher initial asking price). Paul will either email or text, and he communicates well and is quick to respond to questions. Without reservation, I would recommend Paul for any of your real estate needs. Thanks Paul! Tom and Kris

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
about 5 years ago
"Mike was very pleasant while maintaining his professionalism

Mike was very pleasant while maintaining his professionalism. He contributed continuously throughout the process and made numerous beneficial recommendations. The results were superior.

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Without a doubt the best in the industry!!!

The best in the industry and a wonderful kind and generous person. Paul McGaragal is by far the most professional “get it done” Realtor I have had the privilege of working with. As a Real Estate Broker, I am knowledgeable and often critical of agents in this profession. After my tenant moved I out I decided to sell a home I owned in Orlando. Living too far away and in the middle of a pandemic I knew I needed to hire an agent. While I know many agents in the Orlando area, I chose to enlist the services of Paul. I soon discovered this was the best decision I could have made. He goes way beyond just sticking a sign in the yard. Paul managed all aspects of this transaction flawlessly. He facilitated, monitored and negotiated better pricing with various vendors working on the property to make it more marketable communicating with me every step of the way. All I had to do is sit back and let him work his magic. The offer came quickly, and he negotiated a final deal that was better than I had expected. After the executed offer Paul did not stop…. he made sure the inspections, repairs, appraisal and the buyer’s lender were working in a timely manner to ensure a timely and smooth closing. He is a well-oiled machine that runs a smooth transaction making it easy for the customer! I simply can’t speak highly enough about the level of professionalism and skill Paul demonstrates over and over again. The best compliment I can give is a referral…..so I just referred my son, a first time home buyer to Paul. Paul never ceases to amaze me. In today’s crazy seller’s market Paul has already succeeded in getting my son under contract. If you want to hire a Realtor and get so much more than you were expecting….hire Paul.

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
85 - 96 of 135
RE/MAX Select Group | Orlando
Contact RE/MAX Select Group | Orlando
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent