Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
135 reviewsacross 35 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
"You couldn't ask for anything more

You couldn't ask for anything more. He went over and beyond. This was not the typical sale. Mike is perfect!! Definitely would use him again.

Mike Mondello

Mike Mondello

  4.9   (103 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Excellent Selling Experience

Excellent service, excellent timing and excellent transaction overall. Highly recommended and very much appreciated. Top notch experience. Well-seasoned expert with outstanding results. Our home sold in one day, multiple offers and over list price. Gail is the best in the business. I highly recommend Gail for all your real estate needs.

Gail Higley

Gail Higley

  5   (10 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Best realtor ever

Hi, I have known Paul since I was 3 years old when he sold my parents our house in Orlando. He was a neighbor for years and a pillar in the local community. He was always at local high school soccer games, volunteering or donating to causes. That being said he was the clear choice for a realtor. However, he far surpassed any expectations I could have imagined. Paul started off by taking a holistic approach from a financial perspective and explained how this investment works. He then set up an entire day together to view homes. Once I found the right place to call home he got it at the price I wanted in an extremely competitive market. He set clear, black and white expectations about where his job starts and ends as well as where his colleagues jobs started and ended. He set everything up from the conversation with the mortgage Broker, insurance agent, to the closing and it was seamless! In what would typically be a lot of work, he made it so simple. Once the closing was complete he continued to be a resource through a renovation and lended his truck to move furniture. To say he exceeded my expectations would be an understatement. I am so grateful Paul was my realtor and I HIGHLY recommend him to anyone considering buying a home.

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Paul is the best realtor we have ever worked with!

This is the fourth home Paul McGarigal “The Real Estate Coach” has helped our family sell. You will not find a more qualified and more experienced real estate agent than Paul. Whether you are looking to buy sell or rent a home or even if you need a professional property manager, look no further than Paul McGarigal. You will be in very good hands!

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Gail Higley has the pulse of the real estate market in Central Fla-

Being in the real estate industry for 30 years being a Certified Home Inspector, I know the good from the (fair) realtors across the spectrum of the real estate market. Gail is the realtor who really cares and protects the client from the beginning to the end of the sale. She provided us with guidance at the beginning on what we should do to the property to get top dollar, to the end of the sale. Not only did she price the property $20,000 more than what we thought, she sold our house in 1 day, with 2 back up contracts. And also getting $10,000 more than the contract was listed for. She guided us on which was the best contract, and closed 20 days later. She always available for phone calls / texts and questions regarding closing statements. I would never buy or sell a property without the guidance of Gail, she has the Pulse of the real estate market in the Central Fla area. It's nice dealing with a professional seasoned veteran Realtor, with expert negotiation skills. Thank you again Gail, for all you have done for my family, your the BEST!!! (5 STARS)!!!

Gail Higley

Gail Higley

  5   (10 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Outstanding Service, Outstanding Results

Gail sold our home in one day with multiple offers received. Sold over list price. Transaction was smooth and professional. From day of listing to day of closing Gail kept he updated and informed. Highly recommend Gail for all your Central Florida residential real estate needs. Experience counts!

Gail Higley

Gail Higley

  5   (10 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Paul is an expert and true professional! You can trust Paul.

My wife and I recently purchased our first rental home from Paul this year and we couldn't be happier. Paul helped us find a renter and made the process simple. You are in good hands with Paul. We also recommend Dave Murray for the mortgage part! Thank you, Paul!!

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Paul is amazing realtor !

We have been working with Paul for over 15 years buying and selling homes and he has NEVER let us down! He always listens to our needs, gives great advise and will try to work the best deal for us! We know we are always in great hands with Paul and wouldn't dream of using anyone else!

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Working with Helen is always a pleasure!

This is the second house Helen has sold for my family and she is always so knowledgeable and professional, I can’t thank her enough for everything she’s done for us! I highly recommend her for any Realtor needs you may have in the Central Florida area.

Helen Thompson

Helen Thompson

  5   (1 review)
almost 6 years ago
One more time!

We have bought and sold homes six times with Paul as our realtor, in addition to 2 rentals. He knows the market better than most and is realistic with pricing and offers. He does his homework on area comps and shares that information readily so that sellers and buyers know what they can expect.

Paul McGarigal

Paul McGarigal

  5   (17 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Gail was a pleasure to work with and a true professional!!

Gail was a breath of fresh air for our family! We dealt with other agents who were unreliable and left a bad impression of Florida real estate in our minds . Gail knew we were only down in Florida for a short time and asked plenty of questions to make sure she had the right houses set up for us to see. She of course found the perfect house for our family and got us a great deal. She kept us in the loop during every aspect and checked in regularly to keep us at ease being we lived in New Jersey. She Even gave us plenty of details on the area of Oviedo to get us settled easier. We are 2 weeks into being in our new home and still she has checked in to see how we are and if we need anything. She truly is an amazing agent and I would recommend her to anyone I know moving to the area!!

Gail Higley

Gail Higley

  5   (10 reviews)
109 - 120 of 135
RE/MAX Select Group | Orlando
Contact RE/MAX Select Group | Orlando
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent