Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
140 reviewsacross 32 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Midge is a top notch resource for buying and/or selling real estate

I have worked with Midge both as a buyer and a seller. Her expertise and experience in the Sarasota market was delivered in a friendly and dependable manner. Her approachable personality and considerable skill helped navigate the entire process.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Truly outstanding in every way.

My sister passed away unexpectedly, and I was suddenly faced with an almost overwhelming number of challenges. My attorney recommended Midge when I asked her advice about a realtor to help me decide how to handle disposition of my sister’s house. Midge guided me through the entire process with exceptional professionalism, tact, and compassion; she was with me every step of the way. She listened thoughtfully to all my concerns and questions, offering advice and support while always respecting my decisions. She consistently replied very promptly and maintained open communication via phone, text, and email, often anticipating issues that I would not have been aware of and making numerous phone calls on my behalf. She gave excellent recommendations for service providers who unfailingly delivered prompt, excellent work at fair and reasonable prices. Midge obtained a final selling price that was considerably higher than I had thought possible, and the entire process went through very smoothly, thanks to her team of talented professionals. Midge has a wealth of experience, and this has allowed her to build a reliable network of people who can help resolve virtually any issue that might arise in connection with a real estate transaction. I recommend her enthusiastically and without any hesitation; she is a true professional and, quite simply, a wonderful human being.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 2 years ago
It’s always a pleasure to work with a professional

She definitely is the go to person when it comes to knowledge, professionalism, and integrity. We have worked on other deals in the past and have Always had a good experience. I would definitely use her again in the future.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Hard working Realtor!

Midge was wonderful to work with. She is very knowledgable about the area and sale trends. Communication was terrific. She was always easy to reach and quick to respond to requests/questions. Unfortunately, the sales in our area were very slow and it took a long time to sell our condo, but Midge worked hard doing open houses almost weekly, as well as implementing other marketing techniques.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Goes the Extra Mile

I highly recommend Midge McCarthy as your next Realtor. She is very knowledgeable, reliable and professional. She helped me sell my dad's home while I moved him into an Assisted-Care facility. I initially tried to sell "as is" however our unit was outdated and the market drastically changed. Midge advised me to renovate during the slow season and sell during the high season. She was very instrumental helping me with movers, contractors, painters, electricians, plumbers, pest control, garden services, air-conditioning, and professional cleaners and other laborers. I live out of town and Midge was my primary source of referrals and help. She is easy to work with and responds same day to any questions or concerns. She pointed out the do's and don'ts of remodeling to sell our unit. Everything she recommended was right on track. We sold my dad's home in a short period of time and for asking price. She is very personable and really cares about her clients and treats you like family.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Highly recommended

Midge made my purchase experience an easy journey. I was living in my area 50 years and was extremely apprehensive moving to a new area where I knew no one. I felt very comfortable with all her research and encouragement along the way. She literally held my hand and I’m not new to buying homes. I would recommend Midge to anyone coming to the area that she services. She goes above and beyond any agent I have had in the past.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Highly recommend!

Midge helped us navigate everything from start to finish and went above and beyond for us!

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Topnotch Agent Helped Us Get Our House

Without Midge, we would not have found our house. She was aware it was going to be on the market and helped us put in the offer. Throughout the process, she did everything we asked her to do, including virtually taking us through the property. We are so grateful for her help at every step.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 3 years ago
professional and thorough

Midge exceeded expectations Just putting up with me proves my point Very helpful, considerate and willing to go the extra mile. Thank you

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Excellent service

Midge is one of a few unique realtors in this county that walks along side the seller & pays attention to all the details, taking care of any issues that arise with professionalism and efficiency. Midge truly cares about her clients and is a one of a kind realtor.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Great Experience

Midge is great, very knowledgeable and extremely experienced.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (56 reviews)
13 - 24 of 140
RE/MAX Platinum Realty - Sarasota
Contact RE/MAX Platinum Realty - Sarasota
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent