Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
137 reviewsacross 32 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 months ago
Trusted Real Estate Professional

Midge’s knowledge of the local market runs deep and wide from her years of experience as a real estate professional. She worked with us continuously through the purchase process explaining the next steps; providing follow-up with any questions or issues and connecting us to local home related resources when needed.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
5 months ago
Professional from start to finish.

Working with Midge to sell my house was a pleasure. Midge brings experience, knowledge and great customer service skills to her customers.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
7 months ago
Midge McCarthy

Midge is a very experienced realtor. She has a lot of knowledge in her market. Her communication skills and professionalism are excellent. If you want a job done right, I recommend that you use Midge McCarthy of ReMax Realty. She goes out of her way to get the job done quickly and properly.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
8 months ago
Outstanding!

Midge, went above and beyond her listing requirements. She had my listing marketing photos along with drone photos up for listing launch. Her timely approach to marketing and highlighting my listing in multiple places brought multiple offers second day of listing. If you are looking for an experienced broker associate call Midge McCarthy 941.809.3800

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Awesome and very professional

She took me to see many places and didn’t rest until she knew. I was happy and decided on the condo that I got. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy property in Sarasota, Florida, and surrounding areas.

Jessica Bow

Jessica Bow

  5   (26 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Sold my condo in Sarasoda.

I listed my condo in Sarasota in July. Then two hurricanes hit. The real estate market fell dramatically. During this difficult time Midge worked very hard with special advertising and many open houses. I had to drop my original price a lot. But, Midge found a likely buyer and keep after them while they looked at other properties. They finally agreed to buy. I closed on my condo today. I am 1400 miles away from Sarasota. Midge kept in constant contact with me. I highly recommend Midge to any seller or buyer. K

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
almost 2 years ago
See review 5 stars!

Midge did a great job! She’s excellent on detail and strides right through all the challenges that arise, she is professional and qualified, I’d recommend her to anyone buying or selling a house in our area!

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Over and Above!

I have worked with Midge for over 30 years. It is her knowledge, experience, compassion, and dedication to her buyers and sellers that keeps me coming back. You may count on Midge for your real estate needs.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Midge is a top notch resource for buying and/or selling real estate

I have worked with Midge both as a buyer and a seller. Her expertise and experience in the Sarasota market was delivered in a friendly and dependable manner. Her approachable personality and considerable skill helped navigate the entire process.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Truly outstanding in every way.

My sister passed away unexpectedly, and I was suddenly faced with an almost overwhelming number of challenges. My attorney recommended Midge when I asked her advice about a realtor to help me decide how to handle disposition of my sister’s house. Midge guided me through the entire process with exceptional professionalism, tact, and compassion; she was with me every step of the way. She listened thoughtfully to all my concerns and questions, offering advice and support while always respecting my decisions. She consistently replied very promptly and maintained open communication via phone, text, and email, often anticipating issues that I would not have been aware of and making numerous phone calls on my behalf. She gave excellent recommendations for service providers who unfailingly delivered prompt, excellent work at fair and reasonable prices. Midge obtained a final selling price that was considerably higher than I had thought possible, and the entire process went through very smoothly, thanks to her team of talented professionals. Midge has a wealth of experience, and this has allowed her to build a reliable network of people who can help resolve virtually any issue that might arise in connection with a real estate transaction. I recommend her enthusiastically and without any hesitation; she is a true professional and, quite simply, a wonderful human being.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
about 2 years ago
It’s always a pleasure to work with a professional

She definitely is the go to person when it comes to knowledge, professionalism, and integrity. We have worked on other deals in the past and have Always had a good experience. I would definitely use her again in the future.

Midge McCarthy

Midge McCarthy

  5   (53 reviews)
1 - 12 of 137
RE/MAX Platinum Realty - Sarasota
Contact RE/MAX Platinum Realty - Sarasota
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent