Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
497 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
over 10 years ago
It was a "by-mail/over-the-internet" transaction

It was a "by-mail/over-the-internet" transaction. Peter McGahan was very helpful putting documents together and arranging on-line signatures. He also orchestrated inspections and other services at the property. Before the sale, he arranged listings, and he was always available to answer questions and provide guidance in a timely way. It was a positive experience working with Peter McGahan.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
almost 11 years ago
We had the pleasure of doing business with Pete early in 2015

We had the pleasure of doing business with Pete early in 2015. Pete is very knowledgeable of Pinellas County. My partner and I both were a little scattered when it came to knowing exactly what we wanted, and being able to articulate that to our agent did not come easy to us. Pete patiently paid attention to cues we were (unknowingly) giving. By the time we viewed the second home, he somehow knew exactly what we were looking for. He honed in on our style and wants, and he was able to find a home that matched us perfectly, and he showed us that home, which we later purchased, on our third outing! He has a gift! We trust Pete, and we find him to be very ethical, which is important to us. We were new to the home buying process, and Pete walked us through each step of the way. He explained absolutely everything in detail. He made everything extremely easy! I stayed up many evenings emailing and texting Pete until 12AM or later. He was always there to answer any question, no matter how silly it was. Do yourself a favor and just stop looking for an agent if you are in that phase. Just give him a call. You will not be sorry!!

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
almost 11 years ago
pete helped us search for the right home in the right area

pete helped us search for the right home in the right area. Is wasn't easy but Petes tenacity and knew what we wanted and searched until he found it. He is 2nd to none and would use him again!

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
almost 11 years ago
My wife and I had such a great experience working with Pete! He made the stressful process of buying

My wife and I had such a great experience working with Pete! He made the stressful process of buying our first house much more manageable and actually a fun and rewarding experience. We were very impressed with Pete's responsiveness to all of our (usually silly) questions. Several times we would shoot him an email with a question at around midnight, expecting an answer maybe the next day, and be shocked to receive an answer from him 5 minutes later! We have nothing but the best things to say about our experience with Pete from the initial search for our house to closing day, and we would definitely love to work with him again when the time comes to sell our home. Thanks for everything, Pete!

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Pete started on finding us a new home immediately after discussing our needs with him

Pete started on finding us a new home immediately after discussing our needs with him. Within the first week he had located and shown us several properties, always working around our schedule and always promptly responding to every question we had. We found the ideal home within the first month and Pete worked diligently to make every aspect of the home buying experience run smoothly and quickly.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
After 3 years of searching for a condo with 5 different real estate agents, I finally met Pete and w

After 3 years of searching for a condo with 5 different real estate agents, I finally met Pete and was immediately impressed with his professionalism. His wonderful personality, can-do attitude and attention to detail helped us narrow our search and find our vacation home. Pete patiently walked us through the negotiation, inspection and title processes. His knowledge of St. Petersburg and the surrounding areas are extensive and he was extremely responsive to our every request. I have and will continue to recommend him to my "baby boomer" friends looking to get out of the snow and find their piece of Paradise!

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Pete represented us two years ago when we bought a condo in St Petersburg

Pete represented us two years ago when we bought a condo in St Petersburg. When we decided to get a larger place we chose Pete again to help us find the right house. He is very familiar with the area and did an excellent job of helping us fine the best fit for our needs and our budget. He is very knowledgeable regarding the home buying process and worked effectively with the seller's agent so that we could get questions answered quickly. He does an excellent job of communicating. We highly recommend him.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Pete was hired to be our Buyer's Agent to handle our cash purchase of a for-sale-by-owner home

Pete was hired to be our Buyer's Agent to handle our cash purchase of a for-sale-by-owner home. He took charge, prepared all the paperwork, dealt with the out-of-state owner, interfaced with the title company, arranged for the home inspection, and had recommendations of a firm for the survey. <br/><br/>The process was handled quickly, professionally, and efficiently resulting in a closing 25 days after initially contacting him. Pete was indispensable in getting this deal done since we reside out of the area. His expertise was worth every penny.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Pete was an excellent contact to guide us through our home purchase in St

Pete was an excellent contact to guide us through our home purchase in St. Petersburg. We had initial contact with him in April when he showed us many homes and was able to develop a good sense of the type of home we ere looking for. When we returned in September he was ready with many homes to show us. We were able to make an offer and have a contract within a week. Then he helped us through the entire closing process and has even continued to work with us since we moved in a some issues that remained outstanding. I would highly recommend Pete to any one looking for a home in the St. Pete area.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Jay helped me purchase my first home and I...

Jay helped me purchase my first home and I could not have done it without him. Jay was very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the process of finding a home and working with the mortgage company. I would highly recommend.

JAY HEIDEL

JAY HEIDEL

  5   (1 review)
about 12 years ago
Pete was recommended through a friend when we started looking at buying a home in St Pete

Pete was recommended through a friend when we started looking at buying a home in St Pete. Since we were buying from out of state, it was especially important that we have a realtor who we could rely on and trust in, to find us the right home, and to represent us from beginning to end. We couldn’t have been more pleased. This was the 5th home we have bought over the years and was easily the smoothest. Pete has a lot of patience and kept us up to speed as homes came on the market. We were in Virginia when the perfect house came up. We flew down to see the house, and Pete completed the negotiation and contract signing electronically, all within 2 days. His representation of us to the sellers and back was seamless. Pete paid prompt and high quality attention to everything we needed after that, including inspections and a remote closing. Since we were purchasing an older home, we were especially concerned about getting a first-rate inspection. Pete has great local contacts and he recommended an inspector and spent the day with him on our behalf. Pete talked us through the inspector’s observations over the phone and it felt as if we were there. It was the best inspection ever, focused on what’s really important, and not endless notations of normal wear and tear that anybody could see. We were more than satisfied as were we with his help in navigating us through Florida Insurance. Pete is a skillful professional, providing one-stop shopping and attention to everything you need, and he’s also a fun person. How many realtors have you gone out to dinner with to celebrate and who enthusiastically offer to help you move your furniture in? This buying experience had at most a half day of stress and, yes, Pete actually made it fun.

Peter J Mc Gahan

Peter J Mc Gahan

  5   (44 reviews)
481 - 492 of 497
Keller Williams St Pete Realty
Contact Keller Williams St Pete Realty
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent