Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
497 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
25 days ago
Simply the best!

When we moved to St Pete in 2022, Jennifer and her team helped us find the perfect place to land. When our life’s journey took us away from St Pete this year, there was only one person we knew we could trust with our listing. Jennifer and her team handled every detail. Jennifer brings creativity, energy, and focus. What makes Jennifer great? she doesn’t treat each deal as just a transaction, she thinks about every detail and makes sure her clients have clarity understanding regarding the strategy. She checks in many times along the way to make sure there is alignment. When it’s time to pivot, she’s always ready to with options. We bought AND sold with Jennifer Thayer. There is simply NO ONE else to call if you’re buying or selling in St Pete. No one knows the market better, and no one works as hard.

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
28 days ago
Extraordinary

Jennifer/ Deb and the rest of the Thayer team were truly amazing. I've been dealing with realtors my entire life, some good and some not so. The experience I had with the sale of my home in this environment was amazing. I can't say enough wonderfully things about the Thayer team!

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
about 1 month ago
Stephanie was amazing, she knew after looking at 1 unit our likes & dislikes

Initially after looking at about 6 units we decided to change our criteria a bit and then we had to head home ( not FL residents). A few weeks later Stephanie reached out to us on a condo listing she saw in Tierra Verde that was amazing. She arranged a video tour for us and we fell in love with it. We had to do everything long distance and she was awesome on all aspects. She got us a great price and a great deal on the unit. .Had to do a remote closing, that was very smooth. About 6 weeks later we made it down to FL to actually stay in our new unit, opened the deck blinds and off of our balcony were dolphins in the canal that we could see - we joked that Stephanie did a great job planning the dolphins visit!! Such a wonderful experience from start to finish. She went the extra mile for us because we were not able to be there.

Stephanie McElroy

Stephanie McElroy

  5   (17 reviews)
about 1 month ago
Excellence in real estate

If you are looking to buy or sell luxury real estate in St. Petersburg, choose Diana Geegan & Greg Geegan. They provided exceptional service in helping sell our condo in Tierra Verde and finding our “forever” home in St Pete Beach. From start to finish, their professionalism, and attention to detail made the process smooth and manageable. In addition to having a deep knowledge of the market, they also explained every step of the process clearly. Documents, deadlines and contract details were thoroughly reviewed so I felt like we didn't have any surprises during the process. There were some minor challenges when dealing with the selling agent, but Diana & Greg handled those situations with confidence. They were firm when it mattered and advocated for our interests and kept everything moving forward. Buying and selling a home at the same time can be stressful, but Diana & Greg made the entire experience much smoother. It was a five star experience indeed.

Diana Geegan, PA

Diana Geegan, PA

  5   (32 reviews)
about 2 months ago
Great Customer Service

Jennifer was amazing and diligent in selling our FL home. We were very appreciative.

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
about 2 months ago
Jennifer Thayer ....Simply incomparable!!

Jennifer Thayer is exceptional in every sense. A great communicator and a deft negotiator. My previous experiences with other realtors pales by comparison. She stands firmly in a league of her own.

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
4 months ago
By far the best selling experience I’ve had

Diana was simply fantastic to work with. She knows her seller, her buyers, and the market. Selling price was higher than I expected, and Diana made the entire process smooth and seamless. Highly recommended!

Diana Geegan, PA

Diana Geegan, PA

  5   (32 reviews)
4 months ago
Knowledgeable excellence

Fantastic understanding of the market, buildings and history of St. Petersburg. Time spent and communication abilities top notch. Could NOT ask for better representation.

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
4 months ago
Janice is a ROCK STAR!

We reach out to Janice remotely at the recommendation of a friend and she quickly went to work sharing listings matching our wants and budget. Number of available properties was somewhat overwhelming but Janice helped us narrow list and scheduled viewings to correspond with a planned trip. After spending one day with Janice visiting properties and going through what we liked and didn't like she was able to find 2 additional listings that we visited on same trip and we found out little piece of paradise. Janice stuck with us through a remote closing and made it easy. She helped us with a final walk through prior to closing and had fresh linens waiting on us for our first visit. She's a 10!

Janice Reed

Janice Reed

  5   (25 reviews)
5 months ago
Great real estate purchase experience with Jennifer!

If you’re looking for a condo in downtown St Petersburg you should definitely consider Jennifer Thayer as your real estate agent. Her detailed knowledge of the area and the various properties is invaluable. She is extremely responsive, professional, and a pleasure to work with. Thanks to her guidance and advice, we were able to successfully purchase a condo we love in a relative short period of time.

Jennifer Thayer

Jennifer Thayer

  5   (123 reviews)
1 - 12 of 497
Keller Williams St Pete Realty
Contact Keller Williams St Pete Realty
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent