Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
165 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, honest, empathetic, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Such a breeze!
over 3 years ago
Such a breeze!

We worked with Melanie twice. Helped us with the buying process and selling process of a property. Loved working with her, her honesty, communication was awesome, always one step ahead of the game, getting everything wrapped up on time. Buying or selling a property its such an emotional and stressful process and Melanie definitely made it feel such a breeze. Don’t think it twice, let her help you close your deal!

Melanie Carnes
Seller review
Great agent. Exceptional service.
over 3 years ago
Great agent. Exceptional service.

Erin Carmona is a fantastic realtor. She just helped me close on the sale of a problematic property that, to boot, experienced a broken pipe and water leak right before the closing. The deal was on the verge of falling through but Erin deftly salvaged the deal and saved me a lot of money and potential lost time. I look forward to working with Erin again soon.

Erin Carmona
Buyer review
Ben Zallaha: professional, trustworthy and honest.
over 3 years ago
Ben Zallaha: professional, trustworthy and honest.

Ben was a pleasure to work with. He was prepared at all times, thorough in everything he did for us, responsive to our questions and concerns, and genuinely interested in us and whether we would enjoy living in Prescott. Above all else, Ben was and is honest.

Benjamin Zallaha
Buyer review
You can’t go wrong with Debbie Gato!
almost 4 years ago
You can’t go wrong with Debbie Gato!

We absolutely love Debbie. This woman is dedicated to her clients! Debbie stuck with us for 3 years helping us find a home. (We are very picky) we had some problems with a builder. Debbie fought for us hard and didn’t back down! She is knowledgeable, professional and dedicated!!! We highly recommend Debbie!!

Debra M Gatto
Buyer review
Fantastic service
almost 4 years ago
Fantastic service

Do you have a great group there whenever my agent was the way people stepped in and handled everything I never had one worry

Garrett Hamlin
Buyer review
Best Realtor Around!
almost 4 years ago
Best Realtor Around!

Erin is amazing!! Highly recommend her 100/10. She was very proactive in looking for houses and got us in to view houses with very short notice. Wonderful communication from beginning to end. Thank you Erin for all your work!

Erin Carmona
Seller review
Erin just saved me $50,000
almost 4 years ago
Erin just saved me $50,000

Erin is amazing. She knows her business and is a true partner in the real estate sales process. After using an out-of-town agent to list my house, which was going nowhere as I continued following that agent's advice to just keep dropping the price (and to drop it another $50k), I called Erin. She immediately gave me other, better ideas and identified problems and weaknesses with the listing as it was with the prior agent. After receiving no offers with the prior agent, and immediately after Erin became involved and took several proactive measures and (re)listed the property, I had 5 or 6 walk throughs and received 2 full price offers--one of which had a huge escalation clause. To say I was impressed and relieved is an understatement! My only regret is that I did not start with Erin. I would have netted a lot more money. I buy and sell a lot of houses, and could not recommend Erin more.

Erin Carmona
Buyer review
Wonderful experience
almost 4 years ago
Wonderful experience

She is a wonderful, caring person , I can not tell anything else about her but the best !!!

Erin Carmona
Buyer review
Great service
almost 4 years ago
Great service

Great service, amazing job

Erin Carmona
Buyer review
The Absolute Best!!
almost 4 years ago
The Absolute Best!!

I am new to the area. Erin planned the first day of house hunting to include homes in every area so I could get an initial feel for each community. The strategy was very helpful. We looked at 30 homes in 5 days until I knew I had found the one that best fit our needs. We spent a lot of time together. Erin was fantastic to work with. I can’t imagine going through that exhausting process with anyone else. Erin is knowledgeable, patient, kind and she has your best interest in mind. If you’re looking for a realtor who knows their stuff and makes you a priority, Erin is your person!!

Erin Carmona
Buyer review
Erin was Wonderful to work with!
almost 4 years ago
Erin was Wonderful to work with!

Erin was so helpful from the first phone call to the close of our land! She is very easy to work with and very consistent with everything we were looking for! I would definitely recommend her to any friends and family that are looking for a new home or property!

Erin Carmona
97 - 108 of 165
© 2026 RateMyAgent