Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
36 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: flexible, hard-working, well-prepared, responsive, attentive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Great help for first time homebuyers with flexibility.
12 days ago
Great help for first time homebuyers with flexibility.

Mark was a great help finding the perfect home within my budget, especially as a first time home buyer. I had lots of questions and concerns. He answered all of my questions and was able to work with my tight schedule, getting multiple showings in one day. He was able to refer me to the right people which helped me close quickly and on time! I would definitely recommend him to my friends and family!

Mark Baldy

Mark Baldy

  5   (1 review)
Seller review
A responsive, professional, and trustworthy realtor.
14 days ago
A responsive, professional, and trustworthy realtor.

We always knew when the time came to sell my brother’s property in Elmwood Village we would reach out to Carolyn Hoyt-Stevens. Her knowledge of the real estate market in the Buffalo area is unparalleled, and her professionalism far outpaces her competitors. Carolyn’s responsiveness to our needs was immediate. Her network is wide and strong and was an enormous asset to us as we navigated the many services needed to empty and clean a legacy home. Her professional style and sharp negotiating skills gave us the confidence we needed to sell this property during an uncertain market period. We trusted her implicitly. The process was quick, smooth and we were completely satisfied with the outcome.

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
Professional
16 days ago
Professional

Carolyn took my family through the selling process during a difficult time. She was understanding, professional, and gave us helpful input. Carolyns insight into the housing market gave our family one less thing to worry about. She was always ready to answer any question by phone, email, or in person. I would recommend her to anyone.

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
With Us Every Step of the Way
24 days ago
With Us Every Step of the Way

Selling and buying a house is stressful. Carolyn was with us every step of the way. No question or concern was too small and she happily responded, scheduled and guided everytime throughout the process. Not only did we benefit from her market savy but, we enjoyed her company too. She understood our family and our needs. We sold quickly, at the price we wanted and bought the house we aimed for even with competition. A+

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent experience with my home purchase!
24 days ago
Excellent experience with my home purchase!

Carolyn was a connsumate professional throughout our home search in Buffalo to find the “perfect one”! She is incredibly thoughtful and knowledgeable when it comes to her expertise in the competitive Buffalo real estate market. It felt like she always had our best interests as her priority. It was an honest pleasure to work with her. I wouldn’t hesitate to highly recommend her to family and friends in the Buffalo/WNY area.

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

Carolyn Hoyt Stevens

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Experience Selling Our Historic Home
about 1 month ago
Excellent Experience Selling Our Historic Home

Jim was terrific to work with throughout the entire process. He had previously helped us successfully list our historic home as a rental, and when it came time to sell, we were happy to work with him again. He understood and appreciated the unique nature of the property—and, importantly, knew how to market and sell it effectively. Jim was responsive, communicative, friendly, and flexible, and he made the process easy from start to finish. Most importantly, he helped us secure a good price in a timely manner. We would gladly recommend Jim to anyone looking to rent or sell a home.

James "Jim" Mack

James "Jim" Mack

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Very knowledgeable and friendly!
about 2 months ago
Very knowledgeable and friendly!

Tim is a great guy, knows his stuff and is very trustworthy

Timothy Smith

Timothy Smith

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Always Looking out for his clients and their interests
about 2 months ago
Always Looking out for his clients and their interests

Provided clear and concise information on everything within the local market. His level of knowledge and delivery of that knowledge was always incredible. Tim provided a great breakdown of how things work in the Buffalo area and how we'd fair given current market conditions. I'd 100% recommend him to anyone looking for a local realtor with experience to help walk you through everything.

Timothy Smith

Timothy Smith

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional, knowledgeable and I wish he lived next door!
2 months ago
Professional, knowledgeable and I wish he lived next door!

My search for the right home was anything but straightforward as my particular situation called for something special. Tim was always ready to show me any possibility and when the right place finally appeared, helped me negotiate a winning offer. He also helped me sell my home, and has made that process as pain free as possible. Tim is always available to answer any questions and goes above and beyond to make sure I have whatever information I might want or need. Communicating with Tim is easy, reliable and enjoyable. I’m going to miss working with him!

Timothy Smith

Timothy Smith

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
excellent realtor with deep knowledge, caring and professional
2 months ago
excellent realtor with deep knowledge, caring and professional

We couldn't wish for a better realtor for us, he is very knowledgeable about house structure, housing market, offer strategy and he guided us through the process despite all the challenges we faced in the current market. Going to the house showing with him was very helpful as he took a close look at everything, answering any questions we had, he taught us what to look for in order to protect us too. His skill in creating competitive offers is excellent. You will be very lucky to have Tim as your realtor. We are very grateful and feel so lucky that we had Tim guiding us through the house buying process.

Timothy Smith

Timothy Smith

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Knowledgeable and professional realtor
3 months ago
Knowledgeable and professional realtor

Daneen did a fantastic job of helping us find our dream home sooner than we expected! She was easy to communicate with and very responsive. She made sure we found everything we were looking for in our dream home. She was very knowledgeable and professional. I could t recommend her enough!

Daneen Vincent

Daneen Vincent

  5   (3 reviews)
1 - 12 of 36
© 2026 RateMyAgent