Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus

272 East Main Street New Albany, OH 43054
  •   5   (166 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

28
Reviews
11
Properties for sale
95
Sold properties
$445k
Average sale price
$42.2m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Our customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus has won

  • National Top 100United States
  • Region Top 10Midwest Region
  • State Top 3Ohio

Meet the team

Get to know the 4 agents at Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus.

About Tiffany
Meet Tiffany Bafford, a dynamic real estate agent with a proven track record of success in Ohio, specializing in the Central Ohio area (especially Granville, New Albany, Alexandria, Newark, Heath, Gahanna, Westerville, Pickerington). With 43 glowing reviews and an impressive average rating of 5.0 out of 5, Tiffany is applauded for delivering exceptional customer experiences. Tiffany's real estate expertise is unmatched, boasting 30 successful property sales over the past year, with an impressive average selling price of over $400,000. Her properties spend an average of just six days on the market, showcasing her efficiency and expertise in securing swift and satisfactory deals for her clients. Currently managing five active property listings, Tiffany is particularly proficient in handling a variety of property types, providing specialized insights into single-family homes and condos. Her strategies are tailored to meet the individual needs of every client, ensuring top-tier service and satisfaction in buying or selling. With over $11 million in overall sales this past year, Tiffany is committed to excellence and integrity in every transaction. Her deep understanding of the local real estate market in Ohio and dedication to client satisfaction makes her the ideal partner for those looking to navigate the complex world of real estate with confidence. Whether you’re buying your first home or looking to sell, Tiffany Bafford is the trusted name in Ohio real estate, ready to guide you every step of the way.
View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievementstop20badgepriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
About Christopher
Cutler Real Estate asked Chris a few questions so you can get to know him better, and here are Chris's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? I am an alum of both the United States Naval Academy and The Ohio State University. 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? Real Estate is in my blood! I have many family members that are and have been Realtors, Brokers, and Real Estate Business Owners. While still in college, I was given an opportunity to work for my Great Uncle in Middletown, Ohio. He invited me to learn the business, and eventually "take over" half of his business. I learned that I loved Real Estate, but that I didn't love living in Middletown, Ohio!! 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I live in New Albany, Ohio. I LOVE New Albany! It's one of the few suburban Columbus Neighborhoods that allow you to walk or ride your bike to all places of interest. Whether it's to the schools, shopping, ball fields, Aquatic Center, post office, restaurants, banking, bike paths and walking trails, places of worship, etc., it's just a hop, skip, and a jump away!! 4. How do you spend your free time? I enjoy going to any of the school activity or sporting event that my daughter is involved in. I also love to travel with my family. We can be found cruising, hitting a beach, or finding a great destination for people watching and eating local fare! 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? Photo albums and pictures Coin collection Comic Book Collection (never read them, but collected on advice of my brother!) A comfortable pillow Our Yorkie Poo! 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Happy!
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
About Mary

Mary currently has 2 active property listings and 12 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
About Stefani
Cutler Real Estate asked Stefani a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Stefani's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? Real Estate - Hondros College 2002 Bank of America 2008-2014 Mortgage & Appraisal Co. 1996-2002 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? In 2002, I chose to become a Realtor, initially drawn to the flexibility that allowed me to be present for my young children. But as I grew in the profession, I discovered that real estate was more than just a career - it became a passion. It's truly an honor to guide people through one of the most significant decisions of their lives, whether they're buying or selling. Sharing in these exciting milestones and helping clients achieve their dreams is what makes this journey so rewarding for me. 3. How do you spend your free time? When I'm not working, I love spending time with my family - they mean everything to me. My granddaughters are the highlight of my day, and I cherish every moment with them. Of course, my pup is always by my side. I also live in a fun neighborhood, where I've made great friends over the years, and we enjoy spending time together. Recently, I've taken up pickleball, and while I'm still working on my game, it's been a lot of fun! 4. If you could only keep 3 possessions what would they be? Family Dogs Photo albums
View Profile
Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus

Are you Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus?

Contact help@renowned.com and one of our friendly team will assist you to claim your profile, request and receive your first review.

Claim profile

About us

At Cutler Real Estate, we have the best Real Estate professionals in the business! We recognize that a real estate company is only as good as its Realtors. The brokerage’s "Transactions Per Realtor Productivity" ranks among the highest in the industry, with Cutler Realtors, on average, closing over 18 transactions per Realtor. For us, the formula for success is simple…hire the best men and women to be Cutler Realtors, provide them with industry leading tools and superior business support and nurture a fun and rewarding culture to do business in!

Our reviews

  5  
166 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 6.
Seller review
Excellent Customer Service
3 days ago
Excellent Customer Service

Tiffany is a great realtor she helped us. Navigate every piece in part of the buying and selling process. She always went above and beyond even when life threw us a few turn along the way. I'm so glad that she represented us. First and foremosmost it's is our friend and former neighbor! You can't go wrong with Tiffany as your realtor!

Tiffany Bafford
Seller review
Excellent communication
10 days ago
Excellent communication

Tiffany is an outstanding real estate agent. She went far above our expectations! She did so much research of comparable home in our area to help us determine the value of our home. We were impressed with how she was careful to not make our value too high, but also not too low and was sure to involve us in two different MLS markets. We believe that her greatest gift is communication. We texted her with numerous questions and she ALWAYS was patient and kind in answering each one. It was amazing how quickly she got back to us even on vacation! She communicated effectively with our buyers agent and always kept our best interest to the forefront. If you are looking for a very effective agent, look no farther than Tiffany!

Tiffany Bafford
Seller review
Above & beyond helpful, courteous, & professional. Highly recommend
13 days ago
Above & beyond helpful, courteous, & professional. Highly recommend

Chris called every play in this game of selling right on track. From timing of the listing, to pricing & presentation. He completely had our best interest and explained any inquiries we had to detail and either an example or reason. This guy is absolutely stellar at his profession & made it a bearable activity

Christopher Rosen
Seller review
Cutting Edge, Kind, Supportive, Timely Communicator, Closer!
29 days ago
Cutting Edge, Kind, Supportive, Timely Communicator, Closer!

Tiffany Bafford is what I think all Real Estate Agents should be. She took a very unique property like ours and found the right solution. She brought in the right partners and gave us many options to help US make the right decision for our personal situation. That was an auction. If you know me I am not a risk taker! This felt risky! That said she brought us the experts to tell us why it was a GOOD RISK! She struck while the iron was hot and the timing was good. We put it on the market and went through the pain staking steps to prep our house of 14 year and get it ready to show. She also took us to see a few houses. At this time if you did not make and offer at the point of seeing the house you lost the opportunity. She found us a great home in the right community that kept us in the same school district and met our unique needs. She suggested a financing person that could talk us though selling an buying a house in this crazy market. He was great. We have now been in our new place for 3 months. We sold prior to the auction and did not have to under go the stress of the actual auction. I believe this was due to Tiffany's Marketing and connections in the market with other realtors! She was able to vet out the right interest and find us the right buyer. She navigated this like a pro and stepped us through it. I was a nervous wreck. This is not a reflection of Tiffany's support it is just my personality on big life decisions and purchases. Tiff got us through it and put us in a great spot. I will be forever grateful for her professionalism and support. In my opinion she was able to thread the needle on the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. I don't easily endorse sales people especially Realtors!!! Tiffany Bafford has my full endorsement!!! She is the gold standard for what a great realtor should be!

Tiffany Bafford
Buyer review
First time home buyer easy experience with guidance and comfort
about 1 month ago
First time home buyer easy experience with guidance and comfort

We worked with Tiffany as a first time homebuyer. In our initial meeting she reviewed the whole process, documents we would see and made it very clear she had our best interest in mind. We created an easy working relationship with a text group chat and always answered each and every question we had clearly and quickly. The whole process was generally overwhelming but Tiffany made it easy and manageable. She helped us to understand that what we were looking for was highly sought after by others and therefore we had to move fast. She was great at guiding us through making an offer and what the offer and other details should be. She was great at working with the sellers and their agent to make a deal that was fruitful for all parties.

Tiffany Bafford
Seller review
Trusted advisor at every step!
2 months ago
Trusted advisor at every step!

Tiffany didn’t assume anything, she offered to educate and share her advice if wanted. The ownership she took of every piece of our experience truly built trust and gave peace of mind.

Tiffany Bafford
Show all 166 reviews
map

Our properties

Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus has 22 properties for sale and sold 95 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$305,000
44480 US-36
Coshocton OH 43812
3
2
5
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
For Sale
$1,149,000
7076 Calabria Place
Dublin OH 43016
3
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
SoldAug 28, 2026
$580,000
269 Park Ridge Ln
Newark OH 43023
4
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany
SoldAug 24, 2026
$1,675,000
8002 Maxtown Road
Westerville OH 43082
4
5
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Cutler Real Estate | New Albany and The Brokerage House LLC
Show all 117 properties
Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus
Contact Cutler Real Estate | One Team Columbus
What information would you like?

Browse nearby locations

This individual or business has not claimed this profile. Even though this profile is on RateMyAgent, this does not mean they endorse the site, is associated with the site, or confirms the listings or sales data information which we display about them, or any other publicly available information, to be accurate in any way. Read more

© 2026 RateMyAgent