Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
372 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Great purchase experience!

I live out of state and counted on Theresa's expertise most of the time during my buying process. Theresa is a knowledgeable agent who knows the area well and provides valuable inputs to her customers to make important decisions. Also, the paperwork process was actually paperless, making everything much faster and easier. I would recommend Theresa for a smooth transaction with an absolute peace of mind!

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Best Home Buying Experience - 5-Star Service from Theresa Shlimanoff

I met Theresa accidentally in an open house that I went to see in Wesley Chapel. I liked how approachable she was and told her what I was looking for and that I was moving from California. She listened to everything carefully to our long list of specifications and at that time I did not know how good she would be at matching us with the right home. All the properties that she showed us met every specification we were looking for...but the market in March 2022 was very hot in Tampa and nothing would stay in more than a day and I was running out of time as I had an interest rate locked at very low rate. She worked so hard and showed us many properties that matched our criteria, but somebody always outbid us. At one time she showed us 10 houses in one day and we finally found our home in Tampa Palms. We are highly satisfied with her work during the entire process including drafting our proposals, negotiation, communication, timeliness, post-closing service etc. We could not have asked for a real estate agent better than Theresa. She is knowledgeable, hardworking, and more than anything kind and patient. We will definitely work with Theresa again. We cannot thank Theresa enough for the kind gesture she showed when hurricane Ian was going to hit Tampa last September. We were not in town, and we had no idea what we needed to do. The only person we knew in Tampa was Theresa, our real estate agent. She drove to our new home and secured everything for us. We are forever grateful to her. So, if anybody is looking for a real estate agent Theresa is your person! She is there for you long after you have purchased your home. She goes above and beyond!! She is a 5-star real estate agent!!

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Excellent realtor

Theresa was a pleasure to work with, has a wonderful personality, and knows how to put an excellent proposal together. We will use her again in the future!

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Dedicated, Dedicated, Dedicated.

Vacation time, December of 2021, Christmas time, Teresa unselfishly spent time showing and arranging homes for us to see. Only had 2 weeks, finally had to head back to New Hampshire. Teresa continued diligently and, found us a beautiful home in Oaks Royal 3, we purchased this home on February 15th 2022, Teresa's interaction and help with the Mortgage Firm, we are so pleased with there assistance, we are permanent residence of beautiful Zephyerhills Florida. David & Susan Brooks

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Theresa is a great REA

Theresa has been very attentive to us from the beginning, looking at several properties, and helping us on various projects until we purchased this project. She even bought us supplies on our first day moving in from out-of-town and picked us from the airport. We appreciate Theresa and her professionalism and going above and beyond. I will highly recommend her to my network of REIs.

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
World-Class Experience

I worked with Theresa on the purchase of my property in Tampa Bay while living in Northern Virginia. Majority of the showings were via video and we met twice prior finding the one. She made my life easy and provide me insights on the market, transaction steps and helped me overcome hiccups. We got to the finish line successfully, I highly recommend working with her. Great experience!

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Very Personable & Knowledgeable

Theresa takes the time to know the market you are buying or selling in and ensures she is aligned with your goals while also assisting with realistic expectations. She really goes to bat for her clients when negotiating becomes necessary . Can’t say enough good things about my experience, I’ve worked with her on more than one sale and home purchase. Her work ethic has earned her an excellent reputation in real estate.

Theresa Reilley

Theresa Reilley

  5   (17 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Efficient, Helpful and Knowledgeable

We were moving from Miami and on a short deadline. Caitlin was able to accommodate our tight schedule, taking us to a dozen houses within our range the one day we were able to be in town. She helped us get a house under contract at an attractive price within a week of showings. She was our boots on the ground during the appraisal/inspection/closing process while we were in Miami with a new baby. Highly recommended.

Caitlin Cowden

Caitlin Cowden

  5   (3 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Giselle is the best!! She started searching for...

Giselle is the best!! She started searching for me before I was able to see properties in person, since I moved to Tampa from out of town. She really got to know what I was looking for, (this was during a very challenging time to buy a house)!! We went through several bids, and she found me the house that is just what I’d been looking for. Gisselle is professional, personable, and very patient! Her advice and direction is always thoughtful, down-to-earth, above and beyond to help you find the right property that fits your needs.

Gisselle Flores

Gisselle Flores

  5   (2 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Highly Recommend!

Brad was an excellent Buyer's agent for me. He knows the market and the areas very well and was able to add valueable input about some of my selections. He did not hesitate to add the good with the bad which is very important! My search lead us to properties and areas that made no sense (LOL) and yet Brad never lost patience or became annoyed. I'm glad that I was able to find him to be my agent and assist in getting me to the close of the condo. I would definately use Brad again! He's a gem!

Bradley Goldfinger

Bradley Goldfinger

  5   (18 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Such a pleasure

Caitlin was such a pleasure to work with. We shopped and found our home remotely from across the country. It couldn't have been any smoother. Caitlin's expertise in the whole process, her quickness in viewing properties and making offers with the correct parameters helped us get our dream home. We couldn't be happier and highly recommend Caitlin and the Compass team!

Caitlin Cowden

Caitlin Cowden

  5   (3 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Awesometastic

Amazing, down to earth, explained all the important stuff . Found our new home and paper work process at and before closing went smooth as melted butter . We love this house !!

Caitlin Cowden

Caitlin Cowden

  5   (3 reviews)
97 - 108 of 372
© 2026 RateMyAgent