Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
819 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
Experience with Roger Pettingell and his Team

Roger and his entire team did an excellent job in setting a proper sale price, marketing, showing the condo, providing advice about offers, reviewing comps in the community, answering questions and getting back to us on our calls requesting consultation.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 5 years ago
A 5 star agent

Yvette was absolutely INCREDIBLE throughout the process of selling our Bird Key home and purchasing a Longboat Key condo. She made the process seamless, oversaw pre-listing projects, provided a quick response to our inquiries, and communicated effectively with all necessary parties in order to ensure a smooth transition. Most importantly she truly cared about helping us find our perfect new home and offered valuable input as we weighed our options. Yvette was such a pleasure to work with and we will highly recommend her to everyone we know.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Hard Working, Compassionate and Listens

I give Eileen Gillen 5 stars. She is a hard working, warm, compassionate person who takes the time to listen to everyone. Being in the business of flipping homes for several years she offers experience, understanding and consequential practical knowledge of the real estate industry. She takes her responsibilities seriously and would make a great working partner in either the sale or purchase of a home!

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Exceeded expectations

Roger and his group were highly recommended to us when we decided to look for a home in Florida. His reputation for working with multi-million dollar transactions could have been intimidating, but his character, communication, dedication to our personal goals and his knowledge for the market quickly solidified we made the right choice. In fact, Roger exceeded our expectations. Once the transaction was complete, Roger did not walk away. He has followed up with us on several occasions and is super helpful as we familiarize ourselves with our new home!

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Shaun is so professional

Easy to work with and goes out of his way to provide answers to all your questions. Perfect if you're relocating from an other state!

Shaun Williams

Shaun Williams

  5   (5 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Experience and communication was the key

Scott was very helpful and courteous throughout the entire process. His communication was amazing and he constantly made efforts to make sure our questions were answered and even gave us information we hadn't even thought of. It was a great experience working with Scott and we felt we that he really valued our time together. Thank you very much Scott. We'll be calling you for the next one!

J Scott Norris

J Scott Norris

  5   (4 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Exemplary!

This is the second home we have purchased through Norma. With dogged determination and the patience of a saint, she found and showed us dozens of properties with never a hint of annoyance. Ever optimistic, her delightful attitude and perseverance to satisfy the seemingly polarized needs of my husband for a "country feel" and mine for a "sense of community," resulted in the perfect property. I love having a portal to explore all the listings within our chosen parameters, to review in my leisure. Norma makes herself available at a moment's notice with enthusiasm and open-mindedness. She is unquestionably one of the jewels in Sarasota's crown.

Norma Mladineo

Norma Mladineo

  5   (39 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Very good at keeping n touch

Shawn is very knowledgeable about the Sarasota market- Keyed in on what we were looking for quickly.

Shaun Williams

Shaun Williams

  5   (5 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Excellent Service

Norma has excellent and professional skills that go beyond words, she took and returned all of our calls and answered all our questions. And her mortgage lender skills helped us close on other house we bought. Great Real Estate Agent!

Norma Mladineo

Norma Mladineo

  5   (39 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Professional and Committed to her Clients

Jannette sold our condo on Longboat Key (in 3 days!) and supported us through the purchase of our new home in Sarasota. She was a pleasure to work with, always available and responsive during the buying and selling process. Jannette was on top of every detail and quickly resolved issues when they arose. She is honest, direct and ensures her clients are well represented. Bottom line Jannette gets the job done!!

Janette Schafer

Janette Schafer

  5   (21 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
"Caroline managed everything and even arranged to have large plants and a fountain removed from my d

Caroline managed everything and even arranged to have large plants and a fountain removed from my deck. She helped me stage the property for sale and advised me to make an investment in several upgrades prior to listing. I believe her suggestion made the property more attractive. It sold quickly to an out-of-town cash buyer sight-unseen and I recouped that investment. It was very good advice.

CAROLINE AMORY

CAROLINE AMORY

  5   (11 reviews)
601 - 612 of 819
© 2026 RateMyAgent