Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
818 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner.

My wife and I recently relocated to Sarasota from Chicago with our son. Alison helped us get to know Sarasota, learn the neighborhoods, and had recommendations for everything from the best parks for toddlers to contractors for renovations. She’s a one-stop-shop for relocation because she gets to know you and what you want, then knows exactly where to find it. We are going through an epic market rush at the moment and Alison always made time to squeeze us into “it just popped up!” showings. Alison is personable, friendly, the utmost professional and overall is just an amazing person to work with. When we found our dream house she transformed into a hard-hitting negotiator and landed us awesome deal. I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner. You could not find a better realtor to work with in the Sarasota area!

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Everything, 1st class

She is excellent. Does what says. Knows the market and gets results.

Kelly Rosenberg

Kelly Rosenberg

  5   (28 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Excellent agent Fantastic team!

Roger knows the market and has assembled a great team! He and his team are true professionals.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 5 years ago
One of the best!

Shaun was incredibly patient, always adjusting to our evolving requirements, helping us to learn about the local market quickly, working through multiple offers, inspections and reviews. We are happy with our purchase and he has always been available for follow-up questions and support.

Shaun Williams

Shaun Williams

  5   (5 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Fierce negotiator

My wife and I recently relocated to Sarasota from Chicago with our son. Alison helped us get to know Sarasota, learn the neighborhoods, and had recommendations for everything from the best parks for toddlers to contractors for renovations. She’s a one-stop-shop for relocation because she gets to know you and what you want, then knows exactly where to find it. We are going through an epic market rush at the moment and Alison always made time to squeeze us into “it just popped up!” showings. Alison is personable, friendly, the utmost professional and overall is just an amazing person to work with. When we found our dream house she transformed into a hard-hitting negotiator and landed us an amazing deal. I have no idea what magic she worked, but I’m so grateful to have had her in our corner! You could not find a better realtor to work with in the Sarasota area!

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 5 years ago
4009 casey key rd.

Excellent marketing & response!

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Great experience during another real estate transaction.

Norma's professionalism, communication skills, availability and attentiveness were great. Highly recommend this competent and hard working sprofessional.

Norma Mladineo

Norma Mladineo

  5   (39 reviews)
over 5 years ago
A seamless transition

Yvette was absolutely INCREDIBLE throughout the process of selling our Bird Key home and purchasing a Longboat Key condo. She made the process seamless, oversaw several pre-listing projects, kept in frequent contact, provided a quick response to our inquiries and communicated effectively with the necessary parties to ensure a successful transition. Most importantly, she truly cared about helping us find our perfect new home and provided valuable input as we weighed our options. Yvette was a pleasure to work with and we will highly recommend her to everyone we know.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 5 years ago
I can’t say enough good things about her!

My dealings with Alison we’re both professional and very very nice! I can’t say enough about the quality of her service, caring and professionalism even though I bought a less expensive home learn a lot in the area. She gave me the same great service that she would give to $1 million home buyer. I can’t say enough good things about her!! If you have the chance to use her for your real estate agent I strongly recommend it. You can’t go wrong!

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Excellent Representation

Candi Rosenthal was my realtor when I bought my condo and I wouldn't have chosen anyone else to represent me when I decided to sell. In this super heated market, Candi delivered superb service: fielding multiple offers, conferring with and counseling me, explaining pages and pages of documents, and overall providing the patient and calm presence I needed to close on the sale of my condo. It was a super fast closing (two weeks) and she made sure everything was in place to get it done. I cannot recommend Candi Rosenthal enough and encourage anyone interested in buying or selling to contact Candi Rosenthal.

Candi Rosenthal

Candi Rosenthal

  5   (4 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Pleasant Persistence Pays....

We are very excited about our home purchase. Yvette was instrumental in convincing the seller to engage with us and ultimately agree to sell his beautiful home to us. She is such a pleasure to work with and got compliments not only from us, but from the seller for her pleasant demeanor and persistence. She's been more than just a broker for us. She's a real partner. I'd recommend her to anyone.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Bought and sold with Shaun

Hi! Shaun is the consummate professional, listens to your preferences, is communicative, responsive; everything you want in a realtor; not to mention, a super great person!

Shaun Williams

Shaun Williams

  5   (5 reviews)
565 - 576 of 818
© 2026 RateMyAgent