Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
817 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Attentive, Caring and Knowledgeable Agent

We worked with Yvette Sellyn on the purchase of our new home on Siesta Key. Yvette was a wonderful agent for us. She was detail-oriented and looked out for our best interests throughout our search and the purchase of our new home. She listened carefully to us and advocated for our needs throughout the process, and even after the sale had completed. We would highly recommend Yvette.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Outstanding Service and Knowledge

Monica and her team of highly knowledgeable professionals helped us both buy a home and several years later, sell a home. We truly can’t say enough about the attention to detail, knowledge of the greater Sarasota market, and tenacity to help you achieve your goals. Communication was constant, open and honest. They truly work as a team with you. This is one of the most important decisions you make in your life, where to live. You want the best working with you. And that is Monica and her team.

Monica Verinder

Monica Verinder

  5   (48 reviews)
over 3 years ago
The greatest realtor ever !!!

Steve is the complete professional when you would ever need a realtor He is the “goat” of real estate

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (163 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Outstanding guidance in RE transactions at "The Oaks"

Steve has been an excellent help in my R.E transactions at The Oaks for many years. He sought to understand weel our needs and narrowed his search, and our time, to a few matches. The before and after sales services and support provided by Steve and Wendy were just perfect: complete, of best quality and timely. I recommend the team wholeheartedly.

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (163 reviews)
over 3 years ago
From start to finish, Alison's professionalism, expertise, and dedication were truly outstanding

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Alison Stottlemyer, an outstanding realtor who went above and beyond to make our home buying experience smooth and enjoyable. From start to finish, Alison's professionalism, expertise, and dedication were truly outstanding. First and foremost, Alison's knowledge of the local real estate market was unparalleled. She has a deep understanding of the neighborhood we were interested in and provided invaluable insights into the current market trends, pricing, and available properties. Alison's guidance helped us make informed decisions throughout the process. What truly sets Alison apart is her exceptional communication skills. She was always available to answer any questions, address any concerns, and provide regular updates. Her promptness in responding to emails, calls, and texts demonstrated her commitment to keeping us informed every step of the way. Alison's attention to detail is remarkable, taking time to understand our preferences, needs, and budget, and meticulously curating a list of properties that matched our criteria was amazing. Alison also has a keen eye for spotting both the potential and flaws of a property which was invaluable during our house tours. We truly felt that Alison had our best interests at heart, guiding us towards the right home rather than just closing a deal. Finally, Alison's network of professionals, including mortgage brokers, home inspectors, and lawyers, was top-notch. She provided recommendations for reliable and trustworthy service providers, which made the entire home buying process seamless and stress-free. Overall, we cannot recommend Alison highly enough. Her dedication and expertise made a significant impact on our home buying journey. If you're in need of a realtor who will go the extra mile to ensure you find the right home for you and your family, look no further. Alison is simply the best in the business!

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Magnificent home buying experience

Residential real estate is personal and emotional for both the buyer and seller. We were out of state buyers who made multiple trips to Sarasota and walked numerous houses. Eileen and Brian consistently reminded us to “be guided by what you want in a home, there is no need to compromise or rush, it may take longer than expected, but we are here for you regardless of the length of time”. At times the home search can be exhausting, but we were always reminded “there is no rush nor a need to compromise”. We lived outside of FL, thus some of our trips to visit houses were on short notice, Eileen and Brian always found the flexibility to arrange showings, regardless of the day of the week. The characteristic that elevates Eileen and Brian above other seasoned realtors is their genuine care and concern that their client is fully informed and comfortable throughout the entire process. Although it took multiple trips to FL and many showings, we did not compromise nor rush, and are thrilled to be in a home we absolutely love

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Amazing Agent in Sarasota

Yvette helped me navigate the changing real estate market and find a property that fits my stage of life. She went above and beyond in meeting trades people for quotes while I was still living out of state. She always did it with a smile. I’m also glad to now call her a neighbor and a friend. Highly recommend her!

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Buying a House CAN be fun!

Buying a house can be daunting and overwhelming. But with the help of Eileen and Brian, it wasn't. They are there for you every step of the way. No matter how many questions or calls, they responded to every one. It truly was a blessing to have every one of our concerns addressed promptly and efficiently. Thank you Eileen and Brian for your constant support and guidance and patience throughout this process. We are grateful for your kindness and wisdom!

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 3 years ago
I absolutely loved working with Alison

I absolutely loved working with Alison. I was looking for a home long distance and I can certainly say that she went above and beyond to help me in finding the perfect property. I will definitely use her again and recommend her to others as I already have;-)

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Exemplary Service

In this competitive real estate market, Monica asked key questions and gave expert advice to ensure we were in our desired location (top rated school district), safety rated home, within our financial means, and meeting our standards in order to secure a quality home purchase.

Monica Verinder

Monica Verinder

  5   (48 reviews)
over 3 years ago
All Star, Monica is the Best of the Best!

Monica is an amazing realtor and a fantastic person. She always looks out to protect your interest. She consistently communicated throughout the process. We found a home for sale by “open door” ….They were impossible to deal with but somehow Monica managed to push through and got us a great deal on a great house with a not so great seller. I don’t believe anyone but Monica could’ve closed on this house and I will never use anyone but her to buy a home in the future. I cannot recommend anyone except HER!

Monica Verinder

Monica Verinder

  5   (48 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Yvette satisfies the social aspects of what you want from a location and property

Any agent can find you a property that fits your price and building characteristics from a publicly available list. If you live in the market you are searching, then that is sufficient. Coming from out of town we also wanted a property that fits our social needs: type of community, access, services, transport, schools, social standing, crime and safety. We didnt know how to judge, in a new city, where the things we valued back home were located. We wanted someone who understood this need and not someone who drove us all over town throwing darts at a dart board. Yvette is that woman who understood us first in order to better target a search.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
325 - 336 of 817
© 2026 RateMyAgent