Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
45 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, friendly, well-prepared, responsive, patient, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Sherry has worked with us for almost a year to find our perfect home
over 1 year ago
Sherry has worked with us for almost a year to find our perfect home

Sherry has worked with us for almost a year to find our perfect home. She was always positive and kept us on track during this journey. She has been responsive to all of our questions and led us through the process of making offers and counter offers. We couldn’t have done this search without her guidance. We really appreciate Sherry’s level of experience and professionalism.

Sherry Poynter

Sherry Poynter

  5   (22 reviews)
Seller review
Jill with Carpenter Realtors was an exceptional help throughout the entire process of selling my hom
over 1 year ago
Jill with Carpenter Realtors was an exceptional help throughout the entire process of selling my hom

Jill with Carpenter Realtors was an exceptional help throughout the entire process of selling my home. She explained the home selling process so that I could understand all that was going to take place. She was quick in getting the best photos of my home, they looked great. My home sold really quick, and I was very pleased with that. Just what I needed. Thank you so much Jill and Carpenter Realtors.

Jill Turner

Jill Turner

  5   (19 reviews)
Buyer review
Jill was fantastic during and after our entire home buying process
over 1 year ago
Jill was fantastic during and after our entire home buying process

Jill was fantastic during and after our entire home buying process. We were moving from out of state on a short timeline due to a job relocation and she made herself available whenever we needed to see homes, discuss next steps, and coordinate closing. While we couldn't do a walkthrough before closing, she offered to do it herself and show us via FaceTime to ensure everything was in order. Her responsiveness and availability made it possible to find a home and close within two months. Her knowledge was also invaluable. This is not our first time buying a home but it is the first time in Indiana and she guided us through the process and some of the differences that we were not aware of. Her expertise and negotiating skills were key during the different offer discussions and she proved that we could trust her judgement. Even after we have closed, she's supported us. There is an issue with our home that we will be using our Home Warranty for, and when I told her she immediately offered assistance in ensuring that process went smoothly. I would highly recommend Jill to anyone looking to buy a home in Indianapolis and if we ever move locally in the future we would definitely work with her again.

Jill Turner

Jill Turner

  5   (19 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent,  caring service
over 1 year ago
Excellent, caring service

Excellent, caring service. I have a new friend that understood my needs. So grateful for her patience and understanding. Highly recommend!

Sherry Poynter

Sherry Poynter

  5   (22 reviews)
Buyer review
It was a truly an amazing experience working with Jill
almost 2 years ago
It was a truly an amazing experience working with Jill

It was a truly an amazing experience working with Jill. She was supportive and always helped us through our ups and downs looking for a home and when we finally decided to purchase a new home she was continually there for the entire process helping with selection of inside and outside work. Her expertise and watchful eyes made sure things were going smoothly and correctly. Thank you Jill.

Jill Turner

Jill Turner

  5   (19 reviews)
Seller review
Always available to answer questions
about 2 years ago
Always available to answer questions

Always available to answer questions. Guidance through the selling process was awesome. Thank you!

Jill Turner

Jill Turner

  5   (19 reviews)
Seller review
Jill did a great job!
about 2 years ago
Jill did a great job!

Jill did a great job! Always answered our questions and kept things moving smoothly.Thank you!

Jill Turner

Jill Turner

  5   (19 reviews)
Seller review
Sherry helped my mom sell her house
almost 3 years ago
Sherry helped my mom sell her house

Sherry helped my mom sell her house. She was encouraging and always went the extra mile. From preparing the house for pictures all the way to the closing. She made the process very easy. I want to thank Sherry for always treating us like family and for all the hard work she put into selling the house. We appreciate you!

Sherry Poynter

Sherry Poynter

  5   (22 reviews)
25 - 36 of 45
Carpenter Realtors - Geist
Contact Carpenter Realtors - Geist
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent