Carpenter Realtors - Geist - Verified Reviews & Real Estate For Sale

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Carpenter Realtors - Geist has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

Reviews

Properties for sale

Sold properties

$378k

Average sale price

$20m

Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 6 agents at Carpenter Realtors - Geist.

Sherry Poynter

REALTOR®

(22 reviews)

About Sherry

In 1981, Sherry Poynter learned the true meaning of "sweat equity" when she and her husband, Pete, purchased a fixer-upper and navigated a 16% interest rate mortgage. That experience didn't just teach her how to swing a hammer-it ignited a lifelong passion for helping others navigate the complexities of homeownership. Since joining Carpenter Realtors in 1998, Sherry has consistently been recognized as a monthly sales and listing leader. Her approach is rooted in education; she believes an informed client is a successful one. Whether you are buying your first home, building a custom dream house, or searching for the perfect retirement retreat, Sherry provides expert guidance through every stage of life. Beyond the paperwork, Sherry understands that a home is where memories are made. To her, there's no better reward than a backyard cookout with family and friends-and she's dedicated to helping you find the perfect place to host yours.

View Profile

Jill Turner

REALTOR®

(19 reviews)

About Jill

I am a dedicated real estate professional with a passion for helping clients achieve their homeownership and investment dreams. Licensed in 2011, I have established a reputation for excellence, integrity, and a deep understanding of the real estate market. Born and raised in Indianapolis, my clients benefit from my comprehensive knowledge of local markets, negotiation skills, and ability to adapt to changing market conditions. I take pride in providing personalized service, guiding clients through every step of the real estate process, and ensuring their transactions are seamless and stress-free. I continue to stay updated with the latest industry trends and technologies to offer my clients the best possible experience. My commitment to excellence, combined with my passion for real estate, has allowed me to build lasting relationships and achieve remarkable results in the ever-evolving world of real estate. Beyond real estate, I volunteer at the Hope Center Indianapolis. My interests extend to various activities, including a passion for exploring new destinations, crafting endeavors, indulging in mystery novels, and maintaining an active lifestyle through exercise. My husband and two wonderful children are a source of boundless love and endless surprises. We cherish the moments we spend together, creating lasting memories and building a strong foundation of love and support for one another.

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Lisa Crooks

REALTOR®

(3 reviews)

About Lisa

Lisa has 5 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile

Jodi Hettermann Blume

REALTOR®

(1 review)

About Jodi

I have always had a passion for helping others. I went to Butler University and have worked as a Physician Assistant for over 20 years in areas including Nuclear Medicine, Neurosurgery and Wellness Based Family Practice. Now I am helping clients sell their homes and find their first home, their growing family home, their forever home or their down-sizing home. Helping my clients sell their homes and find the home they love and want to build their dream lives in, no matter what stage of life they are in, is very rewarding for me. I have two very active boys and you will find us at the baseball fields, basketball courts or on cross country trails in our free time. Spending time with my family healthy cooking, working out and skiing the mountains in the winter and on the lake in the summer. I also enjoy golfing which is definitely a work in progress game for me. I am also a certified wellness life coach and as your Realtor I will work hard for you and with you to sell your home and to find you the right home that fits all your lifestyle needs in the home you will love! I look forward to working with you to find the perfect fit for you and your family.

View Profile

Angela Apley

REALTOR®

About Angela

Angela currently has 5 active property listings and 3 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile

Ellen " ET " Fox, RN

REALTOR®

About Ellen " ET "

Ellen's Sellin' -YOUR GEIST GAL !! CALL her now !! Ellen "ET" Fox, RN and an Associate Real Estate Broker, is now a GEIST neighborhood resident joining Carpenter Realtors at Geist ! "ET"s RN career started with Mariner Health Care, where she was the VP of Marketing and Admissions, facilitating patients into Mariner's nationwide subacute and skilled nursing facilities. Ellen contributed to the placement of patients into appropriate rehab facilities and now "ET" places her clients into their "DREAM HOMES". With ET the possibilities are endless..... After 27 years selling over 556 homes on the shoreline in CT. and RI , Ellen looks forward to providing home buyers and sellers in the GEIST AREA with professional, responsive and attentive real estate services. Ellen represents integrity, energy, hard work, and creative service in every aspect of your transaction. Need an agent who really listens to what you want in a home? Need an agent who knows how to effectively market your home so it sells? Whether buying, selling, investing or renting, Ellen will apply her expertise, market knowledge, and consult with you to streamline the process. Let her help you find your DREAM HOME !! CALL her now !!

View Profile

About us

Carpenter Realtors' Geist office proudly serves buyers and sellers throughout the Geist area and surrounding northeast Indianapolis communities. Our knowledgeable agents specialize in a variety of property types, including waterfront homes, luxury residences, family neighborhoods, and new construction. Backed by Carpenter Realtors' award-winning marketing and extensive professional network, we deliver personalized service designed to make every transaction successful while helping clients enjoy the exceptional lifestyle the Geist community offers.

Buyer review

12 days ago

Jill understood my needs, answered every question, and guided me every step of the way.

Jill Turner was fantastic to work with! She was professional, knowledgeable, and responsive. Her dedication, attention to detail, and commitment to her clients really set her apart. She really understood the type and style of home I was looking for and went above and beyond to find the right fit. She made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I highly recommend Jill to anyone looking to buy or sell a home! Thank you, Jill, for making the experience such a positive one!

Jill Turner

(19 reviews)

Seller review

17 days ago

Great and very easy to work with!

Lisa was a great realtor to work with. She was very responsive and informative throughout our time with her. Anytime we requested to see a house, she got us in right away. And when it was time to sell our house, she clearly made every effort to make it as smooth and as easy for us as possible. She was fantastic to work with and I would highly recommend working with her whether you’re looking to buy or sell a home!

Lisa Crooks

(3 reviews)

Buyer review

2 months ago

Excellent communicator

She kept us informed and answered our questions in a timely manner

Lisa Crooks

(3 reviews)

Seller review

3 months ago

Calm, logical guidance made the transaction a breeze

Jill has a special talent of sharing her wisdom and knowledge of the market with her clients while allowing you to have the final say without feeling any pressure. Jill has sold two homes for me and I have been highly satisfied each time.

Jill Turner

(19 reviews)

Seller review

3 months ago

Jill is a consummate professional. efficient,

Jill was organized, efficient, proactive and engaged in every aspect of this listing. Within one week, we had two offers. Jill guided us to an on time closing and helped negotiate every issue that arose. I highly recommend her as an experienced and extremely capable agent.

Jill Turner

(19 reviews)

Seller review

3 months ago

Sherry was very efficient and professional. My house was sold quickly and for a good price.

She led me through the entire process and gave me helpful advice on preparing my house for sale. I recommend Sherry to anyone who wants to sell their property.

Sherry Poynter

(22 reviews)

Our properties