Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
29 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, attentive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Rich is the absolute best! He has been my realtor for almost 15 years and 3 moves
10 months ago
Rich is the absolute best! He has been my realtor for almost 15 years and 3 moves

Rich is the absolute best! He has been my realtor for almost 15 years and 3 moves. He is so patient with questions, concerns, and navigating the buying and selling process. During this move, circumstances were different and he handled each situation (even when bizarre) amazing. I have, and will continue to, recommend Rich to everyone that needs a realtor.

Rich Costello

Rich Costello

  5   (17 reviews)
Seller review
Cheryl was awesome and made the whole process extremely smooth!
over 1 year ago
Cheryl was awesome and made the whole process extremely smooth!

Cheryl was awesome and made the whole process extremely smooth. She was always keeping us updated and was always there to answer all of our questions and able to explain things so that we understood. I will definitely recommend her if I know someone needing a realtor.

Cheryl Wilson

Cheryl Wilson

  5   (1 review)
Seller review
This year we bought a home in Batesville, In
about 2 years ago
This year we bought a home in Batesville, In

This year we bought a home in Batesville, In. and began the process of all it takes to sell our Indianapolis home of 45 years. We hired Rich to be our real estate partner in both transactions. The buying of our Batesville home was an easy one, but the selling of our historic, lovely old home was more difficult than I could ever explain. With Rich’s guidance and wisdom we survived the four months it took to do the proper repairs, updating, staging and clearing to make it the perfect home in the eyes of a buyer. As a retired realtor I had helped others sell and purchase many homes but I couldn’t emotionally step away from my own home to make the right decisions to sell it. We leaned on Rich multiple times for any doubts and tough decisions. He carried the stress of the marketing and advertising, hired a great photographer, advocated our needs and desires with other realtors and buyers, help us with the pricing, and practically held our hands at the closing table. It takes a professional and caring real estate partner such as Rich to make one of most stressful times of one’s life not so bad at all. I wish I could shout it to the world, “please contact Rich Costello before you buy or sell your home”.

Rich Costello

Rich Costello

  5   (17 reviews)
Seller review
I would give her a 5 star
about 2 years ago
I would give her a 5 star

I would give her a 5 star. Would reccomend Mary Anne to fiends and family. She was great!

Mary Anne Ehrgott

Mary Anne Ehrgott

  5   (6 reviews)
Buyer review
I think MaryAnne Ehrgott is very knowledgeable
about 2 years ago
I think MaryAnne Ehrgott is very knowledgeable

I think MaryAnne Ehrgott is very knowledgeable. She is able to explain the process from beginning to end in a way that I understand. I have recommended her to many family and friends.

Mary Anne Ehrgott

Mary Anne Ehrgott

  5   (6 reviews)
Buyer review
Working with Rich was awesome
about 2 years ago
Working with Rich was awesome

Working with Rich was awesome. He's on point and knows the ends and out . This we our first home purchase experience and we couldn't have asked for a better realtor to help us through the process.

Rich Costello

Rich Costello

  5   (17 reviews)
13 - 24 of 29
Carpenter Realtors - East
Contact Carpenter Realtors - East
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent