Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
355 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
over 4 years ago
The Absolute BEST Realtor in the Florida. *****5 Stars

Our home was on the market for nearly 40 days with ANOTHER agent/agency, at a time period of what looked to be a surging market. We made the hard decision to terminate our listing agreement and hire Gary Dale. My wife and Mother-in-law had just happen to run into Gary at a mall that he was listing. They were so impressed with his professionalism, mannerism and especially his patriotism that they had asked him for a card and expressed to him that we were wanting to sell our waterfront home in Englewood. Gary (based in Sarasota an hour drive away) jumped on board and within 3 days he had 23-30 people show up for an open house (prior agent had 2 open houses and a total 4 people show up) Gary Dale had us a cash offer I believe in 10-14 days after he listed the property. This was not the end of Gary's do diligence, Gary went above and beyond even after the closing of our home to make sure that all of our needs were met. In closing; I don't think there was one single time Gary didn't pick up his phone when I called him and his communication with the whole process was spot on. I personally think that Gary Dale would be successful in any career choice he would have made in his life. When it comes down to it, Gary's Core Values and Attention to details is what sets Gary on the the Top Shelf of all the good people I have encountered in my 53 years on the planet. You will absolutely not go wrong with Hiring Gary Dale as your Realtor Thank You Gary !!!

Gary Dale

Gary Dale

  5   (15 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Excellent Realtor

We have worked with MaryAnn in the past and have always reached out to her for our real estate needs. MaryAnn is the very best at keeping on top of things and keeping her customers informed of all matters, every step of the way. She is easy to talk to, answers all questions, gives great advice and responds to any concerns quickly. We would not think of using any other agent to help us with any future real estate transactions.

MaryAnn Fenton,P.A.

MaryAnn Fenton,P.A.

  5   (17 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Michelle made the process quick, easy & perfect!

Michelle took the time to know exactly what we were looking for and sent listings that mirrored that. We were searching from Ohio and couldn’t be there in person. Michelle would actually drive the distance from one point to another and tell us how long it took and how many turns were involved - just part of the attention to details she provided. She provided virtual tours and showed us any concerns in addition to all the features. We are thrilled with our new home and appreciate all the personal service and help Michelle gave us!

Michelle Pino

Michelle Pino

  5   (18 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Excelent agent

Bought all my 3 properties with Bob. He solved a lot of problems that came at the last minute. I really recommend him.

Bob Stahlschmidt

Bob Stahlschmidt

  5   (41 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Highly experienced professional

I highly recommend Bob Stahlschmidt for all your real estate needs. Bob helped me to find the perfect property in a great area. He always answered my questions in a timely manner. Bob knows his stuff and he really cares about his clients. I can't say enough about how grateful I am to have worked with Bob.

Bob Stahlschmidt

Bob Stahlschmidt

  5   (41 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Great experience!

Michelle was great and knowledgeable, answered all questions and was always available to give advice. A great experience!

Michelle Pino

Michelle Pino

  5   (18 reviews)
over 4 years ago
I'd use Bob Stahlschmidt AGAIN!

Bob was extremely helpful and went out of his way to make everything go smoothly!

Bob Stahlschmidt

Bob Stahlschmidt

  5   (41 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Bob was a pleasure to work with

Bob did an excellent job of helping me find my new home. He always responded quickly to my questions and he was able to give me referrals to competent specialists for all my home related needs. Bob is incredibly knowledgeable, honest, and reliable. I am so grateful Bob for everything he has done for me.

Bob Stahlschmidt

Bob Stahlschmidt

  5   (41 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Hard-working!

Diane is a hard worker and a pleasure to work with!

Diane McDonald

Diane McDonald

  4.9   (12 reviews)
over 4 years ago
She is excellent; always on top of thins

Michelle was great to work with. We had bought other investment properties from her prior to buying our personal residence. She was very knowledgeable of the market and was always ready to answer questions regarding the properties she was showing us. She was also very helpful during negotiation process when emotions ran high. Followup work was her 2nd nature; we were able to close earlier than expected. We definitely will work with her again.

Michelle Pino

Michelle Pino

  5   (18 reviews)
over 4 years ago
A VERY BRIGHT DAY

Reliable,Helpfull, with words of incouragement to stay the course. Diane, MADE MY DAY A VERY BRIGHT DAY INDEED !! Thank`s again ,Diane for all you did. David

Diane McDonald

Diane McDonald

  4.9   (12 reviews)
over 4 years ago
We would highly recommend Bill McCue based on our positive experience.

We met Bill McCue when we were searching for a condo in Siesta Key. We are Canadian citizens and were not certain of the issues we might face when purchasing a seasonal property in Florida. Bill is very affable and patiently stepped us through all of the issues we should be aware of from the initial showing, to the offer, the negotiations and then to the closing. He provided guidance and suggestions about even the smallest details which we inquired about, and there were many I can assure you. We felt very confident through the entire process and are very satisfied with the outcome of our purchase. It was a pleasure to deal with Bill who was very professional, knowledgeable and kept us informed during every part of the buying process. We would highly recommend Bill McCue based on our positive experience. Larry and Betty McFadden

Bill McCue

Bill McCue

  5   (136 reviews)
85 - 96 of 355
© 2026 RateMyAgent