Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

Reviews

177

Properties for sale

148

Sold properties

$620k

Average sale price

$91.7m

Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 20 agents at Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate.

Judy Niemeyer

Associate Broker / Owner

(37 reviews)

About Judy

Judy Niemeyer is a well-known real estate agent based in Fairhope, AL. 1. **Professional Background**: Judy Niemeyer is associated with Ashurst & Niemeyer LLC in Fairhope, AL. She provides homebuyers and sellers with professional, responsive, and attentive real estate services. She emphasizes listening to her clients' needs and effectively marketing homes for sale. 2. **Experience**: Judy Niemeyer has a significant presence in the real estate industry with almost 40 years of dedicated service. She has received numerous awards and is recognized for her professionalism, experience, and knowledge. Judy is the guiding spirit for The Judy Niemeyer Team. 3. **Personal Background**: Judy graduated from the University of Alabama with a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Education. She is married to Carlton Niemeyer and is a mother of two children. She also has five grandchildren. In her leisure time, Judy enjoys traveling, playing tennis, and bridge. 4. **Community Involvement**: Judy Niemeyer is deeply connected to the Fairhope and Eastern Shore community. She has actively served with several organizations, including the CARE House Board (a non-profit Baldwin County Child Advocacy Center), Impact 100 of Baldwin County, Exceptional Foundation, Eastern Shore Art Center, and Baldwin County Humane Society, among others. 5. **Additional Information**: Judy offers virtual tours for properties, allowing prospective buyers to experience properties through an interactive 3D virtual tour. This technology provides a convenient way for potential buyers to explore properties from their computers. If you'd like more detailed information or have any other questions, please let me know!

View Profile

Staci Niemeyer

REALTOR®

(13 reviews)

About Staci

No one knows Eastern Shore style better than Staci. She has helped many area families and professionals achieve homes and offices that are both functional and beautiful through her creative planning, decorating and staging services. She has added real estate agent to the skill set available to our clients. Staci can see the potential in any property, helping clients see the value in a property beyond what the eye readily sees. Staci brings her past planning and decorating experience, and as well as a passion for all things “home”, when helping her clients find a new home or preparing their current one for the market. She has lived in the area for 35 years and is enthusiastic about helping those wishing to join our community or those already living here to find the right place for the next stage of their lives. Staci is active in several programs through the Catholic Church and organ donation advocacy. She attended the University of Alabama. She and her husband, Michael, have three children- Michael, Jr., Preston and Maggie- and six grandchildren. The Eastern Shore community has been there for them and they are grateful to be part of such an exceptional place. She looks forward to helping you discover your place in our community.

View Profile

Colin McBrearty

Associate Broker / REALTOR® / Sales Agent

(10 reviews)

About Colin

Colin McBrearty is an experienced Associate Broker and Sales Agent with extensive knowledge in the Baldwin County real estate markets. His commitment to providing exceptional service and market knowledge makes him a reliable partner for those looking to buy or sell in the vibrant South Alabama regions. Colin’s local insight and professional acumen, coupled with his proactive approach to real estate, ensure that each client’s experience is personalized and successful. Choose Colin McBrearty for a dedicated and knowledgeable real estate partner in Fairhope and Daphne, Alabama.

View Profile

Knox M McMurphy

REALTOR®

(2 reviews)

About Knox M

My mission in real estate is to ensure every client has an exceptional experience on their journey. In today’s competitive market, you need an agent who’s a savvy negotiator, deeply knowledgeable about the market, and brings years of experience to the table. With 25 successful years in real estate, I like to think of my career as a football game — a team effort with many valuable players, coaches, and behind-the-scenes talent contributing to every client’s success. As an Associate Broker with Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate, a boutique company with a significant market presence in Baldwin County, I’ve found both a professional home and a fulfilling career. I’ve lived throughout Baldwin County — Orange Beach, Ono Island, Fairhope, and even the Mobile area — and I bring a local’s perspective to every client I work with. From growing up baiting hooks to my love for deep-sea fishing, hunting, and golf, I’ve always felt at home here. I studied Interior Design at Mississippi State University, and family has always been at the heart of my life. I was married to the late Edward Robinson McMurphy, and between us, we’ve been blessed with three boys, three girls, and thirteen grandchildren. Community involvement is a passion of mine. I’ve proudly served on the boards of Impact 100 and Big Brothers Big Sisters, helping drive positive change in Baldwin County. I’m a Season Sponsor for the Eastern Shore Repertory Theatre and a dedicated member of the Fairhope Tree Commission. As a long-time Board Director for Baldwin Realtors and Chair of the ARPAC Committee, I’ve worked to protect property rights by raising funds for local candidates. In 2023, I was deeply honored to be named Realtor of the Year — a highlight of my career and a recognition I’m sincerely grateful for. “I am so proud to have my daughter, Mary Knox Bixler, join me in this exciting real estate adventure. Working together as a team, we are committed to providing exceptional service, expertise, and dedication to our clients. It’s a joy to share this journey with her and to help families find their perfect homes together!”

View Profile

Nancy Weltlich

REALTOR®

(2 reviews)

About Nancy

Nancy holds an Undergraduate degree in Physical Education and Masters degree in Health from The University of Memphis. A Realtor for over 30 years, she’s been licensed in four states. Born and raised in St. Louis, Missouri, she considers herself the “Token Yankee” of our team. Married to Bob Weltlich, Division 1 basketball coach for six universities, they have two grown children, Casey and Chad. Nancy currently resides in Fairhope and previously lived in Mobile. Her knowledge of both Baldwin and Mobile counties brings credibility to her experience and assists in helping both first time homebuyers or seasoned real estate owners find just the right place to call Home! In her spare time, Nancy officiates high school volleyball games and junior and college tennis. She loves playing tennis and spending time at the beach.

View Profile

Spencer Lane

REALTOR®

(1 review)

About Spencer

Spencer Lane is originally from St. Louis, Missouri and comes from a long line of family history involved with real estate. Spencer is honored to carry on his family tradition in the beautiful Town of Fairhope, Alabama. He grew up in St. Louis playing competitive golf which later carried him down to the Gulf Coast playing for Spring Hill College in Mobile. Following graduation from Spring Hill College, Spencer ventured out west to the Rocky Mountains of Breckenridge, Colorado where his career as a Real Estate Broker began. Spencer focused on building his business from scratch and seized every opportunity, turning strangers into clients, and clients into friends. Since becoming licensed in 2016, Spencer has achieved over $70M in real estate sales. He attributes his success to a hard-working hustle attitude and establishing everlasting relationships based on honesty, loyalty, and always being available to his clients. “Real Estate has no concept of time, and when it strikes, I am ready for action.” After years of snowboarding in the mountains, competitive golf started making its way back into Spencer’s life. He began visiting back down south perfecting his craft at Lakewood Golf Club, traveling on the mini tours, and continuing to sell real estate in Colorado to finance it all. The southern lifestyle, Fairhope charm, and passion for golf had his full attention. He knew the south had his heart again and would need to make it home. Spencer has received his Real Estate License in the State of Alabama and is ready to make your real estate endeavors come true.

View Profile

About us

Local Wisdom. Real Results." Since 2009, Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate has been a leading presence in Fairhope. We help homeowners and buyers across Fairhope, Daphne, Spanish Fort, Point Clear, Montrose, Gulf Shores, Orange Beach, and Baldwin County buy and sell with confidence. Our local advisors combine decades of deep market knowledge, strategic pricing guidance, professional listing exposure, and personal service to help buyers, investors, and sellers make smart decisions in a changing real estate market. Whether you are buying or selling a primary home, waterfront property, investment property, land, or a second home on the Alabama Gulf Coast, our team is here to guide you from pricing to closing. Call an advisor at 251.928.9265.

Seller review

about 14 hours ago

Exceptional Expertise

I've worked with Judy on three separate transactions now, and I cannot recommend her highly enough. Judy brings a level of expertise, calm guidance, and dedicated negotiation that makes every step seamless. Her professionalism and consistent execution make her my top recommendation for anyone looking for exceptional real estate representation.

Judy Niemeyer

(37 reviews)

Seller review

5 days ago

Excellent Realtor with a proven track record of success in Baldwin County

Judy Niemeyer is the best, hardest working realtor in Baldwin County. She has sold two of our homes and represented us very well on both sales. A true professional that knows the market, what works, what doesn’t and is very honest when providing feedback and recommendations on how to put your house in the best possible position to sell. She has a great staff to support her efforts and her pictures and MLS listings showcased our property and everything each home has to offer to interested buyers. If you’re in the market to sell or buy, it would highly recommend you talk with Judy! You will not be disappointed! She is an excellent realtor and an even better person. Judy uses all the latest tools and market data to help show your property. Her follow up and communication was key to making our experience working with her a successful one . She tracks trends, makes adjustments and makes recommendations that truly worked to help get us to the best possible outcome. We are so glad we worked with Judy! Very grateful for all her time and expertise in real estate!

Judy Niemeyer

(37 reviews)

Seller review

over 1 year ago

The Very Best !

Judy was great...handled all our details. Made our sale so easy and sold our home on day #1. We would never use anyone else. What a Professional! Plus she is a such a nice lady.

Judy Niemeyer

(37 reviews)

Seller review

over 1 year ago

Really great to work with!

Judy was quit to reply to questions I had and was a huge help getting the house ready to sell. Lots of people needed to be contacted and Judy did it all. A really Great Agent

Judy Niemeyer

(37 reviews)

Seller review

over 1 year ago

Expert knowledge and amazing help.

I live out of state. Judy recommended companies for all the necessary work on the Villa: windows, doors, roof, carpets. It all worked out beautifully. She worked tirelessly getting the Villa ready to sell, and satisfying the demands of the buyer.

Judy Niemeyer

(37 reviews)

Seller review

almost 2 years ago

Great communication skills and had the ability to provide support in many ways.

Can’t do justice in this limited space for the knowledge of marketing and problem solving Nancy has. She has helped turn around a problem with a remedy to it. After a contract falling through due to code changes she helped guide me to contractors that were not only top notch but lower than other bids. Through the ups and downs of selling my home, she helped me with ideas to help secure a buyer. I would encourage buyers and sellers to communicate with Nancy!

Nancy Weltlich

(2 reviews)

Our properties