
Matthew Rutherford
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
NICOLE MCQUEEN
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here


Sarah Morris
Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 6536 201st Avenue Southwest, Grand Mound
As in any complex situation, we had many questions and concerns along the journey to completion. We were always pleased when we received a prompt response to every single text and/or email we sent to her. We not once, had to wait for her to get needed information we requested. Her prompt, professional and thorough responses took so much stress off our shoulders. The moving boxes kit she provided, also helped to make the move easier right from the start. We were very encouraged to hear other professionals along the way, refer to Sarah as “One of the very best”! She was referred to us by a family member, and we are grateful for that. We have no doubt that this whole experience would have been much different had we chosen a different person.
Buyer of 2074 West Cloquallum Road, Shelton
This purchase went through smoothly and quickly. Sarah has gathered a team of experts to help all areas of finding and buying a new home. A previous contract had multiple failures due to the listing agent not having done their due diligence… Sarah and her team jumped through hoops attempting to do what should have already been done, and then helped us find the better property for us to fall in love with as our new Home 💐
Seller of 3108 Banks Lane Southwest, Tumwater
Sarah responded very quickly to each and every question we had. She gave meaningful information about the processes and expectations involved. Her calming approach to the entire situation helped keep things in perspective and allowed us to focus on the aspects of the transaction where we could have the greatest impact. She has a great sense of humor and was very respectful of our concerns.
County Winner
Pierce County2026County Top 5
Thurston County2026City Winner
Olympia2026
Melanie Newcomb
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 884 Fairmount Avenue, Shelton
Melanie is an agent that will work her butt off for you. I have had several real estate transactions with her over the past few years now. She has definitely gone well above my expectations on them all, but this one especially. If you are looking for someone that has your best interests in mind then look no further and hire Melanie Newcomb!
Buyer of 1323 105th Lane Southeast, Olympia
Navigating a complex move—selling both our home and my dad’s home to purchase a new property together—was an incredibly stressful process with so many moving parts. Working with Melanie Newcomb made all the difference. Melanie sold my dad’s home within a week of listing it. Even though she is a personal friend outside of real estate, she handled the entire transaction with complete professionalism. She was exceptionally patient and considerate, making the whole experience smooth and manageable for my elderly father. To top it all off, Melanie went completely above and beyond on moving day. When we arrived at our new property, she was already there—having spent hours setting up a balloon display and a bounce house for our daughter, along with thoughtful, personalized gifts for everyone in our family. In a market flooded with recommendations, I cannot advocate for Melanie enough. She is an absolute miracle worker, and anyone looking for a dedicated, top-tier realtor would be lucky to work with her!
Seller of 6937 Jericho Lane Southwest, Tumwater
Working with Melanie to sell my home was a seamless experience from start to finish. At my age, I admit I am set in my ways and was not particularly looking forward to the upheaval of putting my house on the market. However, Melanie listened carefully to my preferences, respected my routine, and handled every detail with total professionalism and kindness. Her knowledge of the market is second to none. She priced and prepared the house perfectly, leading to a quick, smooth sale within just one week of listing. She made what could have been a stressful process completely hassle-free, keeping me informed every step of the way without ever making me feel rushed or overwhelmed. If you want a dedicated, sharp, and thoughtful agent who truly looks out for her clients, I cannot recommend Melanie highly enough. — Fred