
Matthew Rutherford
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
NICOLE MCQUEEN
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here


Sarah Morris
Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 326 Milroy Street Northwest, Olympia
Sarah is excellent. She responds quickly, day or night, last-minute or not. With her years of experience, she has deep knowledge of housing market trends, and when looking at houses, she has a good sense of what is normal and what might be a red flag. She made a point to get to know us to learn what we were looking for in terms of location and home characteristics, and she directed her resources and attention toward those specifics. She is patient, and she never tried to pressure us into going one way or another in terms of buying a house. Sarah was also a good negotiator with the seller once our offer was accepted.
Seller of 6536 201st Avenue Southwest, Grand Mound
As in any complex situation, we had many questions and concerns along the journey to completion. We were always pleased when we received a prompt response to every single text and/or email we sent to her. We not once, had to wait for her to get needed information we requested. Her prompt, professional and thorough responses took so much stress off our shoulders. The moving boxes kit she provided, also helped to make the move easier right from the start. We were very encouraged to hear other professionals along the way, refer to Sarah as “One of the very best”! She was referred to us by a family member, and we are grateful for that. We have no doubt that this whole experience would have been much different had we chosen a different person.
Buyer of 2074 West Cloquallum Road, Shelton
This purchase went through smoothly and quickly. Sarah has gathered a team of experts to help all areas of finding and buying a new home. A previous contract had multiple failures due to the listing agent not having done their due diligence… Sarah and her team jumped through hoops attempting to do what should have already been done, and then helped us find the better property for us to fall in love with as our new Home 💐
County Winner
Pierce County2026County Top 5
Thurston County2026City Winner
Olympia2026
Melanie Newcomb
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 7824 196th Ln SW, Rochester
Working with Melanie Newcomb as our realtor was an absolute game-changer. Selling two homes simultaneously while trying to purchase a new one is inherently stressful, but we faced an extraordinary wave of wild, unexpected hurdles along the way that truly tested the process. Through every single twist, turn, and last-minute emergency, Melanie handled everything with absolute grace, poise, and unwavering professionalism. Whenever complications arose, she didn't just manage them—she stepped in with immediate intervention, taking the weight off our shoulders and solving problems before they could derail our timeline. Beyond her incredible competence, what stood out most was her courtesy and dedication. She kept us informed, advocated fiercely for our best interests, and remained a calm, reassuring anchor during a genuinely chaotic real estate journey. If you are looking for a knowledgeable, highly responsive, and exceptionally capable realtor who will go above and beyond when the unexpected happens, we cannot recommend Melanie Newcomb highly enough! I am fortunate to also call her my friend.
Buyer of 7824 196th Ln SW, Rochester
We are incredibly grateful to have had Melani Newcomb as our realtor. She has been very helpful, accommodating, and hands-on throughout the entire process. She made everything feel easier and less stressful for us. Melani was always available to answer all of our questions, and whenever we needed her, she was just one call away and responded right away. She went above and beyond to help us with all the requirements we needed and always gave us the best advice and guidance to make things happen smoothly and without any hassle. We truly appreciate her patience, dedication, professionalism, and genuine willingness to help. She made us feel supported every step of the way, and we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. We highly recommend Melani Newcomb to anyone looking for a realtor who truly cares about her clients and is willing to go the extra mile!
Seller of 884 Fairmount Avenue, Shelton
Melanie is an agent that will work her butt off for you. I have had several real estate transactions with her over the past few years now. She has definitely gone well above my expectations on them all, but this one especially. If you are looking for someone that has your best interests in mind then look no further and hire Melanie Newcomb!