Back Middletown

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

101 real estate agents in Middletown

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Middletown over the past 12 months.
View Monique Johnson's profile
5.0

From 7 reviews overall

Monique Johnson

Monique Johnson

Iron Valley Real Estate of Central PA

Last 12 months in Middletown

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

Helpful Agent

Monique was extremely helpful during my home purchasing. Specific elements I want to point out are her flexibility and patience. I took several months to go from starting home searching and touring to actually making a purchase; I changed my plans on the kind of property midway through, and once I reached the point of almost putting down money on a home before backing out, and she was helpful throughout the entire process. She was always available for touring, tried to accurately assess houses with me, never tried to upsell me on expensive homes, never mis-represented a house in an attempt to sell me on it. She never rushed me throughout the multiple months I was searching, and cautioned me throughout the process when she thought I might be being a bit hasty in my search/not reasonably assessing a home. Overall, it felt like I was searching for a home with someone who was as interested in ensuring I purchased the right location as I was. My only non-positive feedback is a reminder that she's only human, too- the time I almost put money down, only to back out last minute, was because both she and I missed the flood danger assessment on the property review. The property was nearly guaranteed to flood in the next ten years, and I didn't fully read into the assessment. Monique also missed it, and the danger was caught by my loan agent, who warned me- but it was Monique who canceled the preliminary paperwork that was being done, backed me out of the agreement, and helped me continue the search. Overall, very pleased, would recommend.

Alexander Philippi 6 months ago
Email
View Bailey Quinn's profile
5.0

From 44 reviews overall

Bailey Quinn

Bailey Quinn

Keller Williams Elite - Lancaster

2026 Award Winner
Price Expert

Last 12 months in Middletown

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

Above and Beyond

Bailey is absolutely amazing! She goes above and beyond in every step in finding our home, and makes sure nothing is overlooked. Her knowledge and expertise are unmatched, and she always takes the time to explain everything clearly. She is incredibly responsive, honest, and truly has her clients’ best interests at heart. Working with her gave me complete confidence and peace of mind—I couldn’t have asked for a better agent!

Jewelz C 8 months ago

Accolades

County Top 5

ratemyagent award

Lancaster County2026
Market ReportEmail
View Susan Kleinfelter's profile
5.0

From 42 reviews overall

Susan Kleinfelter

Susan Kleinfelter

Iron Valley Real Estate

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Middletown

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

Probably the best realtor out there

Probably the best realtor out there. Susan and Scott worked tirelessly from sending listings almost every day to having the availability to look at houses on a seconds notice. Had a great time house hunting as well as great conversations along the way. Super reliable and knowledgeable I would recommend their services to everyone I know.

Trevor Gruber 5 months ago
Email
View Yvonne Smith's profile
5.0

From 43 reviews overall

Yvonne Smith

Yvonne Smith

Keller Williams Realty

2026 Award Winner
Top 20%
Price Expert

Last 12 months in Middletown

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

The best of the best!

We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. Yvonne is a one of a kind realtor. She truly cares about her clients, and by the time we reached the closing table we considered her a friend. She mentored us, explained what was happening every step of the way, kept us informed about everything going on in the background, she got our offer in within hours of us saying yes to the house. Every negotiation she made sure all our needs were met, even when the seller didn’t want to budge, she found a way. If you're buying a house and want a realtor who is going to fight for you, and your wants/needs as a buyer, Yvonne is the right fit for the job. She will be our go to realtor going forward, and we’d recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home!!!

Samantha Fiore about 1 year ago

Accolades

County Winner

ratemyagent award

Cumberland County2026
Market ReportEmail
1 - 9 of 101

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent