From 22 reviews overall

Kathleen Mackinnon
Realty ONE Group Landmark | Indiana

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 15767
1960 East End Road Shippenville
Kathleen had answers or found them to all of our questions, assisted with our negotiations and was very fast at responding. Was available however we were from phone to text to email. Very Kind yet professional and straight forward! We had a great buying experience!
282 Oak Hill Road Armstrong County
We ran into several unexpected obstacles during the home-buying process, and I truly don’t know how we would’ve made it through without Kathy. From the start, she was professional, patient, and fully committed to helping us but the home of our dreams. But what really stood out was how she handled the tough moments — whether it was dealing with appraisal issues, financing issues, or last-minute negotiation hurdles, Kathy stayed calm, focused, and proactive every step of the way. She communicated clearly, fought for our best interests, and never let the stress show — even when we were starting to feel overwhelmed. Thanks to her persistence and expertise, we ended up with a home we love, and we’re incredibly grateful for the support throughout what could’ve been a very frustrating process. If you want someone who will truly go to bat for you when things don’t go perfectly (because they rarely do), Kathy is the one to call.
From 17 reviews overall
Carolyn Wilson
Realty ONE Group Landmark | Indiana

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 15767
309 Whitesell Street Bell Township
Carolyn kept me informed every single step of the way. She was incredibly responsive, always quick to answer texts and calls, and never left me guessing about where I stood in the process. I always felt like a priority. As my agent, Carolyn didn't just show me properties; she provided strategic guidance. She has a fantastic eye for detail and gave me honest, practical advice that ultimately helped make the best possible decisions. I couldn't be happier with the outcome and would highly recommend Carolyn to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She is a consummate professional and a true advocate for her clients.
116 Philadelphia Street Indiana
She went above and beyond as if it were the minimum standard. She was dedicated in making sure my needs were respected and my wants were always a priority. Carolyn worked with the seller's agent to make sure the sale was exactly what I wanted. Her communication skills are amazing, often responding within minutes and when that wasnt the case it was within hours of my reaching out. She followed through with tasks and getting me info in a timely manner and when thst easnt possible, she was open with the progress or identifying where the stall was. If there was something she couldnt do, she was open about why it was outside her ability, be it legal/ethical or it being someone else's required responsibility. Even months after my closing, Carolyn was immediately responsive in helping me find documentation for an unrelated need. I will be referring anyone in the area to her, no matter their real estate needs.
78 Ellsworth Ave Extension Center Township
As first-time homebuyers, we were honestly overwhelmed and under a lot of pressure to find a home quickly. It felt stressful and uncertain at times, but from the moment we started working with Carolyn, everything changed. She stepped in with confidence, knowledge, and so much dedication, and truly took the weight off our shoulders. She worked tirelessly to make sure we found the right home—and fast. No matter how many questions we had or how anxious we felt, she was always there with answers, reassurance, and a positive attitude. She made what could have been a chaotic experience feel smooth and manageable. What meant the most to us was how much she genuinely cared. We never felt like just another client—she treated us like family and made sure we were taken care of every step of the way. Because of her, we are now in a home we love, and we couldn’t be more grateful. If you’re looking for someone who will go above and beyond, especially as a first-time buyer, she is absolutely the one you want by your side.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 15767
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
From 17 reviews overall

Jennifer Dolby
RE/MAX Infinity | Butler

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 15767
126 Lawrence Avenue Meridian
We started working with Jen in early 2025 looking at land to build; then we waited and weren't really liking the land we could find - and Jen was so patient with us through all of our requests and changes to our ideas. She was so flexible for tours. One thing I can say about her is she won't rush a home sale to "get hers". We looked at several homes that she could've sold us on but she was true to us and to herself and let us know when something wasn't in our best interest. I will use Jen for all of our home sales/purchases in the future (if there are any).
192 Bradys Bend Cemetery Road Bradys Bend Township
Jennifer worked hard for me and my wife, I mean worked extremely hard for us, she guided us in the right direction and the right ppl to reach out to for a better interest rate. She was honest and very accommodating! I'm a procrastinator at times and I love that this woman stayed with me and pushed me every step of the way! She is a wonderful communicator and always responds right away. Jennifer, my wife and I thank you for helping our family find our dream home, thank you again. Jennifer is the agent for you!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Butler County2026