Back Newcomerstown

25 real estate offices in Newcomerstown

Sorted by most reviews for offices in Newcomerstown over the past 12 months.
View REMAX Crossroads Properties | Cuyahoga Falls' profile

REMAX Crossroads Properties | Cuyahoga Falls

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 15
  • For Sale 3
  • Total sales value $2.2m
  • Avg. sale price $146k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Leonard and Newland Real Estate Services' profile

Leonard and Newland Real Estate Services

5.0

(29 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 13
  • For Sale 3
  • Total sales value $2.3m
  • Avg. sale price $179k
Hyung Kimover 1 year ago

Seller of 150 West Main Street, Newcomerstown

Exceptional Service and Support

I have worked with Steven Dailey as my realtor since August 2013 for my building in Newcomerstown, OH until it was sold on March 2025. He has consistently been diligent in meeting my expectations, and I am extremely satisfied and grateful to have him as my realtor. When the electricity bill for my building became unexpectedly high, I asked him to coordinate with an electrician to identify which devices were consuming excessive power. He successfully assisted the electrician in shutting off power to certain devices and helped label each switch on the circuit board. Additionally, whenever there were notifications from the county, he made sure to deliver them to me so I could address any issues. Steven is always responsive to my inquiries and requests, promptly providing the necessary assistance. He is also highly skilled in negotiating with realtors representing prospective buyers. Whenever I visited my building, he was always willing to meet with me to discuss any concerns, and he carefully assessed the building's structure and features to highlight as selling points. I highly recommend him without reservation.

Accolades

View Kaufman Realty & Auctions' profile

Kaufman Realty & Auctions

5.0

(4 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 12
  • For Sale 9
  • Total sales value $3.5m
  • Avg. sale price $296k
Dwayneover 2 years ago

Buyer of 27843 Township Rd 241, Newcomerstown

Excellent

Loren was very responsive, he kept us in the loop as far as what was going on with the property. Would highly recommend him.

Accolades

View Barnett Inc. Realtors' profile

Barnett Inc. Realtors

5.0

(2 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 10
  • For Sale 3
  • Total sales value $1.5m
  • Avg. sale price $154k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View REMAX Crossroads Properties | New Philadelphia's profile

REMAX Crossroads Properties | New Philadelphia

5.0

(3 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 8
  • For Sale 4
  • Total sales value $1.2m
  • Avg. sale price $150k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Howard Hanna Real Estate Services' profile

Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

5.0

(6 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 7
  • For Sale 2
  • Total sales value $1.5m
  • Avg. sale price $209k
John Dietrichabout 8 years ago

Buyer of 2261 Gravel Lick Rd, Newcomerstown

I was a first time home buyer when I met her...

I was a first time home buyer when I met her. She helped me the entire way through the process of helping me find homes that I would like and even getting into them to see them and clear through to the end where I was finally able to hold the keys to my new house. I never once felt lost or confused and she always kept me informed on what was happening every time something happened or changed. Anytime I found a house to look at or had a question whether it was big or small she always answered me very quickly and never left me hanging. I could not have asked for a better realtor than Carly! I highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy a house!

Accolades

View KAUFMAN REALTY & AUCTIONS's profile

KAUFMAN REALTY & AUCTIONS

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 6
  • For Sale 8
  • Total sales value $4.5m
  • Avg. sale price $742k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Coldwell Banker Realty's profile

Coldwell Banker Realty

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 5
  • For Sale 3
  • Total sales value $967k
  • Avg. sale price $193k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View Living Tree Realty, LLC's profile

Living Tree Realty, LLC

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in Newcomerstown 0
  • Sold 5
  • For Sale 8
  • Total sales value $642k
  • Avg. sale price $128k

No reviews in Newcomerstown yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

1 - 9 of 52

Suburbs in Newcomerstown

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent