From 134 reviews overall

Patrick Murphy
Keller Williams Consultants

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Northwest
2957 Kicking Bird Trace Columbus
My fiancé and I originally decided just to look into the home buying process, and that’s when we met Patrick! From day one, we knew he was the perfect realtor for us. He went above and beyond to help us find our dream home, always being honest and transparent with every house we toured. Patrick’s dedication, knowledge, and genuine care made the entire process smooth and enjoyable. We couldn’t be happier with our experience and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy a home!
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Ohio2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Franklin County2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Delaware County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Westerville2026From 13 reviews overall
Holly Lockett
Keller Williams Capital Partners

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Northwest
3136 Frobisher Ave Columbus
Holly was fantastic, and a true professional. As first-time home buyers, we were nervous and unsure of the whole process, and she made everything feel manageable. Patiently answering all of our questions and keeping us updated on what to expect next. Offering honest and experienced feedback on the homes we toured and whether she thought they were over priced or had hidden issues that we hadn't noticed. We reccomend her to all our friends
1586 Lorraine Avenue Columbus
Holly's communications were outstanding during the entire process. She used emails, text messages, and phone calls, and her replies to our questions were without delay, and she checked-in with us freqently even when we had no questions. Her market knowledge was evident in our discussions, with helpful suggestions on the "little things" we could do to make our house attractive to potential buyers. Her professionalism was outstanding and she created the feeling of caring about us personally, not just professionally, and was always looking out for our best interests. When closing on a home purchase or sale, the legal jargon in all of that paperwork can be overwhelming, but Holly walked us thru the explanations for any questions we had of the "legal details" in a manner that was easily understandable. We will definitely call on Holly for any future real estate transactions.
From 4 reviews overall

Sue Van Woerkom
Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Northwest
2579 Trotterslane Drive Columbus
I’ve trusted Sue with multiple home sales and purchases over roughly 25 years, and there’s a reason I keep going back to her. She doesn’t just work in Central Ohio real estate — she understands it on a level that only comes from decades of experience. When Sue gives you advice, you know it’s grounded in real market history, a clear read on what’s happening right now, and a genuine desire to see you make the best possible decision. She’s honest in a way that’s refreshing. You may not always love the news, but you’ll always know it’s the truth, and you can move forward with confidence because of it. What really sets Sue apart is how invested she becomes in your goals. She listens closely, asks the right questions, and makes sure she understands what you want — not just on paper, but in real life. And once she knows that, she goes all‑in. Sue works with a level of determination and follow‑through that’s hard to find. She’s the person who will answer the late‑night text, track down the detail no one else thought to check, and keep things moving even when the process gets stressful or complicated. Buying or selling a home is a big deal, and you want someone in your corner who knows what they’re doing and genuinely cares about the outcome. That’s Sue. She’s steady, knowledgeable, straightforward, and deeply committed to her clients. If you’re looking for a realtor who will guide you with honesty, advocate for you at every step, and work tirelessly to help you reach your goals, you won’t find anyone better
From 43 reviews overall

Neil Mathias
Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Northwest
6886 Lakebrook Boulevard Columbus
Was extremely helpful in making the right decision with my home purchase. I had been looking in a particular area for a few years without any luck. Neil made sure that we found the right home for me. His knowledge of the market is unmatched, and he has all the right insights that any buyer or seller would be looking for. His attention to detail, his responsiveness and his insight is something that is seemingly more and more rare in today's market. You are in the best hands with the Mathias Team! I cannot recommend the team enough!
1123 Firth Avenue Columbus
The Mathias team did a tremendous job with the sale of our prior home! The description of our house, photos and brochures were extremely professional and well done, and made our house look amazing. When we were in the market for our new home we did not see any brochures as detailed or eye catching as the brochure the Mathias team prepared for our home. Their advice on where to focus our efforts to make improvements was very valuable, and they have the connections to make recommendations for contractors to hire to do the work. Our house went into contract with multiple offers the first weekend it was listed. And, when we were caught by surprise with an inspection issue we were unaware of previously, Neil worked tirelessly and skillfully to navigate the issue and turn what could have been a major problem into a win-win for us and our buyers. The Mathias team was responsive and communicated very well, and their market knowledge is second to none. Very thankful for all the work they did on our behalf and extremely pleased with the outcome!