From 42 reviews overall
Jane Kuraly
Cutler Real Estate | Dublin

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
2200 Nayland Road Upper Arlington
Jane is, without question, the best realtor I have ever worked with. Over the years, she has helped me purchase 2 homes and sell another, and each experience reinforced why I continue to trust her completely. Buying or selling a home can be stressful, emotional, and overwhelming, but Jane has a remarkable ability to make the process feel manageable, informed, and even enjoyable. What set Jane apart is her combination of professionalism, expertise, and genuine care for her clients. She is thoughtful and insightful in every interaction, always taking the time to understand my goals, concerns, and priorities. At the same time, she is realistic and honest, which I deeply appreciated. She never told me simply what I wanted to hear; instead, she provided sound guidance and strategic advice that ultimately led to the best outcomes. Throughout every state of the process- from searching for the right home, to navigating negotiations, inspections, contracts, and closing- Jane was incredibly accessible and responsive. No question ever felt too small, and no challenge ever seemed too complicated for her to handle. She anticipated issues before the arose, asked the right questions, and made sure I felt informed and confident in every decision. She cared about finding the right fit for my family. Beyond being an exceptional realtor, Jane is simply an outstanding person. Through these experiences, we got to know each other well and laughed a lot. She became more than a trusted advisor; she became a true friend. I cannot recommend her highly enough to anyone looking for a realtor who combines expertise, integrity, responsiveness, and compassion. Working with Jane is a true pleasure.
269 Ridge Side Drive Powell
Having not known Jane prior to working with her and getting a recommendation as a family friend agent, we were hopeful that the reliable description would hold true. She surpassed any expectations we had and gave us the best experience as first time home buyers. Jane listens to you and even if you don’t know exactly what you want, she is able to build a story from your conversations and searching and find what you are looking for. Besides her excellent attention to detail, Jane is also an amazing communicator, allowing clients to focus on other matters that come up while moving, while she focuses on the logistics of the sale. Jane went above and beyond with everything, guiding us every step of the way. This is the easiest 5 star review to give. Thank you Jane, we are lucky to know you!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Delaware County2026From 61 reviews overall
Lindsey Riley
Cutler Real Estate | Stow/Cuyahoga Falls

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
112/911 Canyon View Road Northfield
Lindsey has a strong commitment to explaining much needed information in the purchase of a home. Her amazing attention to detail and follow up is highly commendable! I felt safe and protected that all my questions and concerns would not only be addressed and answered but also investigated if need be without any hesitation. It was always evident and clear that Lindsey was protecting me as a homebuyer , and everything was always explained so that I had the correct and necessary information before making a decision. Lindsey was very patient, easy to work with and a perfect example of who , what and how a realtor should be! I highly highly recommend Lindsey and her services. She is an absolute pleasure and treasure!
375 Hillside Road Seven Hills
Even while out of town on vacation, Lindsey found time to help me find my new house. Her attention to detail, dedication, and willingness to be available is second to none! Highly recommend her for any purchase or selling of your home!
1163 Greenwood Avenue Akron
My Wife and I were first time sellers. Lindsey held our hand throughout the entire process of selling our property. She was very thorough with her research when it came to our home. One of the things we loved that Lindsey did was she reached out to the Listing Realtors of properties nearby to gauge activity in our area. This was extremely helpful! We listed just before Thanksgiving and Lindsey somehow managed to have our property under contract in just a few weeks during the Holiday Season. Things ran extremely smooth while we were under contract. Closing was great with Title One. We will be reaching back out to Lindsey in the Spring to Sell another investment property of ours. If you are looking for an Amazing Realtor, Call Lindsey Riley!
From 52 reviews overall

Tibitha Matheney
CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
3628 Hopkins Road Youngstown
We used Tibitha’s help when purchasing our first home so it was a no brainer to use her again. She made it so easy by having what seemed to be all the answers. Very fast to respond if we had a question and when finding our new home had us a viewing instantly. Selling our home was a breeze and do to following her guidance we had our home sold in 48 hours with papers signed
From 45 reviews overall

Holly Maloney
Maloney Group - eXp Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
22 Skidmore Avenue Cleves
Holly and Tom were fantastic to work with throughout the sale of our first flipped house. From start to finish, they provided valuable expertise, guidance, and insight that really helped us navigate the process with confidence. Their knowledge of the market and attention to detail made a big difference, and they ultimately helped us secure a great buyer for the property. We truly appreciated their professionalism, responsiveness, and dedication every step of the way. If you’re looking for a team that knows what they’re doing and genuinely cares about getting you the best outcome, we highly recommend Holly and Tom!
5300 Kenridge Drive Blue Ash
Holly and Tom were always quick to respond and they have a breadth of knowledge and experience. They have good advice for selling and paid attention to what we really wanted for buying. They found us the perfect house and we got in to see it first.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Hamilton County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Cincinnati2026