From 53 reviews overall

Cindy Gustwiller
Key Realty
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
From 51 reviews overall

Shannon Conine
Shannon Conine

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
211 Summit Street Fostoria
Selling my home with Shannon was an excellent experience from start to finish. Communication was always clear and prompt I was kept informed at every step and never left guessing. Her market knowledge and pricing strategy were spot-on, which helped generate strong interest and a great result. She handled negotiations confidently and professionally, always advocating for my best outcome. What really stood out was how organized and proactive she was, every detail was handled smoothly, which made the entire selling process feel stress-free. If you’re looking to sell your home and want someone who truly knows the market and goes above and beyond, I highly recommend Shannon.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Seneca County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Tiffin2026From 12 reviews overall
Holly Lockett
Keller Williams Capital Partners

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
3400 Tonti Drive Dublin
Holly is a proven professional and has handled all my real estate needs for the last 30 years. During this time, she has never dropped the ball, always been extremely detail-oriented and thorough. I wouldn't recommend anyone else but Holly Lockett for all your real estate needs.
1472 Lewes Castle Drive Columbus
When my fiancé and I walked into Holly’s office for the first time we knew nearly nothing about the home buying process. We had a vague idea of what we wanted in a house, where we wanted our mortgage to be, and a general vicinity. Within 14 days we were placing an offer on a house. Holly comes equipped with endless knowledge and contacts to get the job done and done well. Do you want to use a certain inspector ? That’s fine go for it, but if you don’t, Holly has a list of inspectors in the area ready to go. Don’t know who to borrow from? Holly’s got you covered. Even down to movers, cleaners, painters. Holly is prepared to support every step of the way and even post purchase. We couldn’t be more pleased with our experience. Holly advised and supported us every step of the way and went to bat for us with the sellers multiple times. We wouldn’t be where we were had she not been willing to put in the work. She is kind, professional and truly cares that you get something that you’ll be happy with
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Ohio
258 N Cedar St Newark
Mindy was so incredible to work with selling our house. She was always in communication with us on anything needed. She helped us locate contractors, and even went to the house herself to check on things so we didn’t have to drive 2 hours to do it ourselves. All around so easy to work with and made selling a house so stress free. I would recommend her to anyone selling or buying a house.
1014 Pleasant Court Reynoldsburg
We appreciated having Mindy Back supporting us while selling our parent home of 64 + years. It was very emotional and she was so informative, compassionate, and so respectful of our feelings. Her expertise and personal touch was exactly what was needed. Thank you Mindy, will always be grateful!
6793 Fallon Lane Columbus
If I could give her 6 stars, I would! Mindy was such a blessing to our home selling experience! After 30 years in our house, it was really hard to leave, but Mindy's kindness and passion for helping families made it much easier. Her prompt communication, understanding of the market, and expertise made the selling process smooth and successful. I highly recommend Mindy for your future buying and selling needs!