From 343 reviews overall

Andrew Nagy
Nagy Properties

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in North Carolina
19107 Southport Drive Cornelius
Andrew Nagy originally sold us our home and was the only person we trusted when it came time to sell. He is a total straight shooter who is easy to build a rapport with and stays highly communicative throughout the entire process. Andrew worked quickly to get us a great result that we were incredibly happy with. We highly recommend him to anyone looking for an agent who is both personable and professional!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Iredell County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Huntersville2026From 25 reviews overall

Amber Lehman
Nest Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in North Carolina
805 Old Ash Court Wake Forest
Amber knew what she was doing! She would share her story expertise with us while also listening to what we wanted and needed. She was as very communicative with us and went about and beyond to help us in this process. She listened to our concerns and shared helpful tips to calm my anxieties. Would definitely use her again!
10209 River Bank Drive Raleigh
Amber has excellent knowledge of the current real estate market. She takes the time to find out your preferences and makes sure you get exposure to all areas of Raleigh. She is professional at all times, and I felt she really worked for me to get me into the home I wanted.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Franklin County2026From 17 reviews overall

Lauren Underhill
Hall & Nixon Real Estate, Inc.

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in North Carolina
129 Rosedale Dr Elizabeth City
Lauren was a great help for me in my first time homebuying experience. I appreciated that she was always honest and direct with me and was always able to answer my questions. I would happily recommend her to anyone!
129 Rosedale Dr Elizabeth City
Hard to put into words how wonderful Lauren is to work with. Every step of the way, she was there, offering guidance, information, good and not so good as needed, but always with next steps. She was patient when I was overwhelmed with making a major move while trying to sell my house. Lauren was quick to respond when I texted her with some small thing and she made me feel like I was her only seller she was working with. Lauren has great knowledge for the area and was always direct and clear in her communications. Lauren was amazing helping me find the perfect home for me when I moved to NC in '18, so I knew she was the only realtor to work with to sell it to start the next phase of my life. Above all, I consider Lauren a friend and certainly would refer her to anyone looking for a realtor in the Elizabeth City area.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Pasquotank County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Elizabeth City2026From 109 reviews overall

Tessa Mayville
AA MAYVILLE REALTY
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in North Carolina
394 Zeppelin Lane Hoke County
We would like the world to know how kind Tessa was to us as our agent. We lived in another state and were building in NC , Tessa kept us updated on all our step through out the building process. And if you have built a home that’s a challenge in itself. She made sure that any requests made were attended to within hours even on off hours and weekends. She was very professional and went above and beyond to make sure things were to our specifications. Thank you Tessa to you and your team for a fantastic job. I would highly recommend Tessa for your agent , you can trust that she will get the job done . Kathleen and Stan
834 Red Hawk Place Vass
Tessa is an amazing Realtor; she represented us in the purchase of our first house and got us a deal better than we could have hoped for. She is incredibly knowledgeable and skilled at her job and made the process so easy for us. Any questions we had were immediately answered and we were kept in the loop the whole way. Could not have asked for a better Realtor; would recommend to anyone looking to purchase property.
341 Arlington Drive Raeford
As a first-time homebuyer with a demanding and often stressful job, I truly couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Tessa. She was incredibly responsive and consistently went above and beyond, often working overtime to make sure I had everything I needed. No matter how small the question, she answered it quickly and thoroughly, which gave me so much peace of mind throughout the process. Tessa was also a strong advocate during negotiations, securing valuable items for me at closing and making sure everything was handled properly before I moved in. She made what could have been an overwhelming experience feel personal, smooth, and reassuring. I always felt like she genuinely cared and had my best interests at heart. Even after I bought my home and moved in, she has continued to stay in touch and be supportive. That level of dedication speaks volumes. I’m so grateful for her and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Cumberland County2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Hoke County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Five Points2026