Shelter Island

Real Estate & Property for Sale in Shelter Island

Showing 64 - 84 of 559 properties

Sort by

Lawrence Rich

Show more detail >

For Sale

$5,999,000

Sag Harbor NY 11963

4

4

1

Other

Sheri Winter Parker

Show more detail >

For Sale

$3,250,000

East Marion NY 11939

3

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Corcoran

Clorinda Tagios

Show more detail >

For Sale

$1,277,000

1025 Seawood Drive

Southold NY 11971

4

4

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Nancy Cervelli

Show more detail >

For Sale

$1,395,000

870 Park View Lane

Orient NY 11957

3

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Kieran Collings

Show more detail >

Pending

$925,000

1320 Arshamomaque Avenue

Southold NY 11971

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldAug 13, 2026

$835,000

2C2/2820 Shipyard Lane

East Marion NY 11939

1

2

Condo

Listing courtesy of Century 21 Albertson Realty and Compass Greater NY LLC

Thomas Panebianco

Show more detail >

For Sale

$629,900

400 Aquaview Avenue

East Marion NY 11939

Land

Listing courtesy of Realty Connect USA L I Inc

5

Show more detail >

For Sale

$799,000

1b2/2820 Shipyard Ln

East Marion NY 11939

2

2

Condo

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Giuseppe Pinello

5

Show more detail >

For Sale

$939,000

595 Greenfields Lane

Southold NY 11971

3

4

10

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Exit Realty Achieve

Show more detail >

SoldAug 12, 2026

$1,475,000

130 Sunset Lane

Greenport West NY 11944

4

5

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty and Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldAug 12, 2026

$800,000

1650 Gillette Drive

East Marion NY 11939

3

2

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Compass Greater NY LLC and Signature Premier Properties

SoldAug 12, 2026

$1,415,000

619 Bailey Avenue

Greenport West NY 11944

4

3

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty and Compass Greater NY LLC

Nancy Cervelli

Show more detail >

For Sale

$950,000

Orient NY 11957

2

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

SoldAug 11, 2026

$620,000

265 Hummel Avenue

Southold NY 11971

2

1

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Melissa Principi

For Sale

$699,000

Southold NY 11971

Land

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Sheri Winter Parker

Show more detail >

For Sale

$4,250,000

169 North Ferry Road

Shelter Island Heights NY 11965

4

6

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Corcoran

Show more detail >

SoldAug 10, 2026

$1,999,999

North Haven NY 11963

3

2

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Elizabeth Cordova Alata

Show more detail >

For Sale

$3,500,000

2723 Deerfield Road

Noyack NY 11963

3

3

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldAug 6, 2026

$961,000

340 Rambler Road

Southold NY 11971

3

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Compass Greater NY LLC

Patricia Shackel

Show more detail >

For Sale

$969,000

270 Opechee Avenue

Southold NY 11971

3

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldAug 2, 2026

$2,345,000

Noyack NY 11963

4

4

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons and Douglas Elliman Real Estate

64 - 84 of 559

Suburbs in Shelter Island

View nearby Cities

Sales:: (619) 566-0008

Quick Links

© 2026 RateMyAgent

Terms & Conditions