RateMyAgentGo to search
Back Shelter Island

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

Real Estate & Property for Sale in Shelter Island

Showing 22 - 42 of 537 properties
Matthew Breitenbach Matthew Breitenbach
Show more detail >
For Sale
$6,999,000
3a/3b/33 Pandion Road
Shelter Island NY 11964
Land
Listing courtesy of Compass
Brian A. Buckhout Brian A. Buckhout
Show more detail >
For Sale
$995,000
12 Hilo Drive
Shelter Island Heights NY 11965
Land
Show more detail >
Pending
$1,950,000
41 Cove Drive
Noyack NY 11963
2
2
Single-Family
Cindy Scholz Cindy Scholz
Show more detail >
For Sale
$20,750,000
51 Mashomuck Drive
North Haven NY 11963
7
9
1
Other
Jack Pearson Jack Pearson
Show more detail >
For Sale
$2,250,000
16 Redwood Road
Sag Harbor NY 11963
3
3
Single-Family
Jennifer Friedberg Jennifer Friedberg
Show more detail >
For Sale
$5,395,000
9 Margarets Drive
Shelter Island Heights NY 11964
4
5
2
Other
Dana Trotter Dana Trotter
5
Show more detail >
For Sale
$7,750,000
12 Suffolk St
Sag Harbor NY 11963
4
4
Other
Listing courtesy of The Agency Hamptons
Jennifer Friedberg Jennifer Friedberg
Show more detail >
Pending
$2,895,000
29 Denison Road
Sag Harbor NY 11963
3
3
Other
Show more detail >
SoldJun 12, 2026
$1,900,000
435 Maple Lane
Greenport West NY 11944
4
5
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Corcoran and Saunders & Associates
Show more detail >
SoldJun 12, 2026
$999,000
216 North Street
Greenport NY 11944
3
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Corcoran and Engel & Volkers North Fork
Christos Lolis Christos Lolis
Show more detail >
SoldJun 12, 2026
$228,000
5/52325 CR-48
Southold NY 11971
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of EAST COAST NEW YORK
Josh Seidner Josh Seidner
Show more detail >
Pending
$3,899,999
1215 Middle Line Highway
Sag Harbor NY 11963
5
4
Other
Listing courtesy of Compass
Susan Ryan Susan Ryan
Show more detail >
Pending
$4,995,000
3645 Noyack Road
Noyack NY 11963
4
3
Single-Family
Denise Wilder Denise Wilder
5
Show more detail >
Pending
$1,195,000
45 Wickatuck Drive
Noyack NY 11963
2
2
2
Single-Family
Lori Schiaffino Lori Schiaffino
Show more detail >
For Sale
$3,995,000
11 Terry Dr
Sag Harbor NY 11963
Land
Shane Donahue Shane Donahue
Show more detail >
Pending
$3,150,000
52 S Midway Rd
Shelter Island NY 11964
4
3
Other
Listing courtesy of The Agency Hamptons
Melina Wein Melina Wein
5
Show more detail >
For Sale
$4,000,000
100 Peconic Avenue
Shelter Island Heights NY 11965
3
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of M Wein Realty Inc
Angelo Piccozzi Angelo Piccozzi
Show more detail >
For Sale
$895,000
307 Champlin Place
Greenport West NY 11944
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc
Kim D. Hovey Kim D. Hovey
Show more detail >
For Sale
$3,495,000
6 Joseph Francis Boulevard
Noyack NY 11963
5
6
Other
Jessica von Hagn Jessica von Hagn
Show more detail >
Pending
$2,095,000
36 Coves End Lane
North Haven NY 11963
5
3
Single-Family
Joe Piccininni Joe Piccininni
Show more detail >
For Sale
$2,650,000
47 Pineneck Avenue
Noyack NY 11963
3
3
Other
Listing courtesy of Compass
22 - 42 of 537

Suburbs in Shelter Island

View nearby Cities

RateMyAgent
Sales:
(619) 566-0008
Quick Links
© 2026 RateMyAgent
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsLicensingSitemap