Back NY, 12758

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

37 real estate agents in NY, 12758

Sorted by most reviews for agents in 12758 over the past 12 months.
View Carole Barotti's profile
4.9

From 13 reviews overall

Carole Barotti

Carole Barotti

Elliott & Pomeroy Inc

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in 12758

$300k

Avg. sale price

3

Sold (as lead agent)

2

Reviews in 12758

Excellent market

A good Market knowledge , great communication and negotiation skills

milos nemec 3 months ago
Email
View Mackenzie Grate's profile
5.0

From 49 reviews overall

Mackenzie Grate

Mackenzie Grate

The Machree Group, LLC

Last 12 months in 12758

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in 12758

Mackenzie is fantastic!

I can’t say enough good things about Mackenzie. She was a superb buyer’s agent, recommended to us by a friend she had also helped find a home, and it was immediately clear why she came so highly recommended. We were searching for just the right second home, and over the course of many weekends (spanning months) driving to different towns across the Catskills, Mackenzie joined us every time with enthusiasm and invaluable insight into both the areas and the houses themselves. She is extremely knowledgeable about homes, never hesitating to go into even the dingiest of crawlspaces, and is especially knowledgeable about short-term rentals. Mackenzie has a wonderful positive attitude, while always being realistic and honest. If something doesn’t sit right with her, she’ll tell you directly, and she never makes you feel pressured, always reminding you that she’ll be there until you find your perfect house. Even after helping you find your dream home, Mackenzie stays invested, going above and beyond by providing contacts and resources to help you get up and running. We cannot recommend her enough.

Victoria Schwartz 9 months ago
Email
View David Elder's profile
5.0

From 2 reviews overall

David Elder

David Elder

Carole Edwards Realty

Last 12 months in 12758

$232k

Avg. sale price

4

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12758

A Fantastic gentlemen of the Catskills

David was a great agent, is a great person and we could not have found a better person to guide us through our first buying experience. First he was funny, informed, and willing to strategize with us through the process. He had stories, technical information, and a good eye for houses within our range and requirements. He was personal and it felt like we were working on a project together with a good friend. And when he didn't have an answer he was active to get it, and smart people say "I don't know, but I'll find out" and that says it all about the intelligence and character of the man. We could not recommend him more.

Jon Topolski 3 months ago
Email
View Peter Feinberg's profile
N/A

From 0 reviews overall

Peter Feinberg

Peter Feinberg

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Peters Realty (Monticello, 12701)

Last 12 months in 12758

$237k

Avg. sale price

4

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12758

No reviews in 12758 yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Email
1 - 9 of 37

View nearby Suburbs

© 2026 RateMyAgent