

Natalie Pantelo
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 17 Annapolis Street, Tinton Falls
Natalie was referred to us by my sister after she helped her family with the purchase of their dream home and from our initial conversation, Natalie put us at ease with her friendly demeanor and vast knowledge of the local real estate market. She was always a phone call away and during our search for our dream house, she was always ready to let us know why we should choose one house over the other. We were first-time homebuyers, and she patiently guided us through each step, providing valuable insights that helped us find the perfect home within our budget. She acted just like a big sister looking for the perfect house for her little sister’s family.
Buyer of 29 Gait Court, Tinton Falls
Natalie's market knowledge is outstanding. She came to initial showing with all necessary details about rent potential, HOA rental requirements, potential CAP rates, etc to simplify my investment buying decision. She was there every step of the way to help guide and answer questions during the buying process. Even after the closing, she has been a great partner in helping find outstanding tenants.
Buyer of 3 Dressage Court, Tinton Falls
I was an extremely picky buyer for investment properties, and nothing that I've seen on the market was appealing to me and hit all my criteria. Until Natalie came into the picture and did all the heavy lifting - she found opportunities that other agents wouldn't have found, and consulting with me on my needs at every step along the way. I recommend everybody have at least 1 intro conversation with Natalie before talking with other agents in the area.

Matthew Sirchio
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 15 Rothbury Court, Tinton Falls
I had a great experience working with Matt. He's very knowledgeable, responsive, and went above and beyond to help me find the perfect home. Throughout the entire process he answered my many questions and helped make the process seamless. I would highly recommend him.
County Winner
Monmouth County2026Pamela Girard
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 2 Edwards Farm Lane, Tinton Falls
Pam was our agent when we moved to the area 20 years ago so we knew she would be perfect for our recent move. Pam knew what we wanted in our next home and she absolutely came through for us again! Things moved at just the pace we needed and we could not be happier with the whole experience. And we love our new home!! Thank you Pam!

Charles Decker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 83 Diane Drive, Tinton Falls
Buying a home can be overwhelming and scary. Charlie walked me through the process as a first time homebuyer and was extremely thorough. He answered all my questions in detail and always went the extra mile. He was flexible with working around my schedule. Additionally, he was very patient with me. He made the process smooth and stress free. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a real estate agent that is knowledgeable and good at what they do.