

Natalie Pantelo
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 20 Brunswick Ave, Spotswood
Working with Natalie was truly a rewarding experience. From the very beginning, she demonstrated a high level of professionalism and dedication to every task we worked on together. What impressed me most was her ability to balance efficiency with creativity — she always brought fresh ideas to the table while keeping projects well-organized and on track. Natalie is also an excellent communicator: she listens carefully, respects different perspectives, and makes sure everyone feels included in the process.
Buyer of 17 Annapolis Street, Tinton Falls
Natalie was referred to us by my sister after she helped her family with the purchase of their dream home and from our initial conversation, Natalie put us at ease with her friendly demeanor and vast knowledge of the local real estate market. She was always a phone call away and during our search for our dream house, she was always ready to let us know why we should choose one house over the other. We were first-time homebuyers, and she patiently guided us through each step, providing valuable insights that helped us find the perfect home within our budget. She acted just like a big sister looking for the perfect house for her little sister’s family.
Buyer of 14 Sunset Road, Oceanport
Natalie did an outstanding job helping us find a suitable rental in the area! She worked with us on our requirements and our family needs. Natalie is very thorough and presented our offer(s) in a very organized and professional manner. It took us a little while, but Natalie got us exactly where we wanted to be, and she was such a pleasure to work with along the way! We highly recommend trusting Natalie with your real estate needs - she will go the extra mile.
Tara Jordan
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 810 Washington Ave, Fairview
Tara is the best and I can't thank her enough. First and foremost, she is incredibly knowledgeable about the Monmouth county area. I've lived in Middletown for six years, and even I didn't know as much about the neighborhoods and desirable areas as Tara did. Because of that, I felt confident in her finding a new home and neighborhood that was right for my family. When we found our dream home, she put her negotiation skills to work - and landed us with the winning bid during a very competitive market! Even the seller remarked on what a great strategy Tara used. She also helped us sell our first home. She did her research, and knew exactly what to list it at to bring buyers in - it sold within a few days and above asking. She guided us through the confusing selling and buying process, and made sure we were clear on our next steps. She was transparent the entire way - gave us honest opinions and didn't try to push anything on us which we really appreciated. Finally, she was patient and kind. She understands what a stressful process this can be, and helped us feel taken care of the entire time. I highly recommend her.

Karen M Goldberg
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Sarah Karabinos
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 1056 Chester St, Union County
I recently had the pleasure of working with Sarah Karabinos from Premier Homes to purchase a new dream home for my family. From start to finish, it was an absolute pleasure! From our initial conversations and throughout the whole process, she was very professional. Sarah and Premier Homes staff were highly knowledgeable about the local market (inventory, valuation, location, etc.).She is an excellent communicator and brokered many conversation/ topics with the seller (I was the buyer). She also went out of the way to ensure every detail was taken care of us from arranging inspections to researching potential issues with a property.I would highly recommend working with Premier Homes team and will be using Sarah again in the future.