Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

95 real estate agents in Old Town

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Old Town over the past 12 months.
View Marilyn Comiskey's profile
5.0

From 50 reviews overall

Marilyn Comiskey

Marilyn Comiskey

The Comiskey Group

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Old Town

$2.5m

Avg. sale price

3

Sold (as lead agent)

2

Reviews in Old Town

Amazing Agent

If you're looking for a stellar realtor, look no further than Marilyn Comiskey! We recently had the pleasure of working with her and her assistant Megan to sell our home at 3929 Pringle Street, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From the moment we met Marilyn, her professionalism and dedication were evident. She took the time to understand our needs and goals, providing us with a personalized approach that made us feel valued throughout the entire process. Her expertise in the local market was impressive, and she offered invaluable advice on pricing our home to attract potential buyers. Marilyn’s marketing strategy was top-notch. The listing was beautifully presented, complete with stunning photographs , video and a comprehensive description that highlighted the best features of our home. She utilized various platforms to ensure maximum visibility, and it certainly paid off! Throughout the selling process, Marilyn was always available to answer our questions and address any concerns. Her communication skills are exceptional, keeping us informed every step of the way. We truly felt like we were in good hands. Thanks to Marilyn's hard work and dedication, our home sold quickly during such a difficult market. We are incredibly grateful for her guidance and support during this important transition in our lives. If you want a realtor who is knowledgeable, proactive, and genuinely cares about her clients, we highly recommend Marilyn Comiskey. She worked with us like a team player and made it more enjoyable. Thank you, Marilyn!

Carl Pallini 5 months ago
Email
View Valerie Cites' profile
5.0

From 17 reviews overall

Valerie Cites

Valerie Cites

Coldwell Banker West

Last 12 months in Old Town

N/A

Avg. sale price

0

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Old Town

Valerie is simply amazing!

After my mother passed away, Valerie helped us to sell her home in a very difficult market. She guided us through every detail with her expertise and knowledge. Because I live out of state, she took care of making sure the house was maintained and ready to show at any moment. Valerie was excellent at communicating information and always available for a call or text. She is the perfect balance of professionalism, knowledge, compassion, and determination. I would highly recommend her to anyone trying to buy or sell a home in San Diego! You simply can't go wrong with Valeris Cites as your realtor.

Beth about 1 year ago
Email
View Susan Willis' profile
5.0

From 12 reviews overall

Susan Willis

Susan Willis

Last 12 months in Old Town

N/A

Avg. sale price

0

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Old Town

She's a pro

Best agent I've worked with.

5 months ago
Email
View Elizabeth Callaway's profile
5.0

From 36 reviews overall

Elizabeth Callaway

Elizabeth Callaway

Compass

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Old Town

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Old Town

Smooth Finish After a Challenging Start and Market Shifts

We recently sold our home with Elizabeth as our listing agent. It was a significant transaction with many moving parts, and while the process had its challenges, we ultimately reached a successful outcome. Pricing a home in a shifting market is never easy, and in hindsight, it’s possible that some early expectations may have been a bit optimistic. That said, Elizabeth stayed engaged throughout the process and was especially helpful toward the end when things became more complex. After a tough home inspection and some potential complications with a backup offer, Elizabeth helped navigate a delicate negotiation and kept the original deal intact — which avoided further concessions and gave us a cleaner close. That level of strategic handling was appreciated. There were moments where we hoped for more visibility or activity earlier in the listing, but we also recognize that selling a home isn’t always linear, and the market can be unpredictable. We also would’ve liked to see more data points throughout the process — the portal was helpful, but a simpler breakdown of key metrics and trends would have made it easier to track performance and interest in real time. Overall, we’re thankful to have sold successfully and appreciated Elizabeth’s commitment in the later stages when it really counted.

7 months ago
Email
1 - 9 of 95

View nearby Neighbourhoods

© 2026 RateMyAgent