From 113 reviews overall

Beth Mulvey
Beach House Sales and Development

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Bay County
8205 Grand Palm Boulevard Upper Grand Lagoon
Choosing Beth Mulvey was the best decision we could have made in listing our home for sale. She thoroughly researched the market and honestly advised us in regards to our listing price, and she nailed it! Beth is a true professional who utilizes the latest marketing techniques combined with her own creativity. This resulted in us receiving two offers in just five days! Throughout the entire process, Beth ensured everything moved quickly and efficiently while communicating with incredible kindness, patience, and care. She helped us a great deal from start to finish, and we couldn't be happier with the results. Working with Beth has been a blessing, and we can't recommend her highly enough!
B505/7205 Thomas Drive Lower Grand Lagoon
Beth is a very detail person! She is such a great realtor on so many levels! I guess for me one of the most important characteristics is how she listens! Also she is always just a text or email away! Even when she is swamped with work and life! You want her on your side of the deal!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Bay County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Lynn Haven2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Panama City Beach2026From 25 reviews overall

Kurt Fadden
Legacy Premier Agency

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Bay County
1539 Donna Ave Callaway
After having my home listed with another agent for 7 months with no success, I feel really lucky to have found Kurt and Legacy Premier Agency. He had my home under contract in just 17 days, and I was signing closing papers on day 51 (which only took about 15 minutes!). The whole team was great to work with. They did an amazing job marketing my home and, just as importantly, kept me informed every step of the way—which meant a lot after my previous experience. I definitely recommend listing with Kurt. Thanks again for helping me get this done and move on to the next chapter!
C/117 S 37th St Mexico Beach
As inexperianced home buyers Kurt was patient and understanding with our many questions and was a perfect guide in helping us make our final decision. He was able to provide us with multiple listings and narrow down to properities we were able to view. Not only was he great in helping us find the home of our dreams he and his team provided support with the closing process and held our hands till the final signature was on the dotted line. He knows the area and pointed us in the right direction for all our ancillay needs (utilities, internet, insurance, mortgage, pool etc) including great places to eat when we were in town. Being more than 10 hrs from PC made things even more stressful. We could not have been in better hands than Kurt and his team at Legacy Premier Agency.
From 64 reviews overall

Tyler S Smith
Legacy Premier Agency LLC

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Bay County
1102/10625 Front Beach Road Panama City Beach
We had an outstanding experience working with Tyler. From day one, he was patient, knowledgeable, and truly invested in helping us find the right home. He communicated clearly, handled every detail with professionalism, and made the entire process smooth and stress‑free. We couldn’t have asked for a better partner in this journey. Highly recommend Tyler! We would work with him again in a heartbeat!!
816/5801 Thomas Drive Lower Grand Lagoon
Excellent communications and gave sound advice. First time I dealt with a short sale purchase and Tyler explained every step of the process, never failed to take my call or answer a question. Went above and beyond my excitations.
3910 Becora Ct Panama City
Tyler Smith was absolutely wonderful to work with. As first-time homebuyers in Florida, we had a lot of questions, and he made the entire process feel so much easier. He showed us what felt like dozens of houses at a time, always making time for us and helping us explore every possible option until we found the right one. He was available to answer our questions at all hours and was always cheerful, encouraging, and in good spirits. What really stood out was how much he helped us understand everything along the way, especially costs, estimates, and all the little details that can otherwise feel overwhelming, especially when buying a home in Florida for the first time. He made the process feel much smoother and less stressful. We are so grateful for his patience, dedication, and positive attitude, and we would highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy a home.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Bay County2026From 106 reviews overall

Christina Daniels
Keller Williams Success Realty
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Bay County
2603 Ashlee Way Lynn Haven
I have bought twice and sold one house with the help of Christina and her team. It is always an easy and smooth process when working with them. I highly recommend The Daniels team for any buying or selling process.