Jefferson County

Natural Bridge

Rental properties in Natural Bridge

Showing 1 - 21 of 61 properties

Sort by

Rented

West Carthage NY 13619

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Rented

West Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,200.00

128 North School Street

Carthage NY 13619

4

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Lisa Woodward Homes LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$1,400.00

650 West End Avenue

3

1

Townhouse

Listing courtesy of North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Show more detail >

For Rent

$1,600.00

Carthage NY 13619

3

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Rented

3

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Rented

West Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of NNY Homes Inc

Rented

Philadelphia NY 13673

4

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Matteson Property Management, LLC

Rented

Philadelphia NY 13673

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Matteson Property Management, LLC

Rented

North Mechanic Street

Carthage NY 13619

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Rented

North Jefferson Street

West Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Matteson Property Management, LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$1,400.00

37210 State Route 3

2

1

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Show more detail >

For Rent

$850.00

308/256 State Street

Carthage NY 13619

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Matteson Property Management, LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$850.00

306/256 State Street

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Matteson Property Management, LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$1,100.00

Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Rented

Carthage NY 13619

1

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Show more detail >

Pending

$1,150.00

534 West End Ave

Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Tenant Landlord Connection Inc.

Rented

Carthage NY 13619

4

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Rented

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of TLC Real Estate LLC

Show more detail >

For Rent

$1,150.00

10 North Main Street

West Carthage NY 13619

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Rented

South Mechanic Street

Carthage NY 13619

4

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Hometown Real Estate Services

1 - 21 of 61

View nearby Cities

Sales:: (619) 566-0008

Quick Links

© 2026 RateMyAgent

Terms & Conditions