Fire Island

Rental properties in Fire Island

Showing 85 - 105 of 582 properties

Sort by

For Rent

$3,195.00

85/85 Adams Way

Sayville NY 11782

2

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,415.00

126/234 River Avenue

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

West Sayville NY 11796

1

1

Other

Listing courtesy of Realty Connect USA L I Inc

Rented

Railroad Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

For Rent

$2,450.00

T06238/544 Terrace Road

Bayport NY 11705

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,100.00

4/40 Tyler Avenue

West Sayville NY 11796

1

1

Multi-Family

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker American Homes

For Rent

$2,850.00

317-6/317 Robinson Avenue

Patchogue NY 11772

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,715.00

F-5/198 Lakeland Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,405.00

2-5D/239 Lakeland Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,895.00

1-7B/219 Lakeland Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,550.00

9-32/32 Starboard Lane

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Bohemia NY 11716

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,390.00

161/250 River Avenue

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Smithtown Avenue

Bohemia NY 11716

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Sayville NY 11782

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of OverSouth LLC

Rented

Patchogue NY 11772

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Lakeland Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Realty Services

Rented

Lakeland Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,985.00

T18625/625 Terrace Road

Bayport NY 11705

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

85 - 105 of 582

View nearby Cities

Sales:: (619) 566-0008

Company

Brand Guidelines

Help & Learning

Product

Tracked Properties

Plans & Pricing

Community

Quick Links

© 2026 RateMyAgent

Terms & Conditions