Fire Island

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

Rental properties in Fire Island

Showing 43 - 63 of 613 properties

Sort by

For Rent

$3,005.00

100/100 Adams Way

Sayville NY 11782

2

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$3,195.00

67/67 Adams Way

Sayville NY 11782

2

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,875.00

82E/82 Easy Street

Sayville NY 11796

2

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,395.00

B06/74 Vernon Street

East Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

East Patchogue NY 11772

4

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of LAFFEY REAL ESTATE

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,625.00

24-B/16 Garfield Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$3,070.00

I5-505/505 Imperial Way

Bayport NY 11705

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,415.00

T10-420/420 Terrace Road

Bayport NY 11705

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,510.00

T08-323/323 Terrace Road

Bayport NY 11705

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,510.00

T03-141/141 Terrace Road

Bayport NY 11705

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

For Rent

$2,930.00

D2/333 Candee Avenue

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

Division Street

Patchogue NY 11772

2

1

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Cross Star Realty

Show more detail >

For Rent

$2,800.00

776 Montauk Highway

Bayport NY 11705

2

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of H & G Realty New York

Rented

Smithtown Avenue

Bohemia NY 11716

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

Bohemia NY 11716

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Rented

Bohemia NY 11716

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

Sayville NY 11782

1

1

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Fairfield Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

West 1st Street

Patchogue NY 11772

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties

Show more detail >

Rented

Division Street

Patchogue NY 11772

1

1

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Cross Star Realty

Show more detail >

Rented

Division Street

Patchogue NY 11772

2

2

2

Apartment

Listing courtesy of Cross Star Realty

43 - 63 of 613

View nearby Cities

Sales:: (619) 566-0008

Quick Links

© 2026 RateMyAgent

Terms & Conditions