Toby's profile

Toby's reviews

  5  
Toby has 31 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
over 4 years ago
Excellent experience all around

We've used Toby as both a Buyer's agent and a Seller's agent. In both cases, he was thorough, helpful, and always available. Our recent selling experience was in the crazy, frothy, market of 2021 and Toby's decisions on how to handle showings, offers, etc, worked great to minimize our stress and maximize our sales price. Worked out great. We had a similarly good experience buying. Toby knows the Colo Spgs market well, keeps up to date on the current market conditions, and is a good listener. Recommended!

almost 5 years ago
He was working hard for us the entire time

I called several realtors in the Springs/Southern Colorado area to help us purchase a home. And out of the several we talked with, Toby was an easy choice because he was the only one who spent more time asking us questions and listening than he did boasting his credentials. But his expertise was quickly evident through his knowledge of the local housing market. Throughout our entire home search he was always reachable when we needed him, even at inconvenient times. We really felt like he was working hard for us the entire time and wanted to see us . We also believe that his professional offer-writing expertise really made a difference in our offer being chosen. We had an unusually large amount of trouble throughout our contract-process with a variety of things. But he was our biggest support by communicating well with the seller’s realtor and others involved, always happy to answer any questions or worries we had, and he was quick and efficient with any paperwork we needed to sign. I can think of many more wonderful anecdotes from throughout our home-buying process, but I will end with this- Buying a home in a small mountain town was always my husband and my dream, but it seemed unattainable in this extremely competitive housing market. However, we are almost 2 weeks past closing on our beautiful house in Canon City, Colorado. And my family genuinely feels so lucky that we had Toby to help us through the whole process!

over 5 years ago
Talent, communication skills, and professionalism.

Toby has handled multiple real estate transactions for my family. Our most recent condominium sale was completed in days. He listed the property and provided professional photographs that resulted in same-day offer above our asking price.We highly recommend Toby because of his talent, communication skills, and professionalism.

over 5 years ago
He’ll immediately earn your implicit trust

As an active duty military member, I discovered Toby 11 years ago after arriving for a new assignment— his tremendous experience, initiative, and personal care was invaluable to me on the journey to finding and purchasing the perfect mountain home. 11 years later as a retired veteran, Toby was my one and only choice in selecting a Realtor to sell the same home. Integrity, unparalleled initiative, and a genuine caring demeanor capture Toby’s hallmark qualities -- he’ll immediately earn your implicit trust for buying or selling your home!

about 6 years ago
We could not recommend him more highly!

Toby helped our non-profit organization sell donated land, and it turned out to be a complicated and challenging sale. We were very impressed with Toby's knowledge, tenacity, positivity, reliability, calm demeanor and kindness throughout the the entire process. We could not recommend him more highly!

about 6 years ago
Toby assisted every step of the way

Toby did a wonderful job helping me buy my new home and sell my old home. Toby assisted every step of the way, from helping me find and close on my new dream home to getting my old home on the market and through the sale. Toby was very professional, responsive, and tuned-in to my objectives. The home-buying and selling process can be somewhat daunting. And, as a very busy professional, I had limited time to devote to the process. Thankfully, Toby made the entire process quite easy, simple, and understandable. In short, I highly recommend Toby to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

over 6 years ago
He provided thoughtful and valuable information

Toby guided us through the sale of our home and the purchase of our new one. He provided thoughtful and valuable information to us that allowed us to get the maximum price on the sale of our old home and the best value on the purchase of our new one.

over 7 years ago
Toby is a pro

Moving to a new state is daunting. Toby showed my wife and I around Colorado Springs and explained the history of the area. He helped us navigate purchasing a home while we were out of state and assisted with any of our requests. Toby is a pro. And very personable.

almost 8 years ago
Toby is from the area and knows the market in Southern Colorado.

We would definitely recommend choosing Toby as your realtor. Toby is from the area and knows the market in Southern Colorado. He responded to all of our questions immediately and was able to make the home selling process less stressful. We wouldn't hesitate to use him again.

almost 8 years ago
With Toby's help, I was able to get my property for below asking price.

Toby is amazing! I recently purchased my third property and have not had luck in the past with realtors. Toby was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. He always responded quickly to my questions/demands. With Toby's help, I was able to get my property for below asking price. He was always very professional and made sure I was happy. I would definitely recommend Toby and will be using him again as I expand my real estate portfolio.

about 8 years ago
Toby is amazing! I recently purchased my third property

Toby is amazing! I recently purchased my third property and have not had luck in the past with realtors. Toby was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. He always responded quickly to my questions/demands. With Toby's help, I was able to get my property for below asking price. He was always very professional and made sure I was happy. I would definitely recommend Toby and will be using him again as I expand my real estate portfolio.

13 - 24 of 31
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent