Susan LaGrotta

Susan LaGrotta

Realtor: 3055286
  •   5   (15 reviews)

About Susan

Susan LaGrotta Resident and property owner on Marco Island since 1997 2003-Present Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Realtor Retired NYPD Detective, Member in good standing Education:-College of Staten Island Early Childhood Education S.U.N.Y Empire State College Human Services N.Y. S. Ombudsperson N.Y.P.D. Police Academy Graduate Awards:- 2004-2020 Leading Edge; Honor Society, Presidents Circle Berkshire Hathaway Home Services NYPD Honor Legion Inductee 1990-2000 Town of Islip, Long Island New York-2000 Volunteer of the Year Youth Enrichment Services Chairperson/Board Member, Volunteer Member Designations:- Marco Island Specialist Designation BHHS Luxury Collection Specialist Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist/Million Dollar Guild Certified International Property Specialist Marco Island Area Association of Realtors Leadership Development Graduate RRC Residential Real Estate Council SRES Senior Real Estate Specialist E-Pro/E-Certified/1031 Exchange CDPE Certified Distressed Property Expert SFR Short Sale Foreclosure Resource Memberships: NAR/FAR/MIAABOR/NABOR Marco Island Chamber of Commerce Marco Island Police Foundation NYPD Retired Detectives Association Volunteerism: 2005 to Present Friends of Tigertail Board of Directors/Current President/ Stewardship Committee Chairperson and Past Secretary 2012 to present Calusa Garden Club Member of Marco Island past Vice President and past Secretary 2009 to present Stewardship Chairperson of the Calusa Park Butterfly Committee 2005 to 2019 City of Marco Island Beautification Advisory Committee, Member and Former Chairperson Marco Island Area Association of Realtors Professional Development Committee, Past Co-Chairperson Marco Island Center for the Arts Clay Guild, Founding Member Naples Botanical Garden Member Special Interests and Hobbies:- Gardening, Boating, Power and Sail/Aviation-Pottery/Tennis/Reading/Cooking Donations: Sunshine Kids Helping Kids with Cancer, for each and every transaction.

Susan's reviews

  5  
Susan has 15 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 6.
Review Susan
8 months ago
Marco Island Expert

We found Susan through a mutual acquaintance and hit it off instantly. Susan is amazing to work with! She is knowledgeable, attentive, responsive, amazing attention to detail and is always looking out for the best interests of her clients. The best thing about Susan is that you don’t feel like you are working with an agent at all. You feel like family. My husband and I couldn’t have asked for a better person to help us find our perfect little piece of paradise! We would recommend using her to anyone!

12 months ago
A Consumate Professional

Susan was with us every step of the way, handling so many of the little bumps in the road on our way to completing our purchase. Her advice, including recommendations for things such as inspectors and other necessary trades-people, was invaluable. I highly recommend her.

over 1 year ago
Amazing experience

Right away upon meeting Susan we knew it was a good fit for our family. She is the perfect mixture of experience, patience and warmth making us feel completely at ease throughout this time with her as our agent. We were relocating our 4 kids to Florida from NY and it wasn’t easy! Working with Susan made that aspect of the move seamless. I cannot recommend Susan enough to any family or anyone looking to move to Marco Island or the surrounding areas. She is an amazing realtor with complete knowledge of every step of this process. A+++++++

over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable Professional

Having a well respected knowledgeable professional representing you in a market you have little experience with is a must! Susan came highly recommended from a friend on Marco Island and I am glad I went with her. She has lived on Marco Island for 25 plus years and is well versed in the local market. From island climate dynamics to who the people are that you need to know to get things done, she makes you feel confident that a first time Florida buyer will be successful. Susan stayed in close contact throughout the buying process and returned calls and text promptly. I highly recommend Susan to anyone in search of property on Marco and especially those who need a little hand holding buying their first home on the island.

over 1 year ago
Susan LaGrotta is an excellent real estate agent and an even better friend!

We worked with Susan LaGrotta last year in December and purchased a condo. Susan was patient with us in our search and gave us a lot of good advice. She pointed out pitfalls to watch for in the Florida market and guided us on inspections, closing costs, and explained the buying process thoroughly for the Florida market as we own our primary residence in another state. Not only did Susan sell us our condo but she has become our friend. A year later Susan still calls us just to say hello. She even followed up a year later to make sure we were comfortable with the property tax process. We consider Susan our friend and highly recommend her to anyone in search of a property in the Southwest Florida market of Marco Island.

almost 2 years ago
Susan did a great job

Susan was a great agent to work with. We had the house on the market and moved away and Susan was at our house checking on it several times a week even when we did not have a showing. She communicated well and went above and beyond what you expect from an agent. We are very happy.

Show all 15 reviews

Susan's properties

Susan has 11 properties for sale and sold 4 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldFeb 20, 2026
$999,000
1404/840 South Collier Boulevard
Marco Island FL 34145
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Re/Max Affinity Plus and BHHS Florida Realty
SoldDec 12, 2025
$475,000
1971 Harbor Lane
Naples FL 34104
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BHHS Florida Realty and John R Wood Properties
SoldSep 5, 2025
$1,175,000
138 North Barfield Drive
Marco Island FL 34145
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BHHS Florida Realty
For Sale
$849,000
110/991 North Barfield Drive
Marco Island FL 34145
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of BHHS Florida Realty
Show all 15 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent