Stacey's profile

Stacey's reviews

  5  
Stacey has 79 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Stacey's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, trustworthy, well-prepared, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Best Agent Ever!!
9 months ago
Best Agent Ever!!

Stacey stayed on top of every aspect of this sale, was able to answer all questions, and helped to keep our stress level to a minimum. She knows what she’s doing!

Seller review
Great realtor who knows the market!
10 months ago
Great realtor who knows the market!

We had the pleasure of working with Stacey to sell our home, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. From start to finish, she was professional, responsive, and incredibly knowledgeable. Stacey guided us through every step of the process—from pricing the home competitively to photos, marketing, and negotiations. Thanks to her expertise, our house sold quickly, and the entire transaction went smoothly. What we appreciated most was her communication—she kept us informed at every stage and was always available to answer our questions. It really made what can be a stressful process feel manageable and even enjoyable. If you’re looking to buy or sell a home, we highly recommend Stacey. You’ll be in great hands!

Seller review
Expertise and Professionalism. That's Stacey.
11 months ago
Expertise and Professionalism. That's Stacey.

I have bought and sold dozens of homes in my life, so I feel like I am more than qualified to render an opinion about real estate agents. Stacey, was quite exceptional, honestly. Even though I renovated the property very nicely, it had a lot going against it, in particular it was a manufactured home in a rural location. In other words, it was a very challenging sale. The buyers' lender had a large number of demands and issues that required resolution. Stacey was hands on and guided the sale forward even when it looked like all was doomed. She managed not only my expectations, but those of the other party and their agent as well. Honestly, some of the issues became so challenging, like those relating to structural engineering inspections and modifications, I am certain a large proportion of other agents would have simply given up and let the deal fold. Not only did Stacey manage the pressure, she had good people, contacts and networks to utilize in order to keep everything on track. In the end, it was a 3 month escrow. Stacey never complained or lost her perspective. She was always honest and plain-spoken and did not sugar coat the issues. She deserves all the good praise that the other reviewers have sent her way.

Buyer review
Got us into our dream home!
12 months ago
Got us into our dream home!

Stacey has been absolutely wonderful to work with. She is very knowledgeable about the area which was helpful as we were moving from out of town. She was honest with us every step of the way, easy to get ahold of, timely in sending paperwork to sign, and we truly felt she was on our side from day one. She made sure that we found the right home to accommodate our family including our daughter that uses a wheelchair and even our dogs. We are so thankful and highly recommend Stacey to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Seller review
Readily available & supportive
about 1 year ago
Readily available & supportive

Stacey made it all happen, with ease, swiftly assisting us to both sell our home & coordinate a purchase closing within 24 hours. She was readily available for our calls and inquiries & super supportive.

Buyer review
Experienced and professional
over 1 year ago
Experienced and professional

Working with Stacey to purchase our house was a great experience. She was always quick to respond to our questions. She had great advice throughout. Even after close of escrow she continued to be available to answer questions we had about potential remodeling we are thinking of doing. The whole process went very smoothly due to her professionalism and experience in negotiating. We highly recommend working with her!

Seller review
Review for Stacey Mattina
over 1 year ago
Review for Stacey Mattina

My sister and I recently had to sell my mom’s house during probate. From the very beginning, Stacey demonstrated exceptional professionalism, dedication, expertise and compassion for our situation. Stacey took the time to understand our needs and provided invaluable advice on how to prepare my mother’s home for the market. Her knowledge of the local market trends ensured that mom’s house was priced competitively and showcased beautifully and was quickly sold. Throughout the entire process, Stacey was responsive and communicative. She kept us informed at every step, making a stressful experience feel manageable. My sister and I would recommend Stacey as she is a professional and a pleasure to work with!

Seller review
Amazing agent!
over 1 year ago
Amazing agent!

I cannot imagine having a more knowledgeable, thorough, faster-acting agent than Stacey. She sold my property in less than 2 weeks in a challenging market. There were multiple offers. With Stacey’s excellent guidance, I selected the offer that made most sense to me. During this process of negotiation, Stacey was always straight-forward as to why some offers were valid and others should be avoided. She was respectful throughout, but never hesitant with what needed to be said and/or discussed. If I ever need an agent in the future, Stacey absolutely will be my choice. I recommend her without any doubt or hesitation. G

Seller review
Outstanding results on the sale of our home!
over 1 year ago
Outstanding results on the sale of our home!

We were very impressed with the results Stacey Mattina delivered as our Seller Agent. Stacey exceeded all expectations with her professionalism, proactive communications and personal involvement through every step of the process. Stacey displayed an excellent sales strategy and an understanding of the Lake County market from our initial conversations, listing, sale and closing. Most importantly, the sale resulted in an offer higher than our expectations. Stacey has a great team of stagers, electricians, painters and handy persons that made the selling of our out of area vacation home an easy experience. We highly recommend anyone thinking of selling in Lake County to meet with Stacey as you will be impressed too!

Buyer review
Experienced and Knowledgeable Realtor
over 1 year ago
Experienced and Knowledgeable Realtor

Stacey is extremely knowledgeable about Lake County properties and the real estate process. She has solid network of related contacts including mortgage brokers, escrow agents, home inspectors, locksmiths etc. She is responsive and has good suggestions for resolving any conflicts or barriers. Stacey is well respected in community.

Seller review
Outstanding
over 1 year ago
Outstanding

Very professional smart l would highly recommend anyone that needs a realtor to give her a call

Seller review
Knowledgeable, professional, skilled
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable, professional, skilled

Stacey Mattina was right on as far as appraisal; she had excellent cleaning staff to call on, and the knowledge and skill as how to best show property. Stacey was also very good at reassuring me about the progress of the sale and escrow — keeping me current in status of sale.

13 - 24 of 79
© 2026 RateMyAgent