Stacey's profile

Stacey's reviews

  5  
Stacey has 81 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Stacey's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, friendly, supportive, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Professional, Knowledgeable, and Supportive Every Step of the Way!
11 days ago
Professional, Knowledgeable, and Supportive Every Step of the Way!

This is the kind of experience first-time homebuyers dream of! Stacey made the entire home-buying process very seamless, enjoyable, and far far less intimidating than we expected. From the start, she took the time to explain what to expect, explained each step, and was upfront about any potential challenges that we might encounter. As first-time homebuyers, this level of guidance and transparency was incredibly reassuring. Stacey was also very professional in every interaction while also making the process feel welcoming and enjoyable. She always made sure our questions were answered and that we understood exactly where we were in the process. She was very responsive and flexible with communication methods and adapted to what worked best for us. She did an excellent job coordinating with our lender and the seller's representative, helping keep everything moving forward. We started our home search feeling completely overwhelmed and intimidated about navigating this process, but thanks to Stacey, it turned out to be a memorable and rewarding experience! We couldn't be more grateful for her guidance, knowledge, and support. We highly recommend Stacey, for anyone looking to buy (or sell) a home! - Victor Fernandez

Seller review
Stacey proved to be knowledgeable, honest, trustworthy, and reliable.
2 months ago
Stacey proved to be knowledgeable, honest, trustworthy, and reliable.

Stacey's perspective on current market conditions and her subsequent marketing plan proposal were insightful and spot on. Since I live in the bay area, it was reassuring to know that Stacey was there every step of the way to make sure the pre-showing tasks were completed. Negotiations with the buyers and her diligent oversight and hard work made the entire process seem effortless for me. Thank you Stacey!

Seller review
This is the fourth home we have had Stacey sell for us! She’s so good, we will hire her again!
4 months ago
This is the fourth home we have had Stacey sell for us! She’s so good, we will hire her again!

Stacey knows the business so well I trust her with all our real estate needs. From the evaluation of your property for listing price, to pictures taken for listing, to advertising, to showing the home, to negotiations when an offer comes in, and to final closing of escrow needs, she is all over it! And, in the world we live in today, I find her honestly so refreshing! You have a property to sell? Stacey is the Real Estate Rock Star!

Seller review
Extremely knowledgeable, made the process very easy
4 months ago
Extremely knowledgeable, made the process very easy

Stacey knows the Lake County market very well and was able to price the property fairly so that it sold quickly. We had many questions about how to prepare the house for sale in terms of improvements that may add value vs. leaving alone to allow the buyer to choose and she provided excellent advice. She expertly guided us through the sales process and kept us informed at all times. I strongly recommend Stacey for your real estate needs.

Seller review
Stacey, AKA “The Closer” is Amazing!
4 months ago
Stacey, AKA “The Closer” is Amazing!

When we decided to sell our second home in Kelseyville, we searched for an agent who we felt we could work with and get our property sold quickly and at fair market value. Stacey delivered. Stacey is experienced and very knowledgeable of the real estate market in Lake County. She gave us great advice on how to prepare our property prior to listing it and was easy to work with. Stacy is a great communicator and kept us informed throughout the sales process. She always responded to our texts and calls promptly. When we hit bumps during the escrow process, Stacy was creative and always came up with solutions to get the deal closed. We just can’t speak highly enough of her professionalism and ability to get the job done. Highly recommend Stacy if you’re planning on selling or purchasing a property in Lake County.

Seller review
Overall Experience was great!
5 months ago
Overall Experience was great!

We had an outstanding experience with our Stacey. From start to finish, she was professional, responsive, knowledgeable, and fully committed to getting our home sold. She guided us through every step of the process, communicated clearly, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable. Her expertise and dedication truly showed, and we were very pleased with the outcome. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Seller review
Great Experience
8 months ago
Great Experience

Stacey Mattina did a great job handling the sale of our home at 316 Robin Hill Dr. She has strong market knowledge, gave clear and practical advice, and communicated well throughout the process. We always knew where things stood and what the next steps were. Stacey was professional, responsive, and easy to work with from listing through closing. I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

Buyer review
Highly Professional & Knowledgeable
8 months ago
Highly Professional & Knowledgeable

Stacey is an excellent agent who understood what I was looking for and kept me abreast of changes on properties I was considering. She helped me navigate the buying process and has a wealth of connections for handymen, painters, electricians or any tradesmen you may want to enlist. She also followed up to make sure everything was going smoothly once I had purchased.

Seller review
Top notch in every way. Accessible, knowledgeable, professional & accurate.
8 months ago
Top notch in every way. Accessible, knowledgeable, professional & accurate.

Stacey was very easy to work with. She knew the area, the market, and was knowledgeable about best practices and how to proceed at each step. Her professionalism was excellent. She returned calls promptly and kept me informed each step of the way. She directed me through the paper process and answered my many questions. I highly recommend Stacey as your agent. She's the best!

Buyer review
A Smooth and Transparent Land Purchase Thanks to Stacey
9 months ago
A Smooth and Transparent Land Purchase Thanks to Stacey

I recently completed a land purchase in Kelseyville, CA, and working with Stacey Mattina was outstanding. She represented both sides with complete fairness and transparency, was very responsive throughout the entire process, and guided me carefully through the disclosure phase. Stacey provided detailed HOA information—including building guidelines, bylaws, and direct contacts—and coordinated escrow flawlessly with a dependable title company. She never rushed me and gave me all the time I needed to make an informed decision. I highly recommend Stacey to anyone buying or selling in Lake County.

Seller review
Great and experienced
11 months ago
Great and experienced

Stacey did a great job getting me nearly asking price on my home when the market wasn’t great. Exceeded my expectations

1 - 12 of 81
© 2026 RateMyAgent