Shelli's profile

Shelli's reviews

  5  
Shelli has 28 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelli's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing to work with!
6 months ago
Amazing to work with!

Shelli was so great to work with. She listened to what we wanted and really took the time and effort to find houses that fit our wants and needs. She also went above and beyond finding out past history and any information that could affect our decision about the homes we looked at. She always made us feel super comfortable and we would recommend her to anyone.

Buyer review
Terrific experience
6 months ago
Terrific experience

Shelli is the best out there. She got us every single thing we asked for from the seller. Everything was super smooth and couldn’t have asked for a better experience.

Seller review
Better than the rest
11 months ago
Better than the rest

Shelli wasn't just knowledgeable and professional but has a since of humor and fun to work with. She will shoot you strait and won't over list your property just to get the listing.

Buyer review
Work with Shelli!
11 months ago
Work with Shelli!

Shelli was great to work with! She made everything incredibly easy.

Buyer review
A true gem
12 months ago
A true gem

Shelli was outstanding to work with! Her knowledge of the market, area, and houses truly gave us ease during a very stressful time. We were doing a cross country move with a toddler and pregnant so stress was extremely high and timeline was critical. Shelli was always available to us and would preview homes for us to ensure our time was being well spent. Her negotiation and communication skills were impeccable. I truly cannot articulate how lucky we were to work with Shelli and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy.

Buyer review
Shelli was truly a gem! We were doing a cross country move with a 20 month old and pregnant so stres
12 months ago
Shelli was truly a gem! We were doing a cross country move with a 20 month old and pregnant so stres

Shelli was truly a gem! We were doing a cross country move with a 20 month old and pregnant so stress was high and timeline was crucial. Shelli was always quick to schedule showings for us when houses became available (bought during a wildly competitive market) but would also preview homes for us to help weed through options and ensure our time was being spent in the right places. She was always available to us and went above and beyond. Her knowledge of the market and area also helped us feel confident in our decisions and ultimate purchase. I truly cannot put into words how wonderful it was working with her and would recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy!

Seller review
Easy to work with
12 months ago
Easy to work with

Shelli was great to work with and went above and beyond for the whole process. I highly recommend using her and plan to use her again in the future.

Seller review
Excellent Service
12 months ago
Excellent Service

Shelli was timely with responses, provided thorough marketing materials, and scheduled opened houses timely. She knows the area well and was knowledgeable about realistic prices. Quick folow up with feedback from showing and after open house. I would definitely use Shelli again.

Seller review
Appreciated Shelli’s positive, prepared attitude.
12 months ago
Appreciated Shelli’s positive, prepared attitude.

I was not looking forward to selling my home. Shelli understood this and made it easier than anticipated. It sold fast! My family and I highly recommend her.

Buyer review
Realtor Extraordinaire
12 months ago
Realtor Extraordinaire

Shelli Jaye is a Realtor extraordinaire. I met her when looking online at Overland Park homes as I considered moving to be near my daughter, husband and future granddaughter. I saw a townhome I liked and Shelli was the listing agent. We exchanged emails for weeks, as I was living in Colorado and not able to visit Kansas right away. In the meantime, that townhome sold. Shelli sent me many listings for homes and townhomes and I chose some to see when I visited Kansas. Unfortunately, none were what I really wanted. Shelli and I talked more about my wishes and she continued to send listings. A villa was listed that backed to the “woods”, and I love trees and the privacy of such a location. Shelli said it was one of her favorite neighborhoods, and I trusted that opinion since she’s lived in the area for years. Without seeing the home in person, I made an offer for over the listing price and got the home a day after it was listed. Shelli did Facetime previews of the home with me and she set up many contractors including a home inspector, and workers to install new flooring, paint the entire interior, install new lighting, hardware, plumbing, etc. She was a blessing with all this help since I was still living in Colorado and trying to sell my home. Shelli coordinated the workers, and visited the house many times to check on things. This was above and beyond typical realtor duties. Shelli knows the area, knows real estate, HVAC units, and many aspects of a home for sale. She is smart, knowledgeable, helpful, always available, patient with many questions, full of great advice on homes, financing, insurance, etc. She volunteers and is a real asset to the community and real estate market. Working with Shelli was wonderful!

Buyer review
Shelli is the best in the business!
12 months ago
Shelli is the best in the business!

I told Shelli exactly what I was looking for and she set me up with viewings. The house I bought was actually down the street from a different how I viewed, but she saw it online and asked if I wanted to check it. Thank goodness she had her eyes peeled because this house is just what I wanted. She worked with both the seller and my buyer's agent to get me in this house! Her follow-up and follow-thru are superb! Don't even think about going with someone else! Shelli does it all and will work for you until you get what you want! 5 Stars all day long!!!!

Seller review
None Better
12 months ago
None Better

Shelli, you are the best agent we could have wished for. Your warm, personal, professional, caring touch made our "adventure" most rewarding, not to mention the extra hard work and sacrifices you made. We will cherish our relationship with you forever. Thank you for being the best and we will cherish our relationship forever. Aloha, Denny & Patti Denny & Patti We will cherish our relationship forever.

13 - 24 of 28
© 2026 RateMyAgent