Shelli's profile

Shelli's reviews

  5  
Shelli has 28 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelli's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent  job!
12 days ago
Excellent job!

She did an excellent job helping us sell our house. She was professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and very helpful throughout the entire process. She made everything easier and guided us through each step. We really appreciated her hard work and dedication, and we would gladly recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

Buyer review
Shelli is amazing!!
12 days ago
Shelli is amazing!!

She is always responsive in a timely manner - usually right away. She has so much knowledge of the business and is willing to share it. She listened to all of my angst about buying and selling a house. Her advice was crucial for us to be able to buy our house because there were many offers. It was a great experience.

Seller review
Best Agent for the job
21 days ago
Best Agent for the job

I am so grateful to Shelli Jaye for helping my family sell our property. We ran into a few unexpected hurdles during the process, but she helped us handling everything with complete professionalism, expert problem-solving skills, and absolute grace. She truly went above and beyond to get our home sold. Thank you, Shelli Jaye, for your hard work and outstanding dedication! God Bless you!!!

Seller review
No better realtor in KC!
about 1 month ago
No better realtor in KC!

Shelli Jaye provides personalized service that is beyond reproach. She is extremely knowledgeable in all aspects of real estate transactions. She is savvy in her negotiation tactics and will protect your best interests financially and emotionally. She is even skilled at assessing potential issues with the structural or mechanical integrity of a house, to help you avoid buying into one that could have costly problems in the long run. Shelli is tireless in her dedication to your home buying/selling needs and will always respond quickly to calls, messages, and questions. She is patient when you are unsure, and will stick with you to the end even if you decide to postpone buying a home. Shelli will forever be my go-to agent for Kansas City area real estate needs.

Seller review
AMAZING Realtor
about 2 months ago
AMAZING Realtor

I was referred to Shelli Jay in 2020. I wanted a house in Shawnee, KS that was turn key. Day one, Shelli set me up to look at three houses. I told her the important things I had to have: fence, no projects and good neighborhood. From that moment, Shelli was on a mission to find me exactly what I had requested. In 2025, I lost my husband and it was time to move on. I called the one I could depend on, Shelli. She sold my home immediately and found me my forever home that I never thought I would be blessed to own. This amazing woman is hard working and the best realtor that I or anyone could work with. Plain and simple - Shelli Jaye is the BEST!

Seller review
It was truly a pleasure working with Shelli.
2 months ago
It was truly a pleasure working with Shelli.

Shelli went over and beyond with taking care of the sale of our property. Her knowledge and expertise is top tier and a true real estate professional. Many thanks.

Seller review
Very professional and knowledgeable of the area
3 months ago
Very professional and knowledgeable of the area

Shelli communicated often during the entire process. She knows the market well and was so very pleasant to work with. She has a great personality and was knowledgeable on who, what, and where to get answers. She listened and worked with us, and if issues arose, she knew how to negotiate our wishes and get it done. I would recommend her to anyone ready to buy or sell a home. She was awesome!!

Buyer review
I could not have done this without Shelli!
3 months ago
I could not have done this without Shelli!

Shelli is such a joy to work with. I was very nervous to make this leap but she gained my trust very quickly. She is very diligent and always had my best interest at heart. Shelli communicates extremely well and always responds quickly! She is a great realtor and I will never use any one else. I highly suggest using her!

Seller review
Wonderful experience!
4 months ago
Wonderful experience!

I have worked with Shelli on a few house purchases and sales and the experience has been fantastic throughout. From knowing expectations, understanding documents, to staging spaces the attention to detail was unwavered. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Highly Responsive Agent
4 months ago
Highly Responsive Agent

Couldn’t be happier with how everything transpired. Shelli’s knowledge and communication are top notch for sure. She listens and goes above and beyond for her clients. I would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a house.

Seller review
Shelli Jaye is the best!
5 months ago
Shelli Jaye is the best!

Shelli truly works for her clients. Her communication, follow up and follow through are outstanding. She is a true advocate for your best interests. The process from start to finish was very smooth.

Seller review
Repeating Excellence through Experience
6 months ago
Repeating Excellence through Experience

Shelli and Kylie were showing a home that we decided we were not interested in, however personality wise we clicked and asked them to be on the look out for one with our preference. As a buyers agent, they quickly identified a home we might like and negotiated and orchestrated our purchase. Six months later, we were accepted into a senior community and we asked Shelli & Kylie to sell the home we had just purchased. That sale also went smoothly and professionally. When negotiating these sums of money, it is important to trust the ones handling the negotiations, and that is Shelli and Kylie. Responsiveness, integrity, trust and communicative are just some of the words I think of regarding these two sales professionals. I have already referred them to family and friends for their home needs.

1 - 12 of 28
© 2026 RateMyAgent