Sheila's profile

Sheila's reviews

  5  
Sheila has 43 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sheila's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, trustworthy, honest, clear communication, friendly, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
She was a port in the storm
over 3 years ago
She was a port in the storm

Sheila is a phenomenal agent. She is extremely knowledgable about the unique Yellow-Springs market and helped us navigate our transaction from a distance which can be incredibly complicated. She was our boots on the ground when we needed them ... and we needed them quite often. Sheila came into our sale during a very difficult time for our family and handled every step with sensitivity, grace and professionalism. As first-time sellers, we are extremely grateful for her help and guidance.

Seller review
Sheila is extremely knowledgeable and responsive
over 3 years ago
Sheila is extremely knowledgeable and responsive

Sheila is extremely knowledgeable and responsive. She was with us every step of the way helping to get quotes for repairs, advising about staging, and answering all our other questions as they came up. We were out of state so she stepped in the handle things that might have been otherwise very complicated to do long distance. She was a joy to work with and very professional .

Seller review
Excellent and knowledgeable service
over 3 years ago
Excellent and knowledgeable service

Sheila was an excellent resource as we were selling our house. She was able to help us stage the property, helped find contractors/repair people to get work done and quotes to move the process along quickly. She is responsive and very helpful. We were selling from out of state and she was able to step in when we weren’t able to be around to make thing go smoothly. She is a joy to work with and very professionally. I would definitely recommend her.

Seller review
Great serve, couldn't ask for better service
over 3 years ago
Great serve, couldn't ask for better service

Property list and had an offer the same day. Closing was seamless. Probably the easiest transaction I have ever had. Highly recommend.

Buyer review
Sheila was recommended to us by family
over 3 years ago
Sheila was recommended to us by family

Sheila was recommended to us by family. She was a great realtor, very accommodating to our quick turnaround time, and very helpful through our process of obtaining a loan.

Buyer review
Personable,͏ knowledgeable, super helpful!
My home buying experience was delightful! I felt really t
over 3 years ago
Personable,͏ knowledgeable, super helpful! My home buying experience was delightful! I felt really t

Personable,͏ knowledgeable, super helpful! My home buying experience was delightful! I felt really taken care of by Sheila, as she took the time to address every question and concern with care and sincerity. I found the perfect fit for me here in Yellow Springs, and she validated it with a unique experience of not just making sure the process was smooth and pain-free, but also made me feel welcome into the community. It's exactly the experience I was hoping for, and I would 100% recommend Dunphy Real Estate!

Buyer review
Personable, knowledgeable, super helpful!
over 3 years ago
Personable, knowledgeable, super helpful!

My home buying experience was delightful! I felt really taken care of by Sheila, as she took the time to address every question and concern with care and sincerity. I found the perfect fit for me here in Yellow Springs, and she validated it with a unique experience of not just making sure the process was smooth and pain-free, but also made me feel welcome into the community. It's exactly the experience I was hoping for, and I would 100% recommend Dunphy Real Estate!

Seller review
Excellent realtor to work with!!
almost 4 years ago
Excellent realtor to work with!!

We have purchased and sold with Shelia Selling a house is no easy feat but she makes the process so simple! Very thorough & knowledgeable about the market. Highly recommend her if you're looking to buy or sell a home!

Buyer review
Wonderful service
almost 4 years ago
Wonderful service

Sheila Dunphy was so helpful and professional, checking in with us to see if we had everything we needed.

Buyer review
Best realtor hands down!
almost 4 years ago
Best realtor hands down!

Shiela knows real estate process so well I always felt in the best hands! She helped with entire process and guided me even after closure!! Professionalism and expertise..that’s Shiela and Dunphy Realty!!

Seller review
Long͏ Distance Sale Sheila͏ was great to work with
almost 4 years ago
Long͏ Distance Sale Sheila͏ was great to work with

Long͏ Distance Sale Sheila͏ was great to work with. Because of various circumstances, it took us an extended period to time to list the house. Sheila was always there helping us out and giving advice. She has an extensive knowledge of the real estate market in the area and gave us sound advice. She connected us with reputable service providers to help get the house ready and since we were out-of-state Sheila even made a few trips to the house to check on repairs. 10/10, would recommend.

13 - 24 of 43
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent