Sheila's profile

Sheila's reviews

  5  
Sheila has 43 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sheila's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, trustworthy, honest, clear communication, friendly, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The Best YSO has to Offer
about 2 years ago
The Best YSO has to Offer

Dunphy Real Estate has served us in every realty transaction we have been a part of since we decided to move to this community; she and Jo are unparalleled in their knowledge of this area’s real estate. They have always been fair, hardworking and a lot of fun . I’d recommend Dunphy Realty to anyone!

Buyer review
The best agent I've ever worked with...
about 2 years ago
The best agent I've ever worked with...

I have bought and sold several homes and interacted with many great agents and Sheila Dunphy is at the top of the list. She was professional, responsive and went above and beyond in making sure all went well with our home purchase. During the search process, she was fair and objective without inserting her own opinions unless asked. Once it was time to make an offer, she was efficient and handled all details. During the inspection period, she scheduled appointments and met with service people to oversee repairs, while communicating updates regularly. I whole heartedly recommend Sheila Dunphy.

Buyer review
Excellent Realtor
almost 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor

Professional, knowledgeable, on top of all the details, kept the process moving in a friendly way. Great experience!

Seller review
Fast and Effective
almost 3 years ago
Fast and Effective

We worked with Sheila to sell our home in Yellow Springs. Given that our house was unique to the area, Sheila was the only realtor we talked to that was willing to look past the comps when setting the price. We sold our house quickly (4 days!) and got full asking. She kept us informed during the entire process through closing. She was easy to work with and we would recommend her to anyone buying or selling in the area!

Buyer review
Great experience securing our home!
almost 3 years ago
Great experience securing our home!

Sheila was extremely communicative, fast response time and answered all of our questions for our second home purchase. Easy to work with and has deep knowledge of the village and area. Also gives helpful recommendations for vendors and companies. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Professional Awesome Realtor
almost 3 years ago
Professional Awesome Realtor

We immensely recommend Sheila as your prospective Realtor. Sheila has a wealth of knowledge to offer. We appreciate deeply her guidance in selling our Home.

Seller review
Careful help during a most difficult transition
about 3 years ago
Careful help during a most difficult transition

Because of some unforeseen health difficulties, our downsizing, cleaning out, and selling house after 55 years of marriage became very difficult. But Sheila’s professional contacts and market knowledge meant that our house sold immediately. Then, she helped with locating painters, movers, haulers and shepherded us through all the financial aspects of the sale. Every question was answered promptly, and her personal warmth did a lot to ease our worries.

Seller review
Sheila͏ Dunphy is the best real estate agent we have ever worked for!
We would give Sheila a million
over 3 years ago
Sheila͏ Dunphy is the best real estate agent we have ever worked for! We would give Sheila a million

Sheila͏ Dunphy is the best real estate agent we have ever worked for! We would give Sheila a million stars if we could. She was and is the best real estate agent we have ever worked with. She helped us find our current home quickly and helped us close on it super fast. Then she helped us sell our house in less than a week or so on the market. Sheila bridged the gap beautifully between us and the sellers of our new house and also of the buyers of our old house. She stayed in contact with us at all times, keeping us up to date whenever anything came up. It seemed like she worked around the clock at times and never rested. Whenever we had questions she was there with a quick reply and help. Sheila is the most knowledgeable and professional agent but she is also super sweet, funny and caring. Working with Sheila is like working with a good friend. She made our experiences as fun, enjoyable, and low stress as buying and selling homes could ever be. We wholeheartedly recommend Sheila Dunphy if you are looking for a real estate agent! And when the time comes we will definitely work with her again! Thank you Sheila for making our buying and selling experiences with you the best ever!!!

Seller review
Sheila Dunphy is the best real estate agent we have ever worked for!
over 3 years ago
Sheila Dunphy is the best real estate agent we have ever worked for!

We would give Sheila a million stars if we could. She was and is the best real estate agent we have ever worked with. She helped us find our current home quickly and helped us close on it super fast. Then she helped us sell our house in less than a week or so on the market. Sheila bridged the gap beautifully between us and the sellers of our new house and also of the buyers of our old house. She stayed in contact with us at all times, keeping us up to date whenever anything came up. It seemed like she worked around the clock at times and never rested. Whenever we had questions she was there with a quick reply and help. Sheila is the most knowledgeable and professional agent but she is also super sweet, funny and caring. Working with Sheila is like working with a good friend. She made our experiences as fun, enjoyable, and low stress as buying and selling homes could ever be. We wholeheartedly recommend Sheila Dunphy if you are looking for a real estate agent! And when the time comes we will definitely work with her again! Thank you Sheila for making our buying and selling experiences with you the best ever!!!

Seller review
The agent you can depend on
over 3 years ago
The agent you can depend on

I have to relocate and need to sell the property remotely. I couldn't imagine how i can get it done without Sheila's help. She was available anytime during the process and went the extra mile to help me get things ready. Being the local agent, she knew the market well and had tried different ways to find the right buyer for me. It took a long time to sell due to the market change and the repairment but she was consistently active and patient. I would recommand her if you want to buy or sell in this area.

Seller review
She͏ was a port in the storm
Sheila is a phenomenal agent
over 3 years ago
She͏ was a port in the storm Sheila is a phenomenal agent

She͏ was a port in the storm Sheila is a phenomenal agent. She is extremely knowledgable about the unique Yellow-Springs market and helped us navigate our transaction from a distance which can be incredibly complicated. She was our boots on the ground when we needed them ... and we needed them quite often. Sheila came into our sale during a very difficult time for our family and handled every step with sensitivity, grace and professionalism. As first-time sellers, we are extremely grateful for her help and guidance.

1 - 12 of 43
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent