Shay's profile

Shay's reviews

  5  
Shay has 17 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Highly Recommend
over 3 years ago
Highly Recommend

Shay was great to work with. He was patient with us while deciding the best time ti place our house on the market. He was honest in setting expectations. Shay is a great communicator and made the process go smoothly. He worked hard and always responded to our calls and texts promptly. We highly reccomend Shay and his lovely assistant.

Seller review
Best experience ever
over 3 years ago
Best experience ever

I’m out of town nearly 200 days a year and despite this, Shay worked around the clock to make sure my house was sold and taken care of in a timely manner! Often times I was in a very different time zone and Shay would stay up ridiculously late just so we could chat on the phone and hammer out details. Additionally, when things came up where traditionally I would have to be at the property- he took it upon himself to be there and ensure all was well! I certainly don’t have enough good things to say about Mr. Schultz

Seller review
Selling a house can be stress free
about 4 years ago
Selling a house can be stress free

It was truly a delightful and stress free experience working with Shay selling my mother’s house. His advice seems to be well informed and he has a very good understanding of our market. Most of all though he is a man of very high integrity. You can trust him to always have your best interests in mind. Should I ever be engaged in the real estate market again, I will definitely call Shay.

Seller review
Best Agent I have ever worked with!
over 4 years ago
Best Agent I have ever worked with!

I was amazed and extremely satisfied with Shay’s service. He was proactive, kept me informed, very quick to respond. He was very helpful with a repair issue I was having. I feel he brought me top dollar for my property. I have been involved in several purchases throughout the years with full fee agents, never have I had service even close to what Shay provided.

Seller review
He isn't just good; he's terrific
over 4 years ago
He isn't just good; he's terrific

Competing agents will always try to scare you, of course, by telling you that if you select an agent who charges a lower commission than they do you then you will get terrible service. This isn't just self-serving nonsense; it is dishonest and false, and Shay Schultz is the living proof. I interviewed five or six agents and selected him to help me with the sale of my house. A very smart decision. He was available, responsive and helpful. He actually listened to me. A rare quality among self-important sales agents. He listened to and respected my opinions and priorities. Not everyone does that. His good character, honesty and integrity were abundantly in evidence. That matters to me. Finally I must tell you that at one meeting he apologized for bringing along his baby daughter. Apologize? She is the most delightful little girl. Be sure to insist he bring her along when you interview him. As you absolutely should. I saved thousands on commissions and he helped me sell my home even above the listing price, which I never at all expected. One little warning though. If you work with Shay, you may discover that you have made a friend for life.

13 - 17 of 17
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent