Scott's profile

Scott's reviews

  5  
Scott has 45 reviewsacross 34 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Scott's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, supportive, friendly, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Selling my parents home
10 months ago
Selling my parents home

Scott was an incredible resource for my family. Our parents moved into their dream home, over 28 years ago. Sadly, they both passed away and after a number of upgrades. My two brothers and I contacted Scott. Scott was gracious with us concerning the passing of our parents. His communication was the best and we were kept in the loop on everything. His diligence and professionalism resulted in the sell of the home with three days, and the sell netted an increase of the asking price.

Seller review
Professional, knowledgeable, resourceful, helpful, more than you could expect.
about 1 year ago
Professional, knowledgeable, resourceful, helpful, more than you could expect.

This is not the first time I have worked with Scott and it will not be the last. Scott and his team were incredible through the entire process. Providing suggestions prior to going on the market, teams to prepare the property, stage the property and help when I was not available to be at the property. Scott’s communication, his resources bad entire team created a very seamless process that ended in a successful and timely closing. Scott and his entire team are the best to work with.

Seller review
Best ever!
about 1 year ago
Best ever!

Scott helped us buy and sell our first home, and was a delight with both experiences. He has been a resource and stayed in contact with us aside from business transactions, and we are so grateful to have him! Highly recommend to anyone.

Buyer review
Excellent Experience...Again!
about 1 year ago
Excellent Experience...Again!

This is our second time buying a house with Scott. He goes above and beyond and ensures we're informed before making a decision. He is never pushy and always wants to make sure we're happy and comfortable with the house we choose. He has great recommendations for service providers too.

Buyer review
Scott is amazing!
about 1 year ago
Scott is amazing!

Scott was an amazing realtor and helped us through our first home purchase. He made the experience so much smoother than it otherwise would have been! He also knows everyone in town it seems like and was able to help connect us with everyone we need during and even after purchasing our home.

Buyer review
Best Realtor to Have On Your Side
over 1 year ago
Best Realtor to Have On Your Side

Scott is in a class of his own. He is everything we needed and more! He was the first name recommended to us by a family member who worked with the realtor's association, and I understand why! He took care of the entire process and was there with us every step of the way--offering advice, encouragement, explanation, and fantastic options for to consider as our new family home. He printed up booklets for every showing with pictures, info, price comparisons, etc.--this made it way easier for us to keep everything straight and have all the information on hand so we could make a well-informed decision. He made us feel like we were his primary concern and made himself available immediately either by phone, text, or to take us on showings ASAP when we found something interesting. He recommended his own favorite inspector and demonstrated his fantastic judgement with the professionalism, experience, and thoroughness of said inspector. He was able to help us not just find a home, but a new way of life, and we are absolutely in love with the new adventure we have started together in this new place. He is honest, dependable, professional, and now even a friend. We never felt overwhelmed or alone, and he made what is usually a pretty difficult and busy process pretty seamless and even exciting! My husband and I are even more in love after going through this process together and I think that speaks volumes to how hard Scott shouldered the burden and anxieties for us! Scott has decades of experience in Colorado, is VP of the realtor association, and is involved in advocating for everyday people involved in buying/selling at the capitol. Scott took on a lot for us--he made us feel supported and I really believe he has a joy and passion for his job that most people would admire.

Seller review
Best Realtor to Have On Your Side
over 1 year ago
Best Realtor to Have On Your Side

Scott is in a class of his own. He is everything we needed and more! He took care of the entire process and was there with us every step of the way--offering advice, encouragement, explanation, helped set up staging, arranged for an amazing photographer (even booked us for twilight shots!). He presented our home stunningly--labeled areas of the home we had updated or wanted to highlight, set up very clear and professional flyers for people to take, set out a handwritten list of things our family personally loved about the home. He suggested a "coming soon campaign" and I'm so grateful we trusted him because our listing and photos got so many view and saves during that week that we had showings booked as soon as we went live and we had a contract signed the next day. He is honest, dependable, professional, and now even a friend. We never felt overwhelmed or alone, and he made what is usually a pretty difficult and busy process pretty seamless and even exciting. Scott has decades of experience in Colorado, is VP of the realtor association, and is involved in advocating for everyday people involved in buying/selling at the capitol. Scott took on a lot for us--he made us feel supported and I really believe he has a joy and passion for his job that most people would admire.

Seller review
Top agent for your real estate needs.
over 1 year ago
Top agent for your real estate needs.

Working with Scott was a wonderful experience. He’s truly a professional, highly experienced agent that handles everything from pricing and marketing, to negotiations, and all the small details in between. His communication skills are second to none. Selling our home couldn’t have gone smoother, and I highly recommend Scott for anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Incredible performance, legendary professionalism
over 1 year ago
Incredible performance, legendary professionalism

I’ve worked with Scott on 3 home purchases in the past 6 years. I trust him completely and value his professionalism and friendship. Scott is a true, classic professional, an amazing listener, and a patient soul that makes the home buying and selling process efficient and memorable.

Seller review
Scott was knowledgeable in all aspects of the Real Estate profession!
almost 2 years ago
Scott was knowledgeable in all aspects of the Real Estate profession!

We could not have sold our home without Scott being so knowledgeable in his real estate field. Even though our home closing had some problems Scott was always with us working these issues out with great communication and professionalism. We completely trusted him with advising us and when he needed additional answers he would go to great lengths to find a solution. Our home sold on time and allowed us to move forward in our new adventure because of Scott . Sheri & Dennis

Seller review
Scott did an EXCELLENT job in selling my home!!!!
almost 2 years ago
Scott did an EXCELLENT job in selling my home!!!!

Scott did an EXCELLENT job in selling my home. He is very professional, knowledgeable, and has excellent follow-through. For any problem that came up, Scott used his resources in a very timely manner to resolve the issue. Scott kept me up-to-date on the day-by-day process and status of selling my home and getting ready for the closing. I would GREATLY RECOMMEND Scott Mathias to be your broker to sell your home. Scott has over 30 years of experience in selling homes and I have used him about 5 times over the past 25 years in selling and buying my home because I know that I can trust him in obtaining the best price for my home and of taking care of any problems or issues that may arise. Scott did a job WELL DONE again for me in selling my home!

Buyer review
Best experience as a first time buyer
almost 2 years ago
Best experience as a first time buyer

Scott really helped me with breaking everything down and making it more simple. Had answers to all my questions and was very quick to ask the other realator questions if I had any concerns. Overall Scott was the best!

13 - 24 of 45
© 2026 RateMyAgent