Scott's profile

Scott's reviews

  5  
Scott has 53 reviewsacross 39 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Scott's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, dedicated, friendly, responsive, reliable, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Hands Down the Best Realtor in Colorado
9 months ago
Hands Down the Best Realtor in Colorado

Scott is truly exceptional at what he does. This is our second time working with him, and I couldn’t recommend him more. He’s incredibly detail-oriented, communicative, organized, and deeply knowledgeable about the market and on top of that, just a great guy. We’ve worked with him on both the buying and selling sides and had outstanding experiences each time. He successfully sold our condo despite several challenging factors, and he handled everything flawlessly. Hands down the best realtor in Colorado.

Seller review
Exceptional
9 months ago
Exceptional

We’ve had the pleasure of working with Scott and his team for the past 16 years. Throughout this time, Scott has consistently gone above and beyond to help us buy and sell four different homes. He treats us like family rather than just clients, and his friendly and professional demeanor makes him an excellent choice for anyone looking to buy or sell a home. I highly recommend Scott and his team for their exceptional service and knowledge.

Buyer review
Great experience, made things easy
11 months ago
Great experience, made things easy

I've known Scott for a long time and when I went to pick a realtor it was a no brainer. He helped every step of the way and for a first time homebuyer, made the process less daunting than I thought it was going to be. Expedient in getting appointments setup and made sure that we were always in the know.

Seller review
Exceptional and Results-Driven
about 1 year ago
Exceptional and Results-Driven

Scott is an exceptional real estate professional whose expertise proved invaluable throughout the sale of my condo. His greatest value was demonstrated when the buyer's financing collapsed unexpectedly just prior to closing. Scott immediately leveraged his professional network to secure alternative financing for the buyer. His sense of urgency saved the transaction, demonstrating a commitment far exceeding the standard expectation of a listing agent. I highly recommend him to any client seeking a competent, results-driven real estate partner.

Seller review
Scott Mattheis review
about 1 year ago
Scott Mattheis review

Excellent communication- great knowledge of current market. Quick sale within 31 days of listing.

Seller review
Great experience selling with Scott
about 1 year ago
Great experience selling with Scott

Scott has done this a time or two and his market knowledge shows that. Very professional and communication was great throughout the process.

Seller review
Top-Notch Professional
about 1 year ago
Top-Notch Professional

Scott has represented my family on several transactions over the years. I've been involved in numerous real estate transactions personally and professionally. Scott is the most professional and effective residential agent I've come across. His process is efficient yet well thought-out and individualized. He has the experience to anticipate and solve any problem. He's a great communicator and makes you feel like you're his only client.

Buyer review
Fantastic Experience!
over 1 year ago
Fantastic Experience!

We were able to find and close quickly on the perfect house for our family. Scott was very knowledgeable and took the time and patience to make sure we had all the information we needed and answered any questions every step of the way. I would highly recommend to our friends, family, and anyone looking for a house in the area!

Seller review
Selling my parents home
over 1 year ago
Selling my parents home

Scott was an incredible resource for my family. Our parents moved into their dream home, over 28 years ago. Sadly, they both passed away and after a number of upgrades. My two brothers and I contacted Scott. Scott was gracious with us concerning the passing of our parents. His communication was the best and we were kept in the loop on everything. His diligence and professionalism resulted in the sell of the home with three days, and the sell netted an increase of the asking price.

Seller review
Professional, knowledgeable, resourceful, helpful, more than you could expect.
over 1 year ago
Professional, knowledgeable, resourceful, helpful, more than you could expect.

This is not the first time I have worked with Scott and it will not be the last. Scott and his team were incredible through the entire process. Providing suggestions prior to going on the market, teams to prepare the property, stage the property and help when I was not available to be at the property. Scott’s communication, his resources bad entire team created a very seamless process that ended in a successful and timely closing. Scott and his entire team are the best to work with.

Seller review
Best ever!
over 1 year ago
Best ever!

Scott helped us buy and sell our first home, and was a delight with both experiences. He has been a resource and stayed in contact with us aside from business transactions, and we are so grateful to have him! Highly recommend to anyone.

Buyer review
Excellent Experience...Again!
over 1 year ago
Excellent Experience...Again!

This is our second time buying a house with Scott. He goes above and beyond and ensures we're informed before making a decision. He is never pushy and always wants to make sure we're happy and comfortable with the house we choose. He has great recommendations for service providers too.

13 - 24 of 53
© 2026 RateMyAgent