Sarah McGonagle

Sarah McGonagle

  •   5   (3 reviews)
Sarah McGonagle

Are you Sarah McGonagle?

Claim your profile now and showcase your client service excellence.

About Sarah

Sarah is a Real Estate Agent at Realty ONE Group Landmark | Natrona Heights. They have 3 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 2 active property listings and 9 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $2,159,250.

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 3 reviewsacross 1 different locations, showing 3.
Review Sarah
Seller review
If you are looking for a competent, service...
almost 6 years ago
If you are looking for a competent, service...

If you are looking for a competent, service oriented, master of real estate, SARAH IS THE ONE! This is the second time Sarah has represented my wife and I. First time was in early 2016 when we purchased our first home. We sold that house and purchased our new home under her guidance. Sarah quickly understood what we were looking for in a new home and always kept us top of mind as inventory in our area, combined with our specific needs, limited our options. However, once the property we eventually purchased came available, she was able to get us in to tour right away. The purchase was an EXTREMELY competitive situation and also a foreclosure. Her knowledge, experience and expertise is the only reason we were able to purchase the home and feel comfortable with the process of purchasing a bank owned property. She knew our budget, market values and renovation costs and guided us to be the highest offer (1 of 6) by a $750 margin. Throughout the closing, she was always on top of what was needed when buying a bank owned property. On the selling side, her marketing process and industry know how led us to multiple offers above asking price. What is even more impressive is that this was done in the midst of the COVID-19 shut down. Again, under her guidance and expertise, she led us to this decision by creating a defined, reasonable process for success when there was a lot of uncertainty. My wife and I would 100% recommend Sarah to anyone looking to buy or sell, turn-key or fixer-upper, moving in from out of market, etc. She is an expert in her craft.

Seller review
If you are looking for a competent, service...
almost 6 years ago
If you are looking for a competent, service...

If you are looking for a competent, service oriented, master of real estate, SARAH IS THE ONE! This is the second time Sarah has represented my wife and I. First time was in early 2016 when we purchased our first home. We sold that house and purchased our new home under her guidance. Sarah quickly understood what we were looking for in a new home and always kept us top of mind as inventory in our area, combined with our specific needs, limited our options. However, once the property we eventually purchased came available, she was able to get us in to tour right away. The purchase was an EXTREMELY competitive situation and also a foreclosure. Her knowledge, experience and expertise is the only reason we were able to purchase the home and feel comfortable with the process of purchasing a bank owned property. She knew our budget, market values and renovation costs and guided us to be the highest offer (1 of 6) by a $750 margin. Throughout the closing, she was always on top of what was needed when buying a bank owned property. On the selling side, her marketing process and industry know how led us to multiple offers above asking price. What is even more impressive is that this was done in the midst of the COVID-19 shut down. Again, under her guidance and expertise, she led us to this decision by creating a defined, reasonable process for success when there was a lot of uncertainty. My wife and I would 100% recommend Sarah to anyone looking to buy or sell, turn-key or fixer-upper, moving in from out of market, etc. She is an expert in her craft.

Seller review
If you are looking for a competent, service...
almost 6 years ago
If you are looking for a competent, service...

If you are looking for a competent, service oriented, master of real estate, SARAH IS THE ONE! This is the second time Sarah has represented my wife and I. First time was in early 2016 when we purchased our first home. We sold that house and purchased our new home under her guidance. Sarah quickly understood what we were looking for in a new home and always kept us top of mind as inventory in our area, combined with our specific needs, limited our options. However, once the property we eventually purchased came available, she was able to get us in to tour right away. The purchase was an EXTREMELY competitive situation and also a foreclosure. Her knowledge, experience and expertise is the only reason we were able to purchase the home and feel comfortable with the process of purchasing a bank owned property. She knew our budget, market values and renovation costs and guided us to be the highest offer (1 of 6) by a $750 margin. Throughout the closing, she was always on top of what was needed when buying a bank owned property. On the selling side, her marketing process and industry know how led us to multiple offers above asking price. What is even more impressive is that this was done in the midst of the COVID-19 shut down. Again, under her guidance and expertise, she led us to this decision by creating a defined, reasonable process for success when there was a lot of uncertainty. My wife and I would 100% recommend Sarah to anyone looking to buy or sell, turn-key or fixer-upper, moving in from out of market, etc. She is an expert in her craft.

Sarah's properties

Sarah has 2 properties for sale and sold 9 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 1, 2026
$72,750
371 Main Street
Leechburg PA 15656
4
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REALTY ONE GROUP LANDMARK
SoldFeb 6, 2026
$22,000
126 Lincoln Avenue
Leechburg PA 15656
2
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Infinity and REALTY ONE GROUP LANDMARK
SoldOct 9, 2025
$53,000
405 2nd Avenue
Hyde Park PA 15641
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REALTY ONE GROUP LANDMARK
SoldSep 17, 2025
$400,000
209 Bon Air Avenue
Pittsburgh PA 15210
5
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REALTY ONE GROUP LANDMARK and Re/Max Select Realty
Show all 11 properties

Browse nearby locations

This individual or business has not claimed this profile. Even though this profile is on RateMyAgent, this does not mean they endorse the site, is associated with the site, or confirms the listings or sales data information which we display about them, or any other publicly available information, to be accurate in any way. Read more

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent