Sarah McCandless

Sarah McCandless

REALTOR® Salesperson / Sales Agent
  •   5   (57 reviews)

About Sarah

A Naples native and an experienced agent, handling real estate transactions for over a decade, Sarah works hard for her clients to make the buying and selling process as stress free as possible. For Sellers she’s there for showings, inspections, appraisals and balancing the schedule so homeowners can both continue their lives and prepare for their next move. For Buyers, she’s able to listen to their needs, procure the property that fits their exact needs and walk them through the process to meet their goal of becoming a homeowner. In her free time, you’ll find Sarah with her family, at home on their 15 acre farm, surrounded by a menagerie of animals, including a goofy pair of German Shorthaired Pointers, a herd of sheep, some miniature cows, one very adorable little pony and a miniature donkey …just to name a few! As an avid equestrian and animal lover, Sarah is the prefect agent to handle sales of large acreage parcels or farm properties. “My love for the outdoors and my knowledge of the area makes it fun to sell in Golden Gate Estates. It’s so diverse. If you need room for a building to house a classic car collection or pasture space for your animals, you’ll find it in the Estates. The area has grown in leaps and bounds the last several years for that exact reason, there’s something for everyone here.” With a passion for helping others, you can be confident you’re making the right decision buying or selling a home with Sarah.

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 57 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sarah
24 days ago
An agent that is beyond exceptional in so many ways!

Sarah really knows her stuff! I went from not even being in the market for a new home to seeing one of her listings and immediately falling in love with it. From that moment on, Sarah made the entire process feel manageable and smooth. She communicated quickly, worked around my crazy schedule to get a showing lined up, and somehow were able to close in just 30 days! Even when potential hiccups arose, Sarah was always prepared. Not only communicating with the Sellers; she also provided me with a list of trusted contacts and resources to make sure everything kept moving and nothing fell through the cracks. Sarah also helped me find a lender who was able to guide me through the bridge loan process, a huge help in this spur of the moment decision to make a dream a reality! Her knowledge went beyond simply buying and selling a home — she was able to explain important differences and potential issues between a wood-frame home and a CBS home, and she gave me a clear timeline of what needed to happen and when. Now, Sarah is helping me sell my old house, and I couldn’t be more grateful to have her in my corner! I’ve known Sarah personally for many years, and while I never imagined I’d eventually use her as my real estate agent, I’m so thankful that I did. Throughout the entire process, as a Naples Native agent, she has been knowledgeable, responsive, organized, and trustworthy. Most importantly, I know I can rely on her experience and expertise, and that peace of mind has been invaluable. If you’re looking for someone who truly knows Naples, the real estate business, and will be there for you from start to finish, I whole heartedly recommend Sarah!!

25 days ago
Attentive, available, and right agent

Sarah listed and sold our property, and we couldn't have asked for better. This wasn't a standard Naples listing. Four-plus acres, fenced and cross-fenced, a chicken coop, and shop building — a place for someone who wanted land and animals, not just a house. That narrows the buyer pool considerably, and Sarah understood that from the first conversation. She never tried to sell it as something it wasn't. She was available for every question we had, no matter how small, and we never felt like we were bothering her. She was also present at every showing to make sure the property was secured afterward. With animals on the place, gates left open isn't a small thing, and she never once let that slip. That told us she was paying attention to what mattered to us, not just to the sale. In the end she found the right buyer. If you have an property and you're worried the average agent won't know what to do with it, call Sarah.

3 months ago
Wonderful Agent

Sarah McCandless is a wonderful agent when selling your home and helping to answer questions when purchasing a new one that is out of the immediate area. Sarah answers her phone calls and if she is unable to gets back promptly on the phone. She is a great communicator and kept us up to date on everything and if not on the phone via text. ( as there are a zillion questions) She was understanding of the emotional aspect of a selling a home you love and provided guidance with the nervousness of fear with buying a new one. Sarah never acted like we were a burden/bothersome. She always cheerful even when we knew she had a busy day. We found her to be very knowledgeable and went beyond the basics. She made to process easier to handle. Overall outstanding..

4 months ago
Excellent Communication & Seamless Experience

Sarah was amazing to work with. Her communication was excellent throughout the entire process, and she made everything feel smooth and stress-free. She was always available, kept me informed, and truly went above and beyond to help with my home sale. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated and professional agent.

4 months ago
EXCELLENT

We have used Sarah 4 to 5 times. Sales and purchases she always does perfect. Would highly recommend her.

Show all 57 reviews

Sarah's properties

Sarah has 13 properties for sale and sold 14 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$850,000
3271 7th Avenue Northwest
Naples FL 34120
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
For Sale
$365,000
2618 Helen Place
Lehigh Acres FL 33971
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
SoldSep 3, 2026
$650,000
2210 20th Ave NE
Naples FL 34120
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Equity Realty
Pending
$275,000
930 24th Ave NE
Naples FL 34120
Land
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
Show all 27 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent